Based on 176 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
9 E Federal St, Middleburg, VA 20117
Phone: (540) 687-8880
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Nicole Adams
I was traveling through the area when I got a craving for pizza. I got a slice of cheese pizza from Teddy’s and had a life changing experience. The pizza here is by far the best pizza that I have ever eaten! The sauce to cheese ratio is perfect!!
… more
Charlie H
You really can’t beat Teddy’s for an authentic, homey, hole-in-the-wall NY pizza experience. Teddy is second to none on pizza knowledge and passion. His product is the result of his experience and enthusiasm for a great pie. Crispy crust of perfect thickness, vibrant house-made sauce, and the perfect amount of cheese and oil. While Teddy’s earns its stripes on the merits of the cheese pizza alone, they’ll gladly accommodate a topping and offer many. Granted, if your topping choices are of the Hawaiian persuasion, they may accommodate you reluctantly with the wit and sass of NY pizza vets. We came looking for great pizza but left with a laugh, an experience, hospitality, and fun memories from chatting the counter up while we waited. We will be back.
… more
Justin Nguyen
Drove all the way to Middleburg to try Teddy’s (the things you do for food…) and it did not disappoint. While the restaurant is fairly small, it easily accommodated my family and I.
… more
April Sullivan
Teddy’s is the BEST pizza I’ve had anywhere including NYC! The crust is airy and crispy without being over cooked. It’s the perfect crust! The sauce is flavorful and tastes authentic and homemade. The cheese is delicious! It’s not salty and it’s packed with so much flavor. The best part was the impeccable service! Teddy does it all right and really puts others businesses to shame. I can’t and won’t go anywhere else now. I am making the trip to middleburg, again today just for teddys pizza. You must try Teddy’s Pizza! You won’t be disappointed! Thank you so much Teddy & Family!!!
… more
Ronnie Mendiola
Best pizza I’ve had to date! The dough is perfect and light. The garlic flavor is incredible but not over bearing. All the ingredients are top notch and the cheese so hot and gooey!!!! Teddy and Family are great people with tremendous heart and character.
… more
P D (PDiddy)
When visiting Middleburg, VA for shopping or equestrian tournament, go to Teddy’s Pizza & Subs for a bite. Teddy’s is the best NY pizza in the 20 miles radius. We had pizza brackets during pandemic. Teddy’s came on top.
… more
Wise Guy
Great pizza, great service, made with fresh ingredients. Looking for excellent NY style pizza this is the place!!
… more
Jesse Edenhart
Stopped by here as I was in the area. Best Pizza and Cheesesteak I’ve had in a long time. Teddy, the owner, is also fun to talk to. Definitely going here again.
… more
Raymond Hovanec
Fantastic pizza with fresh ingredients and is exactly what you would expect out of a New York style pizza. The salad and homemade Italian dressing is always crisp and fresh. The family is friendly and a lot of fun to talk to while waiting. Teddy and Anthony always have jokes. Absolutely my favorite pizza.
… more
Robert Topa
It’s a great tucked away pizza place one block off the Main Street (rt 50) Family owned Pizza place that takes pride in their food they serve. Unfortunately not always opened. Teddy likes to travel. But we’ll worth the wait.
… more
… View more