Based on 78 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
2 S Main St, New London, OH 44851
Phone: (419) 929-8179
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 4–11 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Lloyd Colegrove
Righteous Pizza place on Main Street in New London Ohio. I have to admit that it’s the only place to find food in town on a quiet Tuesday night unless you want to do takeout. But the people are friendly, the Pizza was fine and the chicken wings wonderfully crispy beneath the spicy bar-b-que sauce. And in north central Ohio they had Corona! Was better than we expected, prior to walking into the place, but we quickly shelved our out-of-towner skepticism and were pleasantly surprised.
… more
Mary Jo Hammer
Great food, friendly staff, quick service.
… more
Jody Hurd
What a great little place! Oh, the people there were so friendly & like I had known them forever! They were behind the counter but interactive with us while we ate in the dining area. Large portion sizes & good food! I love finding places like this in a town I’ve never been to.
… more
Stephanie Perrin
So good that I didn’t think about taking a photo until it was half done. But prices are good; the owner, Mike, and the employee, Kirsten, were both fantastic; and my barbecue chicken bacon and pineapple pizza tasted zingy and sweet!!!
… more
Chantal Vanbuhler
So online it says you have to choose light or extra cheese thin or double crust which extra and double cost more btw BUT you dont have to choose either just skip it for normal crust and cheese. Also their alfredo was done with spaghetti noodles it didn’t look as good as it tasted ! Over all good food
… more
Rob S
Absolute S show. Order delivered was wrong. Wanted to charge me extra money to deliver the order I put in? Really? No. People go somewhere else. Not like New Londoners have a lot of options but seriously. Go to subway. That or bring the Fritz’s back. Oh add money for double crust? Nope. You guys gals need to figure this business model out. Also the online prices are wrong. Last chance for me. Had issues in the past but pretty much done. I tried.
… more
Lynn Caskey
I had the BEST salad ever there this week. Im so excited to be giving my review,and empressed by everything I have had from the Pizza house.
… more
Teresa Workman
Ordered chicken, not good. I also ordered a side of cole slaw….it was NOT edible. Sorry
… more
Kody Miller
Called at 6:20 said 1 hour for a large cheese pizza.
… more
Alaina Singh
I definitely recommend Joe’s fries: hand cut fries, rolled in 2 kinds of cheese after frying with real bacon
… more
… View more