Based on 363 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
Address:
1218 Jericho Turnpike, New Hyde Park, NY 11040
Phone: (516) 492-3195
Website: http://www.oldetradingpost.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jacqueline Vita
Looking for a fun night out? Come on down to the Olde Trading Post! The bar draws a crowd as does the two dining rooms. And when the band strolls in more folks hustle in to dance, so it fast becomes a hot time at the Olde Trading Post tonight! Televisions display sporting events so if you aren’t into the music you can catch your favorite game. And some just come for the food. Luckily, it is all good as comfort food favorites abound. Their burgers, sandwiches, and wraps are delicious. Their entrees are tasty too! We brought a crowd of 20, so we worked a package out ahead of time for passed appetizers and drinks. It was well worth it. Food wise we enjoyed Swedish Meatballs, Chicken Quesadilla, Cheese Pizza, Risotto Balls, Mini Burger Sliders and BBQ Chicken on Skewers.
… more
Nick Datt
We had burgers and fries in the back room. Food and service were pretty good. If you like singing, dancing, etc they have live bands playing the weekend nights. Beer on tap was a bit expensive. $7 for a blue moon tap. They have a board advertising all the beer specials but didn’t realize the fine print you have to get those at the bar only.
… more
Jennifer Hannafey
This was our second time here. The first time was just to feel the place out and we had a every expensive beer at the bar. 8 bucks for a domestic beer is crazy. Even if it’s a craft. This isn’t Manhattan. Tonight, was a little better. We sat outside with comfy chairs and fire pits! There was only waitress for like 15 packed tables. By our waitress was super personable and sweet. Once the cried died down we have a nice conversation. I want to say her name was Reynah but I might be wrong. We had cocktails and appetizers. I had a so-so “bleeding sunset” with vodka and blood orange juice with a Prosecco float. My friends had the golden margarita,which was a silver at best. And the hubs had a Stella. We order the mixed platter that came with slightly better than average wings, mozzarella sticks and potato skins. The skins were the best thing, with smoked bacon. I got a tasty French onion soup that was really cheesey and the bread was still a little crunchy. The only complaint was the thyme sprig branch things still in there. My friend got the lava cake, which was meh. They just opened so they are working out their whole thing. The place was popping for a Tuesday night. They definitely needed more staff. But all and all a solid 4star evening.
… more
Greg Woo
Great food, great prices, and great service. The place is immaculate. Had a fabulous steak sandwich. I would definitely come back.
… more
Tracey Cholakis
I hosted a baby shower for my sister, The decor of their party room is modern rustic, I only added mason jars with flowers and it looked beautiful. They offer great (and many) options for their catering package, the food was fantastic from the appetizers to the main course and desert!! No one was disappointed or left hungry!!! The service was great, very attentive and helpful! My sister loved everything, she and I still are getting compliments about how great it was. A month later my husband and I went for dinner, again another great meal ! Finally the location is great and convenient.
… more
Victoria M
Went yesterday for the first time, loved it. Our waitress Kristin was so sweet and helpful. The food came out quick, everything was delicious. I went with my 12 year old daughter so I was skeptical to go in, thinking it might not be a place for her. I was wrong. We chose to eat outside and just loved it all. Will definitely be going back.
… more
Jim Boniello
A great outdoor dining experience. They have plenty of space in their fenced in courtyard to handle the reopening protocols correctly.
… more
Peg Dunleavy
My father and I are regulars here, the servers are wonderful. The food is good. They just did some renovations in the kitchen to add more variety to their menu. Sadly and very disappointed they are making all credit card customers pay more, I understand why they may have to do that BUT instead of giving their customers a choice or heads up on paying cash which would save you money they just put a notice in with your increased credit card bill.. Not a super big deal but it put a sour taste in my mouth.. Tell your patrons what’s happening. Don’t make a change and m
… more
tom “DJ Google” king
Positives: outside garden seating is excellent. Everything is new
… more
Laura Lacorte
Went on Taco and Trivia Tuesday. Seemed like a nice crowd. We didn’t have the taco special but many others did and it looked great! We didn’t partake in the Trivia either but we plan on going back and will join in then. My veggie burger was excellent and my honey enjoyed his burger. Service was a little slow but very pleasant. I would recommend.
… more
… View more