Savory Sweet Eatery Menu – Monticello, NY

Type : Restaurant

Location : Monticello, NY

No bathroom, sorry! Please take care of business before joining us.
Independent Latina/Dominican-owned restaurant specializing in gourmet burgers, fresh chicken, children’s meals, and custom international coffees.

Everything is MADE FROM SCRATCH UPON ORDER.

We are known for our daily-fresh-ground burgers, mac & cheese, and fresh treats like croissant muffins, cookie sandwiches, bundt cake, and more! There are also power bowl salads for the health conscious.

Check out our menu on DoorDash! One half-hour before closing, DoorDash will stop taking orders.

Reserve a table on TableAgent (link on SavoryAndAntonia dot com)
Lunch/dinner served all day.
Non-alcoholic drinks on premises.
Afternoon tea (reservation only).
Supper clubs coming soon!

Based on 59 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Savory Sweet Eatery 12701

Address:
452 Broadway suite 3, Monticello, NY 12701

Phone: (845) 770-4335

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 11:30 AM–8:30 PM
Thursday 11:30 AM–8:30 PM
Friday 11:30 AM–9 PM
Saturday 11:30 AM–9 PM
Sunday 11:30 AM–6:30 PM
Monday Closed

Menu

Stuffed Burgers
Mom Stuffed Burger
Stuffed grilled onions, mix cheese, bacon, Mom’s BBQ sauce, and a fried egg.
$8.95
Inferno Stuffed Burger
Stuffed mix hot chilies, pepper jack cheese, and ghost BBQ sauce.
$8.95
Sides
Homemade Chips $2.50
Hot Dog $3.00
Deluxe Bowl
Classic Banana Split
Scoops of vanilla, chocolate and strawberry ice cream, fresh banana, and topped with chocolate, strawberry and pineapple sauce, crushed nuts, and whipped cream.
$5.75
Chunky Monkey
Vanilla ice cream, fresh banana, chocolate chips and chocolate sauce.
$5.75
Soda Fountain
Manhattan Egg Cream Seltzer
Milk and vanilla syrup.
$2.75
Monticello Egg Cream Seltzer
Milk and dark chocolate syrup.
$2.75
Milk Shakes
Shaking Bacon
Vanilla ice cream, crispy bacon, maple syrup, and more bacon.
$4.75
Oreo Cookie
Vanilla ice cream, chocolate syrup and crushed Oreo.
$4.75

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reservations: tableagent.com

Reviews

Justine E
Highly recommend all vegans visit this spot on their trip through the Catskills. We got the vegan chicken noodle soup with the bread bowl which was perfect for the fall/winter weather outside. The soup was delicious and good portion. We also got 2 vegan chicken sandwiches. For starters, the vegan chick’n patty is homemade in store and the BEST we’ve ever had. We travel often and have tried many Chick’n patty’s, but this is the best by far. It tastes like real chicken (even better actually). I want to say this in the kindest way possible because I truly mean these are the best we’ve had, but the sandwiches were a bit over spiced. These sandwiches are the real deal and so flavorful on their own. They don’t need all that sauce on the sandwich because the flavor is so amazing on its own. Next time I would request no seasoning/sauce on my sandwich because we enjoyed the sandwich so much just as it is. The sauce just takes away some of the beautiful flavors that the awesome cook created! Can’t wait to return to this spot on our next trip.

… more

Rebecca M
SO glad we found this gem! As a vegan traveling with friends it can be hard to find food for EVERYONE. You often wind up eating lettuce and tomatoes while your friends have steaks burgers pastas and more. Well, Savory Sweet Eatery has everyone covered and is DELICIOUS. The vegan options are awesome and you aren’t up charged because you are vegan. The owner is SO lovely and accommodating. I can’t wait to try more on my trip back upstate. If you are plant based or even just want to support an amazing small business, EAT HERE.

… more

Shevez Freeman
Hands down the Best Burger and Service I’ve had! The owner and chef is Amazing and she’s a true chef. Everything is made so fresh! The burgers are huge and freshly ground! As my fiancé says the seasoning is in the burgers and not just on them. The food was flavorful and juicy! We live an hour away and will definitely be returning even if only for the food. Visit this place now; you won’t regret it! So happy to support such an amazing Black-Owned Business.

… more

Mermaid Lu
First time trying this place . I was craving macaroni and cheese since a few days but they was closed Monday and Tuesday . But finally it’s Wednesday and got me this delicious macaroni and cheese with chicken and roasted tomatoes . Omg so delicious like real southern food . The cake was delicious as well . You want home style food please give this place a try you won’t be disappointed. I gotta say one of the best foods I’ve tasted out of Monticello ny

… more

Bennet Meyers-Im
This is an absolute gem. The chef is making delicious food from scratch, so relax and have a coffee from the wide selection of single-origin beans. We tried the cob salad, steak salad, Greek salad, Nashville hot sandwich, and a selection of cakes for dessert. All of it was wonderful, with the chicken and steak for the salads cooked to order and the dressings all made in-house. Thank you, chef!

… more

Paul DeMilto
I have to say, this is some home style cooking. The Mac and cheese was on point. My wife got the salad with shrimp. She was very pleased. I had a fresh made hamburger with bacon and blue cheese cooked perfectly. How I asked for. A small, quiet atmosphere with light music in the background. The owner said the building was once an old theater, and the ticket box is still at the front door. What a great experience.

… more

Tialisa Whipple
Our first time going to Savory Sweet was by chance. We set out to eat elsewhere and it was closed. We were unsure what to make of the place because the sign out front said Savory Sweet Confections and through the window all we saw was what looked like a bakery shop. I finally saw the stuffed burger sign on the window and decided to give it a shot. The owner served us kindly. Chatted with us and gave us a run down on how things were prepared. I got the chicken bacon ranch sandwich and my Husband got a burger. The first bite of my sandwich was absolute heaven! Juicy chicken breaded with a flavorful crispy batter, fresh roll and just enough bacon to not overwhelm but compliment the chicken. My Husband absolutely loved his burger and it was cooked to perfection. If I had one suggestion it would be to make it an obvious restaurant. The place is within a stones throw of 2 busy bakeries but with this menu front and center there would be lines out the door. Absolutely delicious, it was a pleasure.

… more

nishchitha singh
It was awesome I am a very picky person but I loved everything and the mac and cheese was awesome the vegan mac and cheese didn’t even taste like it was vegan and the drinks were awesome it was a flavour explosion I hope you enjoyed this restaurant as much as I do

… more

Benjamin Metzger
We were headed home to Long Island from Liberty and googled Vegan nearby and jumped off the exit and quickly found the restaurant with free parking on the street. The owner and staff were friendly and we tried the Mac N Cheese, tomato soup, a salad, and chicken sandwich with jerk spice! We could tell the fried chicken sandwich was delicious and made with care (on it’s own without spice) but our mouths were sooooo on fire from the jerk, that we couldn’t taste the beautiful soup or truly taste the sandwich or fries. Our mouths were in a fiery jalapeño state for the whole meal until I slammed down a non alcoholic Beck’s and seltzer. We used Honey too. They warned us but we love spicy food so it was comical but fiery! The Mac N Cheese blew us away. Creamy and hot. Please watch out if you order a spicy dish. There are plenty of non spicy dishes here. We will be back. Apparently there is a stellar Sunday brunch with vegan and non vegan options. Thanks for the meal and we will see you soon.

… more

White Sun Films
I have had dozens of veggie burgers in my life as a vegan. This establishment has claimed the spot for number one, BEST vegan burger I’ve ever had. So many restaurants tout fresh ingredients, but this veggie burger was made with SUCH FRESH ingredients, I could ACTUALLY taste the difference. The owner was so personable and sweet despite how busy she was with online orders. Her homemade chips were delicious. On top of everything, she was SO attentive to our specific dietary needs. She was voluntarily, (without request!) so aware of potential allergen cross contamination, and made the chips in a fresh, separate oil. We felt at home here. Her homemade hot sauce was as delicious as it was hot. Can’t say enough good about this place, I’d be there every day if it wasn’t so far away. PLEASE give this place a try if you’re a vegan.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions