Old-fashioned establishment known for seafood specials & traditional American comfort food. Based on 234 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
Address:
S72W16373 Janesville Rd, Muskego, WI 53150
Website: https://www.facebook.com/CountrySquireSupperClub
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Theresa C
From the minute we arrived, greeted by Linda and Claudia. It was a busy Friday night had a seat at the bar for a drink and our table was immediately ready. Our young waitress Shayne was very friendly and it was a pleasure to watch her interact with the staff and customers. From the soup, fish and burger it was all wonderful. Not too many classic supper clubs left and I have to say the food, service and atmosphere was everything a great supper club is supposed to be!
… more
World Traveler
This is a quaint supper club catering mainly to locals looking for a quality traditional Wisconsin dining experience. The dining rooms are somewhat compact and the decor is a little dated, but it tells me that they’ve been here awhile and it must be for a reason.
… more
Mike Jozwicki
The wait was long. The service was good. The perch was one of the worst I’ve ever had. The breading was missing on some of it upon delivery and the texture of the perch was pasty. The potato pancakes did not taste homemade as advertised. This is the 2nd time I’ve been here and will be my last.
… more
John Tice
We are big fans of the Country Squire, the food, drinks and service are incredible. You get large servings at a very reasonable price. Do yourself a favor and get a after dinner ice cream drink.
… more
Karen
The end of an era for Country Squire. No longer open. We will see what replaces this old school supper club.
… more
Richard Price
Went on Friday with brother and sister. Had to wait over an hour (was gold 45 minute wait time). The Lake Perch Fish Fry was tasty but the pieces were on smaller size compared to other restaurants. Stopped in based on recommendation from brother in law. Server did a good job checking on our table for refills.
… more
Jeff Rhine
looking for a nice dinner out for a special occasion, ordered the filet 8 oz medium. it came out charred was offered the prime rib instead. sadly, it was so tuff that it was hard to eat. later found out waitress put the order in well done for the steak. after a pretty disappointing dinner. we got the 12 dollar bill for soda which included the charges for refills.
… more
Al Downs
Went there July 10, 2021 at 5:30 pm. 1st time going there. As we entered we were greeted by friendly staff. It was immediately noticeable that this place is seriously in need of updating and make over. Makes one wonder what the kitchen is like. Food was good, staff friendly. Ordered eggplant as an appetizer and shortly after was told they were out of eggplant. 5:30 pm on Saturday and out of eggplant? They open at 5:00 pm on Saturday. They also did not have any asparagus. We were told the owner looked everywhere and there was none. I stopped at the local grocery store on the way home and behold there was asparagus.
… more
Mark Karpinski
My wife, my brother and I went here for a Friday night fish fry. We all enjoyed our meals. My brother and wife had cod, fried and baked and I had fried lake perch. The staff was friendly and courteous.. We would definitely go back.
… more
Jayme Kalashian
Ted makes one of the best fish fries around. Actually it’s our favorite and the homemade potato pancakes are the best ever. Just like my mom and grandma use to make. Great d Fashioned s also.
… more
… View more