Based on 41 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
Address:
103 Pine Hollow Rd, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
Phone: (516) 922-5522
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Brandy Hill
NO CREDIT CARDS ACCEPTED, CASH ONLY, so we didn’t stay, they did tell us the closest atm, staff was very friendly, owner came out to greet us, great atmosphere, food looked great, was packed with people, not great parking, , overall would have been much happier if we had known ahead of time that it was CASH ONLY
… more
Allan R
The fish my wife had grouper), was very fresh, like it was, just out of the ocean that day. The mussel was great too. I had fish and chip. One of the best I ever had. George the owner, was very nice to us. The prices a little high, Maybe, but not for real fresh fish. I’ll be back.
… more
James Bresnahan
Great food and atmosphere.
… more
Christopher Ganymedias
Come for the grouper, stay for the grouper. The way a small, authentic LI fish place should be. Unpretentious. Accommodating. Friendly. Fresh. Reasonably priced and worth what you spend. There’s a lot on the menu, but don’t be afraid to try the recommendations.
… more
Chef
Love this place. Great seafood, outdoor seating, lovely staff and live music make for a terrific experience every time. Prices are great for the quality and quantity. Ask for the fries well done!
… more
Angelo Scuderi, Jr.
$1 clams & $2 oysters that were amazing. A reasonably priced lobster roll that actually has lobster (and a lot of it) on it with a good amount of celery to boot. The fish tacos were also great and we were sitting outside listening to some great live music. Be aware that this is a cash only establishment.
… more
Leejay Heller
For a great hole in the wall, no frills seafood place, it was a great deal! I had the New England Clam Chowder and the Lobster Bisque. The bisque was fantastic and would highly reccomend. If I am ever back in the Oyster Bay area I would go again and so should you!
… more
Nidji Photography
I moved from Oyster Bay to Queens a little over two years ago. To this day, I still make it a point to grab a bite whenever I’m in the neighborhood. Best fish tacos and lobster bisque! Ever!
… more
Tom Abby
Great place! The food is fresh. Favorite dish is stuffed artichoke w/ lobster. The best I’ve ever had!
… more
Geoff Wheeler
Best Steamers around! And decent Mexican if you’re tired of fresh fish. Unpretentious, just damn good food.
… more
… View more