Based on 345 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
157 Granite St, Westerly, RI 02891
Phone: (401) 596-1001
Website: http://www.supremepizzaofwesterly.com/
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
PETE KORE
I had the small Chicken Florentine pizza, i debated whether it was hand tossed dough or pre-formed. What I know for sure though was the pizza was cooked evenly, light and crispy! Almost seemed pan pizza style, the Ricotta and other toppings were well balanced and flavorful. My child had the Burger Supreme, it was as described. A thick juicy hamburger patty topped with all the fixings. My wife got the Buffalo chicken wrap, very large portions and chock full of juicy chicken. Now the uh-ohs! The Calamari appetizer was a bit soggy and bland, would prefer them to be crispy. The peppers were a nice touch and it was a decent portion. The mozzarella sticks were also nothing special. Otherwise a clean and roomy atmosphere with prompt and attentive wait service. I’d give it a 2.9 overall for the appetizers a 4.0 for the dinner.
… more
Emily Phillips
I’ve ordered from Supreme multiple times and I’ve never been as disappointed as I am tonight. The calamari that arrived was not even fully cooked, and didn’t have any breading, the turkey club we ordered was just a sandwich cut in half, and we ordered bbq chicken fingers and received plain chicken fingers with sweet and sour sauce. The steak and cheese subs were phenomenal though.
… more
Katie Palmer
Some of the best pizza and calzones I’ve had. Absolutely delicious, we got the calamari (classic Rhode Island-style ) and pizzas and calzones and apps and everything was so good. Thank you!
… more
Bucko Franco
Great food and wonderful staff. Recently dined in and as usual our lunch was perfect and the service, flawless. Reminder for those leaving less than stellar reviews (here and elsewhere) that wait staff have to deal with people like you every day, and some care deeply about their jobs and take your words to heart. Be kind. See you again soon SR&B.
… more
John Epley
I never leave reviews, but I’m just thoroughly disappointed. I previously enjoyed supreme, now it’s just not that good and falling down hill. It’s overpriced for its quality of food. I understand raising prices, but not for this food. And raising prices multiple times. My order wasn’t correct, multiple times. I always give benefit of doubt, however, multiple times shows it’s consistently mediocre food or not correct. If you do delivery plus a card you’re looking to add 4 for delivery fee and 1 to use your card, plus include tip. Which I always do 20%. Just a basic place, that’s not worth the cost, in my opinion. The wings which are about $1.50/wing, were way over done and a big miss. Only reason I’m giving it 2 stars is because I once enjoyed it and doubt every meal is bad.
… more
Erika Fiore
Supreme been my favorite pizza for years. The chicken florentine pizza and the buffalo chicken calzone are my favorites. Consistently delicious
… more
Crystal Howard
My Husband and son and I were looking for somewhere to eat, didnt realize most everywhere closed at 9pm ( it was just before 9)A quick Google search showed that this place was open until 10, it was close by, lets give it a try. Knowing we would be showing up after 9, we didn’t want to ask too much- don’t want to be ” those people”. Just walking in, it was a very nice place and we were greeted by the owner who assured us it was okay to take a seat and he’d get us our food quickly. My guys ordered a meatball and ricotta pizza and when I couldn’t decide, the owner suggested Chicken Francais ( I didn’t want to ask for anything complicated as we were very aware that we’d be there past closing) so I quickly agreed!
… more
Jackeline Nazareth
Love their buffalo fingers and steak and cheese sub! Have never had a problem here ordering or service.
… more
Holly Greene
My favorite place to eat in Westerly, for casual dining. It is spotlessly clean. The staff are so friendly and accomodating. The food is delicious, and the portions are BIG. The prices are comparable, if not lower, than other restaurants in the area. My favorite is their eggplant parm grinder, and you HAVE to try their onion rings! It is so nice to eat off REAL ceramic dishes and glassware. Refills on soft drinks, too.
… more
Sarah Saint Laurent
The pizza is delicious and delivery was timely. However, the chicken wings are awful. You can tell they are pre-breaded and frozen, poured from a plastic bag into the fryer. Skip the wings, go for a pizza.
… more
… View more