Anthony’s New York Style Pizza Menu – Tampa, FL

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Tampa, FL

Open for 14 Years! We are American owned and ran and we are originally from NY City. We use the same products from back home and only the top of the line ingredients to ensure the best quality. Stop in for a slice off of our 28’ Pizza and see for yourself.

Based on 480 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Anthony's New York Style Pizza 33624

Address:
12041 Anderson Rd, Tampa, FL 33624

Phone: (813) 962-8777

Website:

Hours

Saturday 11 AM–10:30 PM
Sunday 12–9 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
11 AM–10 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–10 PM
Thursday 11 AM–10 PM
Friday 11 AM–10:30 PM

Menu

Extra Condiments
Add On Items $0.00
Add Side Potato $0.00
Appetizers
Side Of Meatballs (3) $7.99
Garlic Knots (4 Pc) $3.99
Mozzarella Sticks $7.99
Garlic Bread $4.99
Garlic Bread W/ Cheese $6.49
Fries $4.99
Bacon Cheese Fries $7.99
Chicken Tenders $8.99
Dressing $1.00
Wings
Wings (6) $8.75
Wings (12) $16.99
Wings (16) $22.99
Wings (20) $24.99
Wings (48) $49.99
10 Boneless Wings $8.99
20 Boneless Wings $15.99
Salads
Greek Salad $12.99
Garden Salad $8.99
(Add Grilled Chicken) Garden Salad $12.99
(Add Crispy Chicken) Garden Salad $12.99
Caesar Salad $8.99
(Add Grilled Chicken) Caesar Salad $12.99
(Add Crispy Chicken) Caesar Salad $12.99
Antipasto Salad $14.99
Side Garden Salad (No Add Ons) $4.49
Side Ceasar (No Add Ons) $4.49
Extra Dressings $0.00
Potato Salad $3.00
Pizza By Slice
Slice $4.29
Slice Specaility $4.99
Slice Anthony $7.99
Sicilian Slice $4.59
Medium Pizzas
Che Pizza Med 12″ $11.99
Sicilian Med (6 Slices) $17.99
Small Sicilian (4 Slices) $13.99
Large Pizzas
Cheese Piz Large 16″ $16.99
Sicilian Piz Lg 16″ $19.99
XLarge Pizzas
Cheese Piz XLarge 18″ $17.99
Giant Pizzas
Giant Che Piz 28″ $38.99
Specialty Pizzas
Meat Lovers Pizza $3.00
Chicken Parmigiana Pizza $3.00
Veggie Lovers Pizza $3.00
Hawaiian Pizza $3.00
BBQ Chicken Pizza $3.00
Margherita Pizza $3.00
Buffalo Chicken Pizza $3.00
Anthony’s Supreme Pizza $3.00
White Pizza $3.00
Chicken Alfredo Pizza $0.00
Philly Steak Pizza $3.00
Mediterranean Chicken & Herb Pizza $0.00
Florentine Pizza $3.00
Amalfi Pizza $0.00
Calzone & Stromboli
Cheese Calzone $13.99
Stromboli $14.99
Subs
Philly Steak & Cheese $12.49
Chicken Philly & Cheese $12.49
Meatball Parmigiana $12.99
Chicken Parmigiana $13.29
Eggplant Parn Sub $12.29
Chicken Tender Sub $12.79
Chicken Cutlet $12.79
Italian Sub $12.99
Ham & Cheese $11.99
Buffalo Chicken $12.99
Drinks
Fountain Soda $2.99
Can Soda $1.99
2 Liter Bottle $4.99
Bottle Water $2.75
Entrees
Chicken Parmigiana D $16.99
Eggplant Parmigiana D $14.99
Baked Ziti $12.99
Stuffed Shells $12.99
Meat Lasagna $15.99
Pasta W/ Marinara $8.29
Pasta Meatballs $12.99
Penne Alla Vodka $13.99
Fettuccine Alfredo Dinner $13.99
Pasta Meatsauce $12.99
Desserts
Omg Chocolate Cake $5.99
Cheese Cake $5.99
Italian Cannoli $5.99
Funnel Cake Fries $4.99
Zeppoles (6) $5.99
Zeppoles (12) $7.99
(In House) Specials
Lg Cheese And 12 Wings $32.99
XL Cheese And 12 Wings $33.99
2 Med Cheese $19.99

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

TKDBoy1889
I’ve enjoyed coming here on occasion since I’ve lived in the apartment complex just behind it. It’s a great little pizza parlor to go in for a quick bite.

… more

Camila Peña Giraldo
Like a Family. The pizza is super good but the staff is the best, always friendly and they know me and recognized my order in seconds. I strongly recommend to eat inside because the pizza will get the perfect texture. In the box when you pick that up, the pizza loss the natural crunch and being soft (which is good as well, but is better to eat at the restaurant) I don’t change this pizza for nothing else.

… more

Gopal Choubey
I ate cheese slice at this place. It worth the money. It tasted good and the portion was sufficient for medium hunger.

… more

dennis lee
We ordered here for the 1st time to try them out. We got a large alfredo pizza, large hawaiian pizza, 3 large meat balls and cheese sticks. The cheese sticks were hard like they left it under the heat lamp for too long. The meatballs were small and not worth the $2 per meatball. As for the pizza we have attached some pictures. As you can see all the sauce and toppings slide to one corner of the box. It was not worth the $70 price tag. We will not order from here again.

… more

vanity cortes
I love this place! I have never had any issues! I actually just ordered a pizza 5 mins before they closed, and the workers were so sweet about it. I felt so bad, but they were very kind, so I had to come on here and ensure I wrote a review because that’s so rare to find these days! Their pizza also tastes delicious, and they have the best LARGE slices worth every penny!

… more

Manuel Marquez
Pretty good pizza and good prices. Discovered them on my way home one day and can’t stop going to get the giant slice!! Definitely recommend this place for some good pizza just wish they made it fresh but besides that it’s great.

… more

Brian H
Pizza is decent, slices are huge which makes them hard to eat on the run.

… more

Robert Negron
I like the italian sub here when the right person makes it. I’m trying the pizza again after a long time. Mixed feelings, the pizza tastes great, nice cheese, great sauce and the toppings were very good. No char to the crust loses a star from me, it was chewey and at times gooey. They have a tradional oven so why no char? Is oven temp too low or pizza removed from the oven too early? Do I need to request it? When I know, you’ll know. The place looks a little dumpy, a cleaning crew and some organizational skills are in order. If you like a chewy crust, this is your spot.

… more

Stacey Kehn
Ordered the Alfredo pizza last night and it was horrible. The Alfredo and cheese was so soupy it just dropped right onto the plate. Thought maybe the pizza was just too hot and needed to rest but…nope! The bottom crust was so thin and overall did not taste good. Very disappointing.

… more

Elizabeth Campagna
The pizza is pretty good here. I’ve not had a bad slice from this place. I do get a side of hot sauce and that sauce is pretty good.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions