Sully’s Grill at Sullivan Hardware & Garden Menu – Indianapolis, IN

Type : Restaurant

Location : Indianapolis, IN

Based on 129 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Sully's Grill at Sullivan Hardware & Garden 46220

Address:
6955 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Phone: (317) 255-9230

Website: https://sullivanhardware.com/

Hours

Sunday 10 AM–5 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
Closed
Tuesday 11 AM–8 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–8 PM
Thursday 11 AM–8 PM
Friday 11 AM–8 PM
Saturday 10 AM–7 PM

Menu

Starter House
Pat’s Philly Pretzel
Served with a smoky cheese sauce for dipping
$5.00
OMG Candied Pepper Bacon
Bacon, fresh black pepper, dark brown sugar double smoked on a hickory fired Traeger Grill. Low calorie recipe (just kidding)
$8.00
Sully’s Chips
Kettle chips freshly made in house and seasoned with our secret blend of spices developed by the guys in the electrical department. Served with french onion aioli.
$5.00
Smoked Chicken Wings
Large meaty wings smoked on our Big Green Egg and then finished off with the sauce of your choice. Sauce options: Buffalo, BBQ, Inferno, Kickin Asian. Don’t like sauce? Try them dry rubbed!
$10.00
Pulled Pork Nachos
Tortilla chips piled high with our pulled pork, cheese, tomatoes, jalapeños, onions, topped off with our sassy BBQ Ranch sauce.
$10.00
Smoke House
Pulled Pork
Heritage Farms pork shoulder mustard brined for 24 hours before a 13-hour hickory smoke.
Beef Brisket
Our Brisket from Indiana’s Heritage Farm is rubbed in our BBQ spice blend mixed in house in the paint department. The cherry smoked masterpiece will cook low and slow for 15 hours.
Sliders
2 slider rolls with choice of meat, gator pickles and choice of 1 side
$10.00
Sandwhich
1/3 pound of meat on a brioche bun, choice of 1 side. Or have it naked…no bun!
$12.00
Platter
Your choice of 2 meats, 2 sides and a roll
$18.00
Sully’s BBQ Sundae
You need to try this! We layer our mac & cheese, pulled pork, Memphis coleslaw, BBQ sauce into one unusual sundae treat. Topped not with a cherry but with candied BACON!
$12.00
Dog House
Chicago Style
A windy city classic. All beef hot dog, yellow mustard, green relish, onion, tomato wedges, pickle spear, sport peppers and celery salt. Comes with your choice of Side.
$8.00
Smokey Mac Dog
All beef hot dog, layered with our smoky pork mac and cheese and topped with our BBQ ranch sauce. Comes with your choice of Side.
$8.00
Carolina Style
All Beef dog loaded with pulled pork and topped with our Memphis coleslaw. Comes with your choice of Side.
$8.00
Sides
Smoky Mac & Cheese
Memphis Slaw
Slide Salad
Sully’s Chips
Potato Salad
Cup Of Soup
Green House
Greek Salad
Crispy romaine lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, kalamata olives, and feta cheese tossed in our greek vinaigrette.
$4.00
Greek Salad
Crispy romaine lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, kalamata olives, and feta cheese tossed in our greek vinaigrette.
$8.00
Classic Ceasar Salad
Romaine lettuce topped with fresh shaved parmesan cheese, croutons and our caesar dressing.
$4.00
Classic Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce topped with fresh shaved parmesan cheese, croutons and our caesar dressing.
$8.00
Chef Nick’s Chopped Salad
Chopped romaine, apples, parmesan cheese, candied bacon, egg, and walnuts all tossed in our house mustard vinaigrette
$10.00
Chef Nick’s Chopped Salad
Chopped romaine, apples, parmesan cheese, candied bacon, egg, and walnuts all tossed in our house mustard vinaigrette.
$10.00
Soup Combo
Select one of our soups de jour and pair with a half sandwich or salad. Sandwich choices are grilled cheese, BLT, turkey and pear panini or pulled pork slider. Half salad options are greek or caesar.
$9.00
Southwestern Pulled Pork Salad
Romaine Lettuce, corn, black beans, pico, pulled pork, and tortilla strips tossed in BBQ ranch dressing.
$10.00
Rosted Beet Salad
Fresh arugula, roasted beets, goat cheese, walnuts, balsamic dressing.
$10.00
Bowl Of Soup
Select one of our hot soups served with a homemade crostini
$5.00
Bread House
Mary Rita’s Egg Salad Sandwich
Farm fresh eggs, mayo, dijon, dill, chives with a bit of gator pickle added served on toasted bread just the way Grandma Rita served it.
$10.00
Grilled Cuban
Our famous pulled pork, honey ham, Swiss cheese, spicy mustard and gator pickles all piled high on a hoagie roll and grilled to perfection.
$12.00
Not Your Momma’s BLT
Classic BLT made with our candied pepper bacon, tomatoes, lettuce and dressed with our bacon jam aioli
$10.00
JB’s Turkey & Pear Panini
Smoked turkey breast, thin sliced pears, creamy gruyere cheese, and fig jam piled on our fresh sourdough bread and grilled. The perfect fall combination!
$12.00
Classic Grilled Cheese
Fresh sourdough bread topped with sharp white cheddar and creamy gruyere cheese. The perfect cheesy combination!
$10.00
Tree House – Kids Menu
Hot Dog
Hot Dog on a bun served with chips
$5.00
Pulled Pork Slider
Pulled Pork Slider served with chips
$5.00
Mac And Cheese
Mac and Cheese served with chips
$5.00

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Jimmy Bailey
Best hardware store this side of America. Want tools, no problem, want home and garden no problem. Want to have a beer and look around or just relax no problem? This is the place for you. Highly recommended!!!

… more

D.W. Everett
Our second time at Sully’s. Once again it is everything the name implies! Pat Sullivan is an extraordinary business man. The little bistro inside of 71st and Keystone is a gem. From the special wine to the special of the day ( smoked turkey w brie and apple chutney ) to the fresh spinach and arugula salad to the Parmigian butternut squash soup the meal was superb!! Our waitress [ Victoria ] was superb with her customer service and suggestions to enhance our dining experience!! I suggest you ask for her when you arrive.

… more

Mia West-Tourner
The plan was breakfast after church but we got there a little too late. We decide to stay and have lunch. The food was absolutely amazing. It was so flavorful. Our waitress was great. Never thought a restaurant would be locate in a hardware and garden shop. Get your flower fix then eat a great meal.

… more

Magnus Wu
Absolutely loved the sandwiches here. The sauces and aiolis are amazing. Located in the back of Sullivan Hardware Store. Very limited seating during holidays

… more

Charlie Demler
I took my girlfriend there for Valentine’s dinner. Love the dinner the train ride was a little disappointing, not nearly as good as the Christmas train ride but I later found out it was never supposed to be like the Christmas train ride. Very cool place to go and eat and Shop. I will go back

… more

Mimi Brown
I had so much fun. In a hardware store, ikr. There’s a lot going on in there. Definitely not a disappointment. You gotta go see for yourself. Loved it

… more

Gary Dolick
Small, but creative and outstanding menu. Who would have thought that eating at the hardware store would be a thing? And a really good thing, at that!

… more

Barbara Page
As another patron mentioned, not recommended for dinner. With Grill in the name, I don’t know, maybe offer something from the grill. The brussel sprout Caesar salad had way too much vinegar dressing. Our waitress seemed put out.

… more

Ruth Shoulders
Great place for a fabulous lunch! Great service and excellent food. Will definitely be going back! I had the citrus spinach salad and it was wonderful.

… more

Kent Hiller
A beer while shopping at the hardware store….how can Saturday afternoon errands get any better??

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions