Pizzeria set in a charming Beach Haven shopping hub serving NY-style pies for dining in or takeout. Based on 280 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
310 Taylor Ave, Beach Haven, NJ 08008
Phone: (609) 492-4484
Website: http://bay-village-pizza.keeq.io/
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–12 AM |
| Friday | 10 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–12 AM |
| Monday | 10 AM–12 AM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
William L
First time going to to Bay Village Pizza after usually eating at panzones. Living full time in North Jersey where pizza is an art, I can tell you the pizza here is simply amazing. Flavorful, large slices that fold perfectly. We had pepperoni, mushroom, and plain and all 3 were amazing. Slightly more expensive than at home ($25 for a L pie) but it’s cheap for a place on the Island. I highly recommend!
… more
Poughkeepsie 360
Bay Village Pizza is a local treasure! Their pizzas are a slice of perfection, with a thin crust that’s perfectly crispy. The sauce is flavorful, and the toppings are fresh and abundant. The menu boasts a variety of pizza options, catering to all tastes. The friendly staff and cozy ambiance make dining here a pleasure. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or having a family dinner, Bay Village Pizza is a must-try. It’s evident that they put love into their craft, and I can’t wait to return for more delectable pizza experiences!
… more
Diane Ciemnolonski
Very good Pizza, Even with it being a Friday night around 6pm, ordered and was served my Pizza within 15 mins. Crust was very good, and pepperoni was not greasy. A little pricey but your at the shore, and it’s actually very good so I don’t mind. Definitely going back.
… more
Gabrielle
V good pizza, took 20 minutes to get a 18inch classic cheese but there were plenty of places to window shop at while we waited.
… more
Glenn Adams
While this place has unique shops when we returned to our car in a crowded parking lot, there were about 20 teens right next to our car sitting on and around a jeep parked next to us while videoing others on a bike popping wheelies. Almost hit one on a bike just trying to get out of there. We actually drove out on an “in only” just to get out of there. A cop saw us do that but didn’t seem to care. This was on a Thursday evening.
… more
hi hi
the fresh cut fries never disappoint and pizza is good sometimes.. fries take a little while but pizza is almost immediate but they do tell you that it will take a little while. people who take the orders are usually very nice.
… more
D. Ramirez
No frills, walk-up pizza joint. Quite popular so it gets pretty busy. Expect to wait even if the line is not that long. Seems to be located smack in the middle of everything in Beach Haven (Bay Village, Fantasy Island, waterpark and mini golf). Simple menu. Walk-up to the window, place your order, give your name and wait to be called. They have a few tables in a porch-style seating area off to the side. Plain slices start at $4. Pizza was alright, not bad by any means but not sure if it was worth the wait. If there were half ratings this place would get a 3.5 but since there aren’t, I will give them the benefit.
… more
Morgan Allen
Pretty overpriced for what you’re getting. Pizza wasn’t bad but also wasn’t great. They also used to give big slices but now they’re pretty small. You might as well spend the money and get a real meal somewhere else.
… more
M Rogers
Great pizza to go with the brewery right around the corner. The slices hit the spot
… more
Brendan
An average pizza joint but with HUGE slices of pizza and great fries which I recommend getting which cheese. Great place to have a quick meal at.
… more
… View more