Farmhouse-style steakhouse with hand-cut filets & homemade pickles, plus live music on the weekends. Based on 556 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$$
Address:
475 Temple Hill Rd, New Windsor, NY 12553
Phone: (845) 561-1762
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Taylor Scott
Schlesinger’s is definitely a unique experience. It has an associated cigar bar which I’m not a fan of, but they have a non smoking dining area. The service was good. The house pickles (mild dill flavor) were decent, but the bread was cold and hard. I had a french onion soup that had good developed flavor. The salad had a lot of hearts in it that I’m not a fan of having in a side salad. They also have a small dressing selection. A had a filet and mashed potatoes. Everything was above average just not high end. The steak had a real strong iron taste and potatoes lacked seasoning. Overall it was a good experience, but a step below a Ruth’s Chris or similar.
… more
Herder G. Rodríguez Ayala
Excelente location near town and airport. Great service, very good timing in between serves. Antique decoration, good lighting it gives a historic look. Big portions and amazing prices. Plus a cigar area next to restaurant.
… more
Kathy Wingfield
Scallops were delicious! Baked potato and bread were very good. Filet mignon was a bit underdone. Service was very good. Will definitely return.
… more
Renee Pastore
Came here last night for my Birthday, nice quaint setting, I had shrimp cocktail, my husband had the potato skins & crab cakes for appetizers, for dinner, I had the Prime Rib, baked potato, my husband had the Schlesinger’s steak, steak fries, OMG both pieces of meat were PERFECTLY cooked, our waitress was SUPER sweet, definitely coming back, thank you for the desert for my Birthday, really made dinner more special
… more
David Clayton
Awesome steaks (and pickles) reasonably priced (pickles are free) and very courteous service. Cozy place for a date or business casual dinner (or semi-private rooms to book for events). Steaks are juicy and cooked to perfection and portion sizes are generous. One of the better steakhouses in the Hudson Valley. Once you’re full, you can continue that tax-deductible business dinner at the attached cigar bar with a wide selection of cigars and spirits.
… more
Fritz Maandig
Love the place! Service is awesome, the waiter was attentive and was very pleasing. Steak was great! Ambiance was cozy! Had a good time, I’ll be coming back again for sure!
… more
Matt Healey
If you like steaks, drinks, and cigars this is the place for you. The staff is great. Everyone is friendly while also attentive. I wasn’t lucky enough to check out the beach yet (outdoor area complete with bars, sand, and a stage), but that just means we’ll be back.
… more
Robert Samuelson
They have an ad in Saturday’s paper September 2 featuring their shore dinner, Tuesdays and Wednesdays, after driving 43 miles to get there, on Tuesday, September 5th, they said that was over on Labor Day. No apologies or anything and the owner was hidden from clear sight. We were fortunate to find an outstanding restaurant less than 2 miles from there, called Citrus. Outstanding food, outstanding service and half the price.
… more
Jessica Bergeron
Amazing food, cool seating outside, loved it. And portions were insane. AND they gave us a jar of pickles! We can’t wait to go back!
… more
Stephen Fengler
This was my 1st time here and I was highly satisfied. I ordered the French Dip Au Jous which was delicious and cooked perfectly. The french onion sauce on the side complemented the sandwich well. The bread was also nice and crispy. The service was friendly, helpful, and very knowledgeable. The interior was neat and has kept a nice historic charm dating back to the structure being built in the 1700s. Highly enjoyed this restaurant and would come back here again.
… more
… View more