Based on 42 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup
Address:
718 Meacham Ave, Elmont, NY 11003
Phone: (516) 825-9827
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 5:30–11:30 PM |
| Thursday | 5:30–11:30 PM |
| Friday | 5:30–11:30 PM |
| Saturday | 5–11:30 PM |
| Sunday | 5–11:30 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Reviews
william wall
I haven’t been to Teddy’s in many years, my sister used to live in Elmont, but I have to say that their pizza was the best that I have ever tasted, thin crust and delicious…I have to make a point to return again very soon!!!
… more
Jennifer Hope
Haven’t been in years but I think about this pizza all the time. I stopped in one tome and the owner was so nice and talked to me as he made the pie himself. It was some of the best pizza I ever had. I would go again if I had a car to get there!
… more
Linda Gannon
Lived around the corner on Donovan went there many times miss that place- places like this are few and far! Miss NY now live in SC. Maybe when I’m up there I will come by and have a pizza.
… more
Tom Faber
I grew up in Elmont and have been eating Teddy’s pizza my entire life. The place and pizza are the best! I have so many memories of going there with my friend and his dad. I’ve taken my kids there to eat the pizza and whenever I’m back on LI, I call and order a few pies to bring back home to Westchester. I’ve eaten lots of pizza and Teddy’s is at the top! Please keep the business going!
… more
Nick Proton
Great times. Amazing friendly people. Will be back soon for another pie.
… more
Larell Marie Mele
We had SUCH a nice time there!! The pizza was amazing and the owner, Lou, was so personable and accommodating. We shared stories and jokes. Will DEFINITELY be visiting again! Highly recommend this neighborhood bar/pizzeria.
… more
Clifford Lesperance
Real throw back! I loves my experience.. It was a step back in the past of what pizzerias was once like. The pizza has the throw back original crust taste that really says they kept the original secret recipe in family..
… more
Brian Schmidt
My dad grew up eating this pizza and introduced our family to it. It has ruined all other Pizza for me. The greatest. Didnt know it was still open. I wonder if its the same as the good ol days.
… more
Kelly Moschonas
Probably the best pizza in town (Franklin Square / Elmont area)! Dough comes out crunchy and delicious – sauce and cheese very tasty. Sold by the pie only (no individual slices). Place is old, but meant to be that way… it even has an old phone booth, along with old phone books, too! Place is adorned with sports-themed items. Although old, the place is clean, has seating for about 30 people, and a bar that probably seats 10 with a TV on the wall. I like the place and the pizza! Try it… you’ll like it!
… more
DJ Doobie
Not sure what the hype was all about, but the pizza had very little flavor. It took like 35 minutes to make for some reason. The place was empty (covid) so it wasn’t because they were busy. Maybe they had a different cook when I went. ♂️ Not worth it.
… more
… View more