Benny’s Pizza Menu – Milwaukee, WI

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Milwaukee, WI

Based on 605 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Benny's Pizza 53215

Address:
1102 W Lincoln Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53215

Phone: (414) 384-5500

Website:

Hours

Thursday 10 AM–12 AM
Friday 10 AM–12 AM
Saturday 10 AM–12 AM
Sunday 10 AM–12 AM
Monday 10 AM–12 AM
Tuesday 10 AM–12 AM
Wednesday 10 AM–12 AM

Menu

Sandwiches
Italian Beef
Bar-B-Que Beef
Italian Sausage
Combo
Chicken Sandwich
Fish Sandwich
Cheeseburger
Gyros
Hot Dogs
Polish Sausage
Pveal Cut Let
Grilled Chicken Breast
Sides
Pizza Puff
Hot Bites
Pizza Bread
Chicken Nuggets
Onion Rings
Cheese Sticks
Mushrooms
8 Pc Chicken Wings
French Fries
Cheese Fries
Others
Coke Products

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Lisa Mumm
Their prices are reasonable, the staff is nice, and they always answer the phone. I don’t think they’ve ever not made a pizza within 30 minutes of calling. Their main thing is pizza. I’m not sure why you’d come to a pizza restaurant and get mad they don’t have good burgers. They also mainly do take out and delivery. You can technically eat in but they have limited space. One of the other reviews said they had hairy food and roaches. They got an A from the health department and the kitchen is always spotless. The building is just older.

… more

Erik Sanchez
Great pizza not the best but close plenty of cheese and toppings sauce isn’t too sweet and the bread is well cooked, haven’t had any issues with their food been a client for about 6 years always come back for more ,customer service isn’t the best either but they have never been rude to me tbh ,I’ve had a good experience overall .

… more

Maria Hernandez
The slices are amazing! I always get a customized chicken sandwich and they have no problem with that. I order from here AT LEAST once every two week, however on lazier weeks it goes up to even two times!! Good and quick food!

… more

Giovaniel Heredia
Yesterday I ordered a pizza for my kids at 3 pm the payment said pending & I never got the pizza after waiting 3 hours and still no food or transaction I just ordered else where. I called today because the payment went through at 10 am!! The manager says there’s nothing he can do because yesterday is yesterday and today is a new day. I got no refund no pizza for the money. I’m furious!!

… more

Christina Pena
Man Bennys I never had to complain to them been buying from them for years and the food is great one thing I won’t do is let me tell you today my food was ice cold Except the marinara sauce. I called to complain for the first time ever and he couldn’t understand why it was cold and made it seem like I was lying or something so instead of yelling I said okay and hung up. Just moved so nothing to warm this food up. Never again I don’t enjoy cool food . Cheese ain’t even melted. Little did you guys know I do reviews for Yelp on food and I threw that burger away. Bad customer service bad food temperature I didn’t even get any napkins and one ketchup for all these freaking fries

… more

Gigi Croysdale
Absolutely disgusting, mozzarella sticks and pizza undercooked. Only warm thing was marinara sauce. The dough had a thick translucent layer in the middle, as well as 2 strands of hair. I called to complain and the man said “thats impossible we have hair nets so go mess with someone else” very rude. After reading some reviews I found out about roaches and people with the same disrespectful service, very immature and unacceptable. I felt so sick to my stomach that I threw up. Raw food gets people sick but they don’t care about that. Don’t waste your time or money on this place. It’s not worth it and you won’t get it back.

… more

Eddie Carr
A great place to visit on the South Side of Milwaukee for great food at a reasonable price. I love the chicken sandwich and Italian beef.

… more

Gary Scott
Very delicious food for the prices you can’t beat! and delivery! on time.

… more

Erica Smith
Best place to get food, super good I order from here whenever I can, friendly atmosphere, busy hard working friendly people, I absolutely love their food.

… more

Christine Gondek
I Like Their Italian Beef Sandwiches, The Lasanga & Spaghetti Dinners. I Like Their Gyros, Grilled Chicken Sandwiches, Meatballs Sandwiches, Cheeseburgers, Bacon Double Cheeseburgers, Italian Sausage Food. I Also Like The Wings & Shrimp Dinners.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions