Chicken Holiday Featuring Nathans Menu – Baldwin, NY

Type : Chicken restaurant

Location : Baldwin, NY

Based on 140 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Chicken Holiday Featuring Nathans 11510

Address:
1203 Grand Ave, Baldwin, NY 11510

Phone: (516) 505-0909

Website:

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday 11 AM–9 PM
Friday 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday 11 AM–10 PM
Sunday 11 AM–9 PM
Monday 11 AM–9 PM

Menu

Our Menu
Cole Slaw
Regular – 1/2 lb – $2.99 | Jumbo – 1 lb – $4.99
Potato Salad
Regular – 1/2 lb – $2.99 | Jumbo – 1 lb – $4.99
Macaroni Salad
Regular – 1/2 lb – $2.99 | Jumbo – 1 lb – $4.99
Fried Vegetables
Served with Horseradish or Cheddar Cheese Sauce Zucchini Stix, Mushroom, Cauliflower, Broccoli, Okra Regular – $11.99 | Jumbo $13.99 | Family $24.99
Mixed Fried Vegetable
Served with Horseradish or Cheddar Cheese Sauce Zucchini Stix, Mushroom, Cauliflower, Broccoli, Okra Small – $11.99 | Large $22.99 | X-Large $32.99
Potato Skins
With Cheddar Cheese & Sour Cream6 for $7.59| 12 for $15.50
Creamy Macaroni & Cheese
Small – 1/2 lb – $3.99 | Large – 1 lb – $6.99
Onion Rings
12 pieces $6.99 | 24 pieces $11.99
Mozzarella Sticks
6 pieces $9.19 | 12 pieces $17.99 | 24 pieces $30.99
Mashed Potatoes
Served with brown gravy Small – 1/2 lb – $2.99 | Large – 1 lb – $5.99 | X-Large – 2 lb – $10.99
Dinner Rolls
6 for $1.99
$0.39
Fried Ravioli
Served with Marinara Sauce6 pieces $6.79 | 12 pieces $10.99 | 24 pieces $21.99
Single French Fries
1 serving Regular $2.99 | Seasoned $3.99 | Sweet Potato $3.99
Double French Fries
1 -2 serves Regular $4.99 | Seasoned $6.99 | Sweet Potato $6.99
Medium French Fries
2 – 3 ServesRegular $6.99 | Seasoned $9.99| Sweet Potato $9.99
Large French Fries
4- 6 servesRegular $9.99 | Seasoned $13.99 | Sweet Potato $13.99
Bucket French Fries
7 – 9 servesRegular $13.999 | Seasoned $18.99 | Sweet Potato $18.99
Holiday French Fries
10 – 13 servesRegular $20.99 | Seasoned $26.99 | Sweet Potato $26.99
Chicken Snack
Thigh, Leg (2 pieces)
$7.99
Chicken
All White Meat – Breast & Wing
$8.99
Super Jumbo Shrimp Pack
6 pieces
$9.99
Fish & Chips Snack
2 pieces
$7.99
Buffalo Wing Snack
8 pieces
$12.50
Garden Salad
Mixed greens, tomatoes, red onions, carrots, olives
$8.99
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, croutons, parmigiano cheese
$8.99
Shrimp Salad
Fried Breaded Shrimp, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion
$12.99
Chicken Salad
Grilled or Breaded Chicken, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion
$12.99
8 Pieces Buffalo Wings $9.99
16 Pieces Buffalo Wings $19.89
24 Pieces Buffalo Wings $28.99
48 Pieces Buffalo Wings $57.99
4 Pieces Tubs Of Chicken $9.99
8 Pieces Tubs Of Chicken $18.99
12 Pieces Tubs Of Chicken $26.99
16 Pieces Tubs Of Chicken $33.99
20 Pieces Tubs Of Chicken $43.99
24 Pieces Tubs Of Chicken $49.99
28 Pieces Tubs Of Chicken $56.99
32 Pieces Tubs Of Chicken $65.99
36 Pieces Tubs Of Chicken $73.99
50 Pieces Tubs Of Chicken $97.99
Wing $1.89
Leg $1.99
Thigh $2.79
Chicken Breast $3.99
Breaded Or Grilled Chicken Cutlet
Please specify
$4.39
6 Pieces Chicken Nuggets $5.75
9 Pieces Chicken Nuggets $6.89
20 Pieces Chicken Nuggets $14.95
50 Pieces Chicken Nuggets $35.65
4 Pieces Chicken Fingers $7.99
8 Pieces Chicken Fingers $13.99
12 Pieces Chicken Fingers $21.85
16 Pieces Chicken Fingers $27.59
Single Order Tubs Of Ribs
6 pieces
$17.99
Double Order Tubs Or Ribs
12 pieces
$35.99
Triple Order Tubs Of Ribs
18 pieces
$53.99
Barrel-O-Ribs
24 pieces
$70.99
Super Barrel
30 pieces
$88.99
Bottomless Barrel
36 pieces
$106.99
Captain Holiday Barrel
42 pieces
$122.99
20 Pieces Small Shrimp In A Basket $8.99
40 Pieces Small Shrimp In A Basket $16.99
60 Pieces Small Shrimp In A Basket $24.99
80 Pieces Small Shrimp In A Basket $32.99
100 Pieces Small Shrimp In A Basket $39.99
9 Pieces Tubs Of Shrimp $13.99
18 Pieces Tubs Of Shrimp $27.99
27 Pieces Tubs Of Shrimp $41.99
36 Pieces Tubs Of Shrimp $54.90
48 Pieces Tub Of Shrimp $69.99
Small Clam Platter $9.99
Large Clam Platter $17.99
12 Scallops $15.99
24 Scallops $31.99
Fillet Of Sole Flounder
2 Pieces $9.99/ 4 Pieces $19.99
Maryland Crab Cakes
2 pieces $7.99 | 4 pieces $14.95
4 Pieces Batter-Dipped Fish $10.35
6 Pieces Batter-Dipped Fish $14.95
8 Pieces Batter-Dipped Fish $20.69
10 Pieces Batter-Dipped Fish $25.29
12 Pieces Batter-Dipped Fish $28.75
14 Pieces Batter-Dipped Fish $34.49
Small Fish ‘N’ Chips Tub
8 Pieces of Batter Dipped Fish & Medium Order of French Fries
$22.99
Large Fish ‘N’ Chips Tub
12 Pieces of Batter Dipped Fish & Medium Order of French Fries
$33.35
Chicken Holiday Dinner
4 pieces chicken
$12.65
Chicken Cutlet Dinner
2 pieces of white-meat cutlet grilled or deep fried
$13.79
Super Jumbo Shrimp
7 pieces
$15.99
Rib Dinner
5 large ribs
$15.99
Combo Dinner
2 pieces chicken, 3 super jumbo shrimp, 1 batter dipped fish
$15.99
Chicken & Rib Dinner
2 pieces chicken & 3 ribs
$15.99
Fillet Of Sole Dinner
2 pieces Flounder
$13.99
Scallops Dinner
12 lightly battered scallops
$15.99
Fried Clams Dinner
Sweet clams lightly seasoned
$12.99
Seafood Dinner
Shrimp, Clams, Flounder
$15.99
Surf & Turf Dinner
3 large ribs & flounder
$15.99
Shrimp & Rib Dinner
3 jumbo shrimp, 3 ribs
$15.99
Duet
8 pieces of freshly cooked chicken, double order of French fries, 1/2 lb salad of your choice
$24.99
Fiesta
12 pieces of freshly cooked chicken, medium order of French fries, 1 lb salad of your choice
$36.99
Jubilee
16 pieces of freshly cooked chicken, large French fries, 1 lb salad of your choice, 6 rolls
$47.99
Picnic Basket
4 pieces of freshly cooked chicken, 6 super Jumbo gulf shrimp, 4 pieces of batter dipped fish, medium order of French fries, 1 lb salad of your choice
$44.75
Combo Pack
8 pieces of freshly cooked chicken, 8 pieces of flame broiled ribs, medium order of French Fries
$49.99
Holiday 6 Pack
6 pieces of freshly cooked chicken, 6 super jumbo shrimp, 6 pieces of flame broiled ribs, medium order fries
$51.99
Holiday Meal Deal
12 pieces of freshly cooked chicken, 20 small shrimp, 6 pieces of flame broiled ribs, 1 lb salad of your choice
$71.99
Surf & Chirp
8 pieces of freshly cooked chicken, 40 pieces of small shrimp, large mashed potatoes (1 lb) with gravy
$41.99
Chicken Club
All white meat breaded cutlet
$8.99
Spicy Chicken Club $8.99
Marinated Grilled Chicken Breast $8.99
Captain’s Catch
Flounder Fillet
$8.99
Maryland Crab Cake Sandwich $8.99
Hamburger
Add Cheese $1.29Add Bacon $1.29
$6.89
Cheese Burger $6.99
Bacon Cheese Burger
Ham, rib pork, Swiss, pickles, mustard
$7.99
Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato Classic $7.99
Chicken Wrap
Regular or spicy breaded chicken breast with lettuce, tomato, onion, dressing.
$10.99
Shrimp Wrap
Fried small shrimp, lettuce, tomato, served with tartar or cocktail sauce.
$10.99
Chicken Tender Wrap
Chicken, Lettuce, Tomato with Honey Mustard, BBQ, or Russian Dressing.
$13.99
Caesar Wrap
Romaine, Parmesan cheese, croutons & Caesar dressing.With Grilled Chicken – $10.99
$7.99
BLT Wrap
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato with Mayo or Russian Dressing With Grilled Chicken $10.99
$8.99
Salad Wrap
Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onion, Olives, Peppers With Grilled Chicken $10.99
$7.99
3 Chicken Tenders $6.89
4 Chicken Nuggets $4.59
6 Chicken Nuggets $6.89
Chicken Leg Or Thigh $4.59
Macaroni & Cheese $5.75
Water $1.50
Can $1.75
20 Oz $2.50
2 Liter $4.50
Red Velvet Cake $4.59
Cheesecake $3.99
Oreo Mousse Cake $4.50
Chocolate Cake $3.99
8 Pieces With Double Fries $14.99
12 Pieces With Medium Fries $19.99
Lunch Specials
Garden Salad
Mixed greens, tomatoes, red onions, carrots, olives
$8.99
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, croutons, parmigiano cheese
$8.99
Chicken Salad
Grilled or Breaded Chicken, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion
$12.99
Shrimp Salad
(4) Mixed greens tomatoes, red onions, carrots
$12.99
Buffalo Wing Snack (8) $12.65
Chicken Snack
Thigh, Leg (2 pieces)
$7.99
Fish & Chips Snack
2 pieces
$7.99
Chicken All White Meat
Breast, wing
$8.99
Super Jumbo Shrimp Pack
6 pieces
$9.99
Pork Or Chicken Empanada $2.00
3 Empanadas $5.00
Biscuit $0.60
3 Biscuits $1.50
Dinner Rolls
each
$0.39
Catering Menu & Party Trays
Economy Plan
Serves 8 – 10 24 pieces of freshly cooked chicken, 12 dinner rolls, choice of salads. Total 2 lbs
$64.99
Taste Tempter
Serves 10 – 15 24 pieces of freshly cooked chicken, 24 super jumbo gulf shrimp, 24 dinner rolls, choice of salads. Total 4 lbs
$119.99
Deluxe Plan
Serves 15 – 20 50 pieces of freshly cooked chicken, 24 dinner rolls, choice of salads. Total 6 lbs
$119.99
Hearty Party
Serves 15 – 20 36 pieces of freshly cooked chicken, 36 super jumbo gulf shrimp, 36 dinner rolls, choice of salads. Total 5 lbs
$179.99
Holiday Buffet Jr
Serves 10 – 20 20 pieces of flame broiled ribs, 20 pieces of freshly cooked chicken, 20 super jumbo gulf shirmp, 20 dinner rolls, choice of salads. Total 4 lbs
$159.99
Holiday Buffet
Serves 20 – 25 40 pieces of flame broiled ribs, 40 pieces of freshly cooked chicken, 40 super jumbo gulf shrimp, 40 dinner rolls, choice of salads. Total 8 lbs
$299.99
100 Pieces Chicken $179.99
50 Pieces Mozzarella Sticks $47.99
100 Pieces Small Shrimp $42.99
100 Pieces Flame Broiled Ribs $287.49
1 Tray Of Mac & Cheese
5 lbs
$28.99
100 Pieces Jumbo Shrimp $179.99
100 Pieces Buffalo Wings $109.99
5 Lbs. Of Salad Of Your Choice
Macaroni, potato, coleslaw
$19.99
50 Pieces Chicken Tenders $75.89
Garden Salad Or Caesar Salad
1/2 Tray $22.99 | Full Tray $40.99
100 Pieces Chicken Nuggets $65.99

… View more

Reviews

Christina Martin
Unfortunately, the young woman who took my order did not get it right. She sassed her boss who fired her in font of us.

… more

A. V.B.
I have been coming here since childhood and still really enjoy it from time to time. The “snacks” are a great value such as dark meat chicken snack or rib snack which come with a choice of fries or mashed potatoes and a can of soda. I think this might be a lunch only promotion I am not sure so please check on that first. I like their regular fries but have to heat them in oven or toaster to crisp them up again at home as they do get soggy in the take out container. Their regular fries are pretty basic so maybe I will try their seasoned version one of these days. Chicken is crispy and juicy. Ribs are great too. Service the last time I was there was friendly, fast, and correct.

… more

Nicolas Villalobos
Is my first time trying Nathan’s, I have questions about the food and I just ask what kind of hot dogs they have, and the cashier answer was, we have hot dogs of course I know they have hotdogs and all this with attitude!!!

… more

joe
They gave me so much food tonight and it was so freaking delicious. I love their ribs and mashed potatoes so much. Definitely worth the $20.

… more

Michael Redenburg
Hands down the best chicken and ribs in town! Had my order ready when I arrived and the staff at the counter were very friendly. I’ll be back!

… more

Pudgy C
I have been going to this place for years. The young lady that was taking my order wouldn’t let me finish before she started trying to finish my order. I know what I want to order, they have to learn how to listen. Then they put someone else on the phone to take the order without letting me know that this was a different person. So I had to begin all over, of course I got frustrated but then the girl started screaming at me. I normally spend about $100 a week at this place. I will NOT anymore though after this. They are very nasty and the chicken has been getting very salty. My daughter worked there about 23 years ago so I am very familiar with this place. I will for sure look for some place else because you can tell this place is going down. They have new managers and you can tell. They have NO people skills. I know they are young people but when you are running a business especially an eatery place you have to be patient. I will spend my money some place else. To give an update I went to the store to speak to the manager, a young girl came out saying she was the manager. She wasn’t as nasty however she kept saying, “Can I help you?” Without even listening to the complaint. She said I was the one being rude. I might have said it in a rude way but I NEVER raised my voice. I was aggrevated because I gave my order and then the other person switched me over to this person. When the next person came on she just said can I have your order after I gave my order 2 times already. As a manager if you come on a call you are suppose to identify yourself as being the manager and then proceed to ask, how can I help you? It’s apparent they don’t have managerial skills or any type of customer service etiquette. Again I wish them well but I will not be spending any money there and anyone that I know who was going there I will direct them to go some place else. So sad because you have these businesses in your neighborhood and you try to support and keep them afloat. I was warned before but I guess I had to see for myself.

… more

Sam b
Worst $6 i ever spent.. i got chicken tenders they looked n tasted like dragon tails.. the mash potatoes were stiff with no taste

… more

Is This A Reference
Food is good enough for the price like their ribs are good the first few times(they’re a bit too fatty for me plus the sauce is a bit tangy in a weird way though not bad) but you can tell the waffle fries and chicken wings are frozen.

… more

S Kenney (SK)
Where should I begin. This is one of my favorite places to go for amazing wings and ribs. The service is nice and friendly. Did I already say that the food is absolutely incredible. Every chance I get, the wings and ribs are a must have. O highly recommend Chicken Holiday in Baldwin NY. I tried a Chicken Holiday in NJ and I was shocked they were allowed to use the name. Of you haven’t already tried this place, trust me, you won’t be disappointed.

… more

Miss Simon
Bri and Dee were absolutely helpful and professional. If you need any suggestion on what to eat they will help the food is freshly cooked and was reasonably priced compare to the other fast food chicken spots. The coleslaw could’ve been better but to eaches own!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions