Based on 154 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price
Address:
127 Main St, Donnelly, ID 83615
Phone: (208) 325-4040
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Spencer Smith
The prices are really good on the burgers and the pizza is normal. We got a 17 dollar combo and it was enough for 3 to 4 adults. The pizza is really good. Not just good for a small town but this would be my go to place if they were in Boise. A few things that stood out were and EXTREMELY clean restaurant and they use real parmesean in the shakers. Not any of the Kraft junk. The attention to detail is great and I will be coming back.
… more
Taylor Daily
If I could give Mainstreet Pizza 6 stars I would. Pizza and salad are wonderful. Perfect place for the family. Friendly fast service! I am coming back next time I am near Donnelly. The pizza is dense, we have 8 adults and 6 kids and the 2 extra large pizzas, 5 salads and 6 garlic bread was a good amount of food for us.
… more
Donna Carter
This is simple the best pizza. Went there Tuesday night an hour before they closed and had a great meal. Haven’t been able to stop thinking about the pizza since. Despite other reviews about the service being slow, it’s not slow, the pizza is made fresh. If you want fast food speed in your service then drive through a Pizza Hut. But if you want to eat awesome fresh homemade pizza you need to go here. The rest of the food is really good too.
… more
Jose negrete
This was our go to spot whenever we came to our home in the area. Great pizza and burgers! Just stopped by after a day on the lake and found out that they are only open for breakfast and lunch, with no pizza!? Very disappointed. Always ate here instead of McCall to support a truly local business. Hope that they bring back dinner hours and most definitely the pizzas.
… more
Dan Quakenbush
My family and I have eaten here twice and have really enjoyed it each time. The pizza is made with quality ingredientand the crust rocks. We also really like the wings. The service is quick and the prices are the best in Donnelly.
… more
Jesus Guevara
They currently dont do pizza, but burgers are big and delicious. Great customer service even when they were packed. But dont show up an hour before closing on a busy day. Place closes at 2pm and they are stern on it, they earn the work they put in. Breakfast meals looked delicious as well. Next time.
… more
Ben Bennett
This is definitely a good place to visit if you pass through Donnelly. The pizza is fantastic! They also have burgers and fries, or sandwiches and salads. The soda machine is not the best, however. I had a diet Coke and it was very flat…. Almost undrinkable. Kory was our server, and she was so good to us while managing her other tables. They get very busy, so if you want a pizza in the summer, go in around 5pm or so.
… more
Ryan Kerby
Pizza was great, the wait was kind of long, but we went right at dinner time. It’s a small pizza parlor with limited seating. They do allow for you to call in and take out, which we might do in the future. Portions are good, we ordered a 10″ and pretty sure it was more like a 12″ pizza!
… more
Ryan McMullen
I am still surprised this places in business. Three times we went in there and we were discouraged service by the owner or completely ignored. We decided to go elsewhere but as soon as the Prime season ended she was more than willing to take our money.
… more
Vicky Evans
One of the worst pizzas I have ever eaten and unpleasant atmosphere.
… more
… View more