A fun friendly atmosphere with a bit of an upscale feel. Our basic philosophy was to go back to “basics”, we make everything from scratch using all fresh ingredients, bake our own breads and desserts, and make all of our stocks. We pride ourselves on great food and friendly professional service.
Upscale American fare & wood-fired pizza in both a semi-formal dining room & laid-back bar area. Based on 485 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
21 S Lake St, Elkhart Lake, WI 53020
Phone: (920) 876-2142
Website: http://www.lakestreetcafe.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lauren Topel
Fun atmosphere inside and outdoors. Inside there is a big mural of the beer founders. They need way more staff. Crazy wait times even when we came at 5. No leftovers because it was good food but also not huge portions.
… more
Tina Schmidt
We had a delicious scallop appetizer! It’s flavors were explosive. Then shared a pear pizza, which was delicious. The crust was crisp and the toppings were perfectly spread out. We also shared the salmon sandwich. It was served open faced and done with cream cheese and greens. I would highly recommend this location for lunch or dinner! Also, try the specialty drinks!
… more
Paige Turner
Went for dinner. Ordered the sea bass. Very nice could have been a little tastier. Beware that soda is not free refills. Prices are fine dine prices, however the atmosphere is more eclectic pizza joint vibe. Outside seating is on a gravel and matted grass area. The chairs are plastic and could be more comfortable.
… more
Wes Nemec
Really enjoyed the lake Street Cafe, hate to deduct an entire star for slow service, but it was noticeably slow. Our server was super nice, we were seated immediately, and the food was good, but it took a while between visits to take orders, and then it took a very long time for the food to arrive. And not like we ordered something fancy or complicated, me and my companion both ordered sandwiches and it took what felt like 45 minutes for them to come out. We sat outside, not sure if that had something to do with it but overall a very nice experience other than just taking a while.
… more
Cali Simes
We ate here on 4th of July this past holiday. It was packed but everyone was KIND and FRIENDLY and the food was delicious and the staff was great
… more
Gino Montoya
Food was all very good but seemed like they skimped on the good part in every dish and for the price that didn’t seem fair. Buratta only four half slices of toast and an overflowing plate of greens. Abura only about 8 pieces of octopus(although the fried kale was good, overflowing with kale). Orecchiette Con Carne maybe 4 pieces of sausage. Everyone else at my table had the same gripe, too sparing with the good stuff.
… more
Renee Thiede
Good food. Had a mule made with super flat ginger beer…. Let them know. Made a new one… much better. Must have been a flat can on the first one. Ended up charging us for both anyway. Just pay attention to your bill
… more
Brandon Polhemus
Unbelievably good. The complimentary bread is OUT OF THIS WORLD. They bake it themselves and is worth the price of admission. I never would have dreamed that this level of dining would be available in such a small, quaint town. (Which by the way is equally amazing) Jasmine (sp?) is an excellent server and made sure to make our time as exquisite as possible. If 6 stars was an option, Lake Street Cafe deserves it.
… more
Rachael Pullin Averill
Food was great. Want to go back soon, so I can try something else because everything on the menu sounded great.
… more
Keith Oliver
Lake Street Cafe is phenomenal. Every time we attend races at Road America we find an evening to have supper here. I try a new item every time I’m there and I’ve never been disappointed. Service is fantastic. Definitely recommend!
… more
… View more