Are you in the mood for a casual dining experience with live music and a laid-back atmosphere? The Fish offers quality seafood and American cuisine all while overlooking the water in Bemus Point, NY. If you’ve got a boat on the Chautauqua Lake, slide up to our floating bar on the dock for a good time. Start off your Sunday on the lake with a spicy bloody mary and stay for lunch while watching the game.
Based on 515 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
61 Lakeside Dr, Bemus Point, NY 14712
Phone: (716) 386-1210
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ray Q
The food was slow. A beer took 25 minutes to get to the table. The food and was just ok. We waited over an hour for food. I got the prime rib sandwich and it was very dry and overcooked. The view is amazing!
… more
Suzanne Parisi
An amazing stop! They have a beautiful covered deck with an incredible view. We had great food, friendly service and enjoyed everything about the visit. They are super dog friendly.
… more
madeline corsini
Walked in at 6pm on a beautiful Sunday evening. Resturant almost empty. This should have been our first clue. Promptly seat by the window, and hostess brought us water. Sat 25 minutes no waitress. Asked host if a waitress could be sent to out table. Another 15 minutes still no waitress. Sorry, for two people with lots of patience, this doesn’t cut it. Y”all won’t last for long with such poor service. Never again.
… more
rob
All can eat crab was delicious and always hot! Wonderful view of lake. Service was good.
… more
Mark Tevis
Stopped for drinks while walking around Bemus Point. The service is always excellent at The Fish and it has the best views of the lake. We will definitely visit again over the summer months.
… more
Jeff Depew (JD)
Great spot on the lake with some great food. Wings, wraps & pretzel bites are delicious for appetizers & sandwiches. Steak is also really good. They have a great bar on the water outside & another bar downstairs that is great to eat & drink at. Corn hole games outside w/ chairs to relax in too. Awesome spot
… more
Kristin Rhoades
Passing through the area on October 9th, 2022. Did some shopping and decided to have lunch at The Fish. BEAUTIFUL VIEW, great menu, clean restaurant. Will not give 5 stars due to lack of service by Trisha H. All the food was delicious! Sadly the soup and Chicken Fettuccine were luke warm. Trisha was a sarcastic and very inattentive server. We pretty much let her be, but needed a drink refill, she said she had to help in the kitchen. We waited and waited for to see if we need anything else or the bill. She was nowhere to be found. Took the bill to the hostess and she finally showed up. The restaurant seemed to have a just a hostess and Trisha and maybe a cook working. No manager on board unless Trisha did it all? If so, she should have explained the situation. I would go back, but Trisha was terrible. Yes, we still left her a decent tip!
… more
Lisa Royek
I read the reviews and chose to ignore the negatives but they were all correct. Very slow, mediocre food/ salad had limp lettuce. Waitress was nice but didn’t even ask if we wanted dessert. Lots of people running around but no toilet paper in the restroom ( at least one stall). Very pricey for what we got. Across the street was super busy and Fish was not at all. Should have trusted the crowd. Not a good experience. ☹️
… more
Connie Anderson
This restaurant has been under very poor management for the past few years. Although it still has gorgeous lake views, the food and service are just not good at all. Unfortunately, it is absolutely nothing like the old beloved Italian Fisherman that it used to be.
… more
Elaine Harshbarger
Great view, staff very welcoming, and good food, overall a great experience!
… more
… View more