It is our goal to handcraft every pizza with the highest quality ingredients from our family to yours. At J&J’s Pizza Shack we strive to give our customers an enjoyable dining experience. All of our pizzas are made fresh, so you and your family can enjoy what matters most- each other.
Family-owned pizzeria serving thin- & thick-crust pies, plus wings & subs in casual digs. Based on 356 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1454 Lincolnway, Valparaiso, IN 46385
Phone: (219) 476-1616
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Friday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–12 AM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Linda Parker
Their stuffed crust kitchen sink is my ALL time favorite pizza! I live about 2 hours away so every time I get up that way I gotta grab a pizza.
… more
Opal Beauty
Pizza is ok. I don’t like that the pizza is not in a box. The latest one came to us with the cheese pushed around from something laying on top of it. I know doing it this way is probably cheaper but I’m not a fan.
… more
Lisa Remus
Who doesn’t love J&J’s Pizza Shack?!? We grew up eating it. They have many restaurants and when I was a kid, we always ordered from the Lake Station restaurant. They also have ones in Hobart and Portage as well. I’m trying to describe how their pizza tastes, and if you’ve ever had Mr. T’s pizza (in Hobart), it’s like that. They have GREAT chef salads too. Deep fried cauliflower, mushrooms, mozzarella sticks, hot wings, etc. They never disappoint.
… more
Pete
This is by far the worst jj’s location. Pizza was terrible, and the wings were burnt with no sauce. Giving two stars because the delivery came quick that was the only positive. Lake station has the best jjs location, order from them.
… more
mitch gilbert
Pizza is decent, but don’t ever believe the wait times are accurate for pickup. Three times in a row my food hasn’t been ready for over an hour when picking up, but they say it will be ready in about 40 minutes. Orders were never complex either. It takes longer to pickup then it does to have it delivered.
… more
Jim Whitaker
Had the beef , flavor was good but needed more beef . I paid extra for extra beef too. Delivery driver was fast and nice . Food was hot
… more
Charles Criscuolo
Great service, excellent Italian sausage sandwich. Served on a toasted roll, nice twist on tradition. Lots of great flavors in each bite.
… more
Katie Wleklinski
Ordered 4 party pizzas for our wedding from the VALPO jjs! Best service ever! They didn’t have to deliver it, but they did. Thank you so much!!!
… more
Denny Marrell
Ordered a pizza and a beef sandwich for dinner. The beef sandwich with beef on bun. No pickles no pepperoncini no au jus. What a let down.
… more
Michael Tarrant
Been a long time customer. This USED to be the best pizza around. Lately, I have been getting food that is way over cooked. Just today I received my order after waiting an hour for delivery. The pizza was not what I ordered. When I called, I got hung up on. Called back and spoke to the “manager”, who told me that they would remake my order, but I would have to wait another 60-70 minutes. This just might have been my last visit to any JJ’s…atleast until they get new management and things back in order. Quality of food and service has really dropped over the last few years.
… more
… View more