Chicago-style stuffed pizza is the draw at this restaurant also offering thin-crust pies & pastas. Based on 89 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1840 E Lincoln Hwy, New Lenox, IL 60451
Phone: (815) 485-9700
Hours
| Sunday | 3–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 3:30–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 3:30–9 PM |
| Thursday | 3:30–9 PM |
| Friday | 3–10 PM |
| Saturday | 3–10 PM |
Reviews
Shirl Boatman
The stuffed pizza is always good. We did have to wait a little longer than normal for our pizza; however, when picking it up, it was explained that when they took it out of the oven, it didn’t meet their expectations for being fully cooked. They placed it back in the over for more cooking thereby allowing us to have an amazing pizza.
… more
Mark Ott
I worked here delivering pizza and was treated so poorly by manager ! It was raining and sleeting and she told her to hurry up and was being timed… I’m a Sr citizen and have been in management my whole life…I found this appalling I made the delivery in a timely fashion and she didn’t have any regard for my safety so I quit !!! BBB has been notified. Owner called me and said sorry I couldn’t get along with her Manager lmbo
… more
M B
Nancy’s has always been our got to for pizza very fresh ingredients and also hot and delicious. Thought only in Alsip, but there’s one in New Lenox. Omg far down the best pizza.
… more
Judith Knapp
Price of the garbage salad has become ridiculous. I use to order regularly. No longer affordable for the size.
… more
Virtue Reclaimed
Something in my pizza tasted sour. Sent me to the bathroom a few times. The later on, I ate the godfather sandwich that made me feel sick. They must have used fresh mozzarella because it was super thick and felt like it was stuck inside my chest until the next night.
… more
D S
I’ve been ordering Nancy’s for years. Love their stuffed pizza, which I order at least once a month. Minor issue with the last order…my extra sauce was forgotten. When I called back to inquire about stopping in the next day to get my sauce, the young man on the phone informed me they were closed the next day due to short staffing. Completely understandable. The ‘older’ delivery person is always courteous. He even thanked me for my generous tip a couple of months ago. I believe in tipping generously…especially during the pandemic. I will continue to order Nancy’s. I should try the thin crust more often. Perhaps next time.
… more
Holly Wysong
I have been getting pizza from this location with my family most of my life . To say the least we are addicted to our pizza haha . The staff has always been welcoming, friendly and the food constantly amazing . If you have not had it yet I suggest you run and get try it . I love this place and I can’t say thank you enough to the amazing staff and wonderful owner who holds the standard of true chicago pizza
… more
Claudia Patti
Hands down the best pizza! My favorite is the Northern Italian Veggie pizza. Recently tried the Chicago Beef; it’s become my family’s favorite! Nancy’s crispy pizza crust is so delicious!!! The owners are the nicest people providing outstanding customer service! If you’re looking for great food and a pleasant dining experience, I highly recommend Nancy’s Pizza!!!
… more
Michelle I
Fresh, hot and delicious!!! You pay more but you get more in every delicious bite! Nice people work there so I’ll keep coming back!
… more
Leah Lacher
The thin crust pizza and garbage salad here are never disappointing.
… more
… View more