Based on 134 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
1420 Mountaineer Cir, New Cumberland, WV 26047
Phone: (304) 387-8000
Website: https://www.cnty.com/mountaineer/food-drink/gatsbyrestaurant
Hours
| Wednesday | 12–7 PM |
| Thursday | 12–7 PM |
| Friday | 12–9 PM |
| Saturday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 8 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 12–7 PM |
| Tuesday | 12–7 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jason markowski
Server was nice and so was the hostess, but it took a long time to get our food. Could be under staffed, I’m not sure. Potatoes did come out a little on the cold side so makes me wonder how long it was sitting. We will be back though
… more
Ross F
Service was okay they weren’t very accommodating. Food was warm and reminded me of a cafeteria.
… more
Joyce Mcbride
Sausage gravy and biscuits as well as pancakes were cold, and refills were not offered we told the waitress who said I’ll have the manager come over. Noone ever came except to bring the bill. We ate literally none of our food just paid them to throw it out.
… more
Debbie Ritter
This was the salad that was served. Not one bite was eaten. Looked like it was leftover from someone else’s meal. Used to like taking the ride down here. Not really any reason to go anymore. Food was not up to par, was not busy. Seems like they are dying out fast.
… more
Frank Cole
The food is good and servers are helpful. They are open limited hours, so check ahead of time. The menu is not large but adequate. Pricing is average.
… more
Barbara Yuzwa
My Cobb salad was wonderful. There was enough salad for three people. My husband’s fish was just so so. I really miss the buffet and a real breakfast in the morning that you can sit down to eat and enjoy
… more
Morgan Vice
Friendly and prompt service and the Reuben sandwich I had was pretty good
… more
H Gil
They have gone deeply down hill. And they don’t care. Food is terrible. And they dont care. Thinking not soon be out of business. It’s a real shame they used to be our to go to place. Then the pandemic hit. They have not got there heads on right since then. As a whole Mountaineer casino and race track will be closed in by next year.
… more
Bill Hamilton
Sat after ordering cheese sticks for 30 minutes. Restaurant was only at half occupied. Sever came to my table only to deliver food never to ask how it was or refills pift. Definitely don’t recommend
… more
Sugar Laing
Service was good. Our waitress was very kind and prompt. We were seated quickly and served quickly. The quality of food was low. Fries were not good. The fish and chips was just one large deep battered cod filet that ended up tasting quite fishy. The Philly sandwich was bland. Overall not a delicious meal. We were disappointed in the food but must say the Service was prompt and the employees were kind.
… more
… View more