Mitchell's Restaurant Menu - Valley Stream, NY

Longtime eatery offering booth & counter seats, all-day American fare & homemade ice cream. Based on 927 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Mitchell's Restaurant 11580

Address:
191 Rockaway Ave, Valley Stream, NY 11580

Phone: (516) 825-9708

Website:

Hours

Tuesday	8 AM–10 PM
Wednesday	8 AM–10 PM
Thursday	8 AM–10 PM
Friday	8 AM–10 PM
Saturday	8 AM–10 PM
Sunday	8 AM–10 PM
Monday	8 AM–10 PM

Beverages
Coffee	$2.95
Tea	$2.95
Herbal Tea	$3.25
Milk	$3.25
Chocolate Milk	$3.50
Hot Chocolate Comes with whipped cream.	$2.95
Iced Coffee	$3.25
Fresh Squeezed Orangeade	$4.00
Fresh Squeezed Lemonade	$4.00
Seltzer	$1.95
Assorted Fountain Drink	$3.50
Small Juice Orange, grapefruit, tomato, apple, pineapple, cranberry, V-8	$3.25
Large Juice Orange, grapefruit, tomato, apple, pineapple, cranberry, V-8	$4.25
Mimosa	$8.00
Bellini	$8.00
Cereals
Hot Oatmeal	$3.95
Grits	$3.95
Add Banana	$1.00
Add Raisins	$1.00
Add Fresh Strawberries	$3.00
Bagel Bin
Toasted Jumbo Bagel	$2.60
Philly Cream Cheese Bagel	$3.55
Nova Scotia Lox Bagel	$12.95
Nova Scotia Lox And Cream Cheese Bagel	$14.95
Toasted Jumbo Bagel All The Way Served with lox, cream cheese and all the trimmings.	$14.95
Toasted Jumbo Bagel All The Way For Two	$22.95
From the Griddle
Golden Brown Pancakes	$8.95
Short Stack Of Pancakes	$8.25
Silver Dollar Pancakes	$8.95
Challah French Toast	$8.95
Old Fashioned French Toast	$8.95
Belgian Waffle	$8.95
Golden Brown Pancakes With Bacon, Ham Or Sausage	$11.25
Golden Brown Pancakes With Canadian Bacon	$11.50
Golden Brown Pancakes With Apple Preserve	$9.75
Golden Brown Pancakes With Fresh Strawberries	$11.50
Golden Brown Pancakes With Two Eggs Any Style	$10.25
Golden Brown Pancakes Deluxe With Bacon, Ham And Sausage	$11.95
Challah French Toast With Bacon, Ham Or Sausage	$11.25
Challah French Toast With Canadian Bacon	$11.50
Challah French Toast With Apple Preserves	$9.75
Challah French Toast With Fresh Strawberries	$11.50
Challah French Toast With Two Eggs, Any Style	$9.95
Challah French Toast Deluxe With Bacon, Ham And Sausage	$11.95
Belgian Waffle With Bacon, Ham Or Sausage	$11.25
Belgian Waffle With Canadian Bacon	$11.50
Belgian Waffle With Apple Preserves	$9.75
Belgian Waffle With Fresh Strawberries	$11.50
Belgian Waffle With Two Eggs Any Style	$10.95
Belgian Waffle Deluxe With Bacon, Ham And Sausage	$11.95
Chicken & Waffle	$15.50
Nutella Pancakes, Challah French Toast Or Belgian Waffle	$10.45
Eggs and Omelettes
2 Eggs Any Style Served with home fries & toast.	$7.95
2 Eggs With Bacon	$10.50
2 Eggs With Ham	$10.50
2 Eggs With Sausage	$10.50
2 Eggs With Canadian Bacon	$10.75
2 Eggs With Corned Beef Hash	$10.75
Western Omelette	$11.95
Spanish Omelette	$11.95
Garden Omelette	$11.95
Leo Omelette Lox, eggs and onion	$13.95
Virginia Ham Steak And 2 Eggs	$16.95
New York Sirloin Steak And 2 Eggs Any Style	$25.95
Skirt Steak And 2 Eggs Any Style	$25.50
Eggs Benedict Two poached eggs, Canadian bacon and toasted English muffin, topped with hollandaise sauce and home fries.	$12.95
Healthy Choice Two poached eggs on a bed of spinach and dry whole wheat toast.	$8.95
Create Your Own Omelette	$8.95
Add American, Swiss, Cheddar, Mozzerella Or Feta Each cheese added $1.50	$1.50
Add Peppers, Mushrooms, Spinach, Onions, Broccoli Or Tomato Each vegetable added $1.50	$1.50
Add Bacon, Ham, Sausage, Pastrami, Corned Beef Or Canadian Bacon Each meat added $1.50	$1.50
Breakfast Sides
Bacon	$4.40
Ham	$4.40
Sausage	$4.40
Canadian Bacon	$4.50
Corned Beef Hash	$4.95
Home Fries	$4.25
Homemade Muffins	$2.40
Buttered Toast	$2.25
Buttered Roll	$2.25
Toasted English Muffin	$2.50
Turkey Sausage	$4.40
Turkey Bacon	$4.50
Fruit Salad	$5.35
Appetizers
Buffalo Wings Comes with bleu cheese dressing.	$10.95
Chicken Tenders Comes with marinara sauce.	$10.95
Mozzarella Sticks Comes with marinara sauce.	$9.95
Onion Rings Comes with special sauce.	$8.50
Spinach Pie Spinach and feta cheese wrapped in filo.	$10.50
Buffalo Wings With French Fries	$13.50
Chicken Tenders With French Fries	$13.50
Potato Skins Comes with bacon and melted cheddar cheese, served with sour cream.	$10.50
Sampler Served with choice of three appetizers.	$15.95
Soups
Crock Of French Onion Soup	$6.95
Pint Of Soup To Go	$4.50
Quart Of Soup To Go	$8.00
Salads
Caesar Salad Romaine lettuce, croutons, Parmesan and Caesar dressing.	$12.95
Greek Salad Iceberg lettuce, cucumbers, green peppers, tomatoes, olives, radishes, Bermuda onions, feta cheese and grape leaves.	$12.95
Authentic Greek Salad Romaine lettuce, fresh dill, scallions and feta cheese, mixed with a homemade vinaigrette dressing.	$12.95
Mediterranean Salad Lightly steamed broccoli, string beans, mushrooms, zucchini, Bermuda onions, tomatoes and croutons.	$12.95
Chef’s Salad Virginia ham, turkey, roast beef, Swiss cheese, American cheese julienne style, with lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, olives and sliced hard boiled egg and choice of dressing.	$17.95
East End Salad Grilled wild salmon served over mixed greens with chickpeas, tomatoes and Gorgonzola cheese with balsamic vinaigrette dressing.	$22.95
Saratoga Salad Breaded juicy chicken breast served over crisp romaine lettuce with sweet raisins, Monterey Jack and cheddar cheese with fat-free honey mustard dressing.	$17.95
Spinach Salad Marinated grilled chicken served over fresh spinach with sliced egg, crispy bacon bits, mushrooms, tomatoes, Bermuda onions and choice of dressing.	$17.95
Oriental Chicken Salad Marinated grilled chicken breast over mixed greens with oranges and crispy chow mein noodles, sesame Oriental dressing.	$17.95
Tuscany Salad Marinated grilled chicken served over mixed greens, mozzarella cheese, roasted peppers, tomatoes and imported olives and balsamic vinaigrette dressing.	$17.95
Mitchell’s Salad Marinated grilled chicken, served over crisp romaine lettuce with chunks of oranges and sweet raisins and fat-free raspberry vinaigrette dressing.	$17.95
Cold Salad Platters
Super Combo Salad Platter A scoop of chicken, tuna and egg salad on a bed of lettuce with garnish.	$14.95
Egg Salad Platter	$10.95
Tuna Salad Platter	$12.95
Chicken Salad Platter	$12.95
Crabmeat Salad Platter	$13.95
Burgers
Beef Burger Served with Cole Slaw or Macaroni Salad & Pickle	$8.50
Turkey Burger	$8.50
Twin Beef Burger Deluxe	$15.95
Pizza Burger	$9.50
Add Cheese	$1.00
Add Bacon	$1.75
Add Fried Onions, Tomato Or Sauteed Mushrooms & Onion	$0.75
Specialty Burgers
Valley Stream Burger Swiss cheese, sauteed mushrooms and onions, french fries and onion rings.	$13.50
Rockville Center Burger Cheddar cheese, bacon and BBQ sauce with french fries.	$13.50
Five Towns Burger Strips of bacon and bleu cheese dressing and potato salad.	$13.50
Patty Melt Burger American cheese, sauteed mushrooms and onions on grilled rye bread with french fries.	$13.50
Salmon Burger Ground fresh salmon on a toasted bun and tzatziki sauce with a Greek salad.	$15.50
Chicken Burger Ground chicken breast on a toasted bun with a Greek salad.	$11.95
Our Famous Veggie Burger On a toasted pita with a tossed salad.	$13.50
Panini Hot Pressed Sandwiches
Portobello And Spinach Panini Portobello mushrooms, fresh spinach and mozzarella cheese.	$14.95
Turkey Panini Sliced white meat turkey, mozzarella cheese, roasted red peppers and herb mayo.	$15.95
Eggplant Panini Grilled eggplant with mushrooms, onions, zucchini and hummus.	$14.95
Skirt Steak Panini Charbroiled skirt steak, onions, mushrooms, mozzarella cheese and herb mayo.	$20.95
Chicken And Portobello Panini Grilled chicken, portobello mushrooms, tomato, roasted red peppers, mozzarella cheese and herb mayo.	$15.95
Chicken Cutlet Panini Chicken cutlet, tomatoes, mozzarella cheese and herb mayo.	$15.95
Wraps
Chicken Wrap Grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, sun dried tomatoes, roasted peppers and mozzarella cheese with a delicious vinaigrette dressing.	$13.95
Greek Wrap Greek salad.	$12.95
Grilled Veggie Wrap Grilled zucchini, tomatoes, onions, peppers and mushrooms.	$12.95
Steak Tips Wrap Sliced steak tips with grilled mushrooms, onions, peppers and melted mozzarella.	$19.95
Tuna Or Chicken Salad Wrap Comes with lettuce and tomatoes.	$12.95
Chicken Caesar Wrap Grilled chicken breast with shredded parmesan cheese, romaine lettuce and caesar dressing.	$13.95
Quesadillas
Steak Quesadilla Sliced skirt steak, onions and monterey jack and cheddar cheese.	$20.50
Chicken Quesadilla Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, monterey jack and cheddar cheese.	$15.50
Southern Quesadilla Grilled chicken, jalapeno peppers, monterey jack and cheddar cheese.	$15.50
Veggie Quesadilla Grilled zucchini, mushrooms, peppers, onions, tomatoes, monterey jack and cheddar cheese.	$14.95
Simple Sandwiches
Grilled Cheese Sandwich	$6.95
B.L.T. Sandwich Bacon, lettuce and tomato.	$8.50
Chicken Salad Sandwich	$8.50
Egg Salad Sandwich	$8.50
Tuna Salad Sandwich	$8.50
Crabmeat Salad Sandwich	$8.95
Grilled Cheese With Bacon, Ham Or Sausage	$7.95
Grilled Cheese With Tomato	$7.25
Club Sandwiches
Turkey Club Sandwich Sliced turkey, bacon, lettuce and tomato.	$13.50
Roast Beef Club Sandwich Bacon, lettuce and tomato.	$13.50
Virginia Ham Club Sandwich Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato.	$13.50
Tuna Salad Club Sandwich Sliced eggs, lettuce and tomato.	$12.50
Chicken Salad Club Sandwich Bacon, lettuce and tomato.	$12.50
Chicken Sandwiches
Grilled Chicken Sandwich On a garlic roll with lettuce and tomato.	$13.95
Grilled Chicken Sandwich With Cheddar Cheese And Bacon On a garlic roll, with melted cheddar cheese, bacon, lettuce and tomato.	$15.50
Grilled Chicken Sandwich With Mozzarella Cheese And Marinara Sauce On a garlic roll with melted mozzarella cheese, marinara sauce, lettuce and tomato.	$15.50
Grilled Chicken Sandwich With BBQ Sauce On a garlic roll with BBQ sauce, lettuce and tomato.	$15.50
Breaded Chicken Cutlet Sandwich On Italian bread with melted mozzarella cheese, marinara sauce, lettuce and tomato.	$15.50
Grilled Chicken Sandwich On Pita With Greek Salad On a pita with Greek salad and tzatziki sauce.	$15.50
Specialty Sandwiches
Monte Cristo Sandwich French toast topped with grilled Virginia ham, white meat turkey and melted Swiss cheese, served with potato salad.	$15.95
Reuben Sandwich Corned beef or grilled pastrami with sauerkraut on rye bread topped with melted swiss cheese, served with potato salad.	$15.95
Skirt Steak Sandwich Char broiled open sliced skirt steak on a toasted garlic roll, served with lettuce, tomato and french fries.	$19.75
Marco Polo Sandwich White meat turkey, strips of bacon, sauteed mushrooms and onions, topped with melted swiss cheese on a toasted roll, served with potato salad.	$15.95
Fried Shrimp Sandwich Lettuce, tomato on a toasted bun, served with french fries.	$20.95
Christopher Columbus Sandwich Hot roast sirloin of beef, melted mozzarella cheese on a toasted roll, served with french fries.	$15.95
Thomas Edison Sandwich Hot grilled pastrami, melted swiss cheese on a toasted roll, served with french fries.	$15.95
Benjamin Franklin Sandwich Grilled chicken breast on a toasted garlic roll with melted cheddar cheese, served with french fries.	$15.95
Archimedes Sandwich Grilled chicken breast on a toasted pita, served with Greek salad.	$15.95
Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich Sirloin of beef with grilled peppers, mushrooms, onions and melted american cheese on a toasted garlic roll, served with french fries.	$15.95
Hot Open Sandwiches
Sliced Turkey Sandwich All white meat. Served with soup or salad, gravy, potato & vegetable	$19.95
Roast Sirloin Of Beef Sandwich Served with soup or salad, gravy, potato & vegetable	$19.95
Brisket Of Beef Sandwich	$18.50
The Carving Board
Corned Beef Carving Board	$10.75
Pastrami Carving Board	$10.75
Roast Turkey Carving Board	$10.75
Virginia Ham Carving Board	$10.75
Roast Sirloin Of Beef Carving Board	$10.75
Brisket Carving Board	$10.75
Entrees
Roasted Fresh Turkey Entree Served with dressing, cranberry sauce, potato and vegetable.	$21.50
Fried Chicken In A Basket Entree Served with french fries.	$16.50
Grilled Breast Of Chicken Entree Served with potato and vegetable.	$17.50
Broiled Chunks Of Chicken Breast Entree Topped with grilled vegetables over rice.	$18.95
Roast Half Chicken Entree Served with dressing, applesauce, potato and vegetable.	$18.95
Frankfurters Served with baked beans and french fries.	$14.50
Quiche Served with Greek salad. Options: Lorraine, Broccoli Cheddar, Spinach Cheddar.	$14.50
Steaks and Chops
Broiled Center Cut Pork Chops	$21.95
Broiled Beef Liver Comes with sauteed onion or bacon.	$18.95
Char Broiled Chopped Steak Comes with onion rings.	$18.95
Char Broiled Turkey Chopped Steak Comes with onion rings.	$18.95
Broiled N.Y. Cut Sirloin Steak With Mushrooms Served with soup or salad, potato & vegetable	$29.95
Broiled Black Angus Skirt Steak With Onion Rings Served with soup or salad, potato & vegetable	$29.95
Seafood
Land And Sea Char broiled skirt steak with two jumbo shrimp stuffed with crab meat.	$29.95
Broiled Wild Salmon	$26.50
Broiled White Sea Bass	$21.95
Broiled Tilapia	$20.95
Jumbo Shrimp Scampi	$29.95
Mediterranean
Spanakopita Spinach and feta wrapped in filo. Served over rice, with choice of soup or salad.	$17.50
Chicken Souvlaki Platter Broiled chunks of chicken breast on a toasted pita with onions and tomatoes. Served with Greek salad and choice of french fries or rice.	$17.50
Pork Souvlaki Platter Pork souvlaki on a toasted pita with onions and tomatoes. Served with Greek salad, an choice of french fires or rice.	$17.50
Gyro Platter Sliced gyro meat on a toasted pita with onions and tomatoes. Served with Greek salad, and choice of french fries or rice.	$17.50
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Served with choice of pasta, and your choice of soup or salad.	$21.50
Eggplant Parmigiana Served with choice of pasta, and your choice of soup or salad.	$17.95
Spaghetti Comes with meat sauce, and your choice of soup or salad.	$15.95
Pasta and Sauteed Specialties
Shrimp Santorini Jumbo shrimp sauteed with white wine, feta cheese and fresh tomatoes in a light marinara sauce over rice.	$28.95
Chicken Francaise Sauteed chicken breast in a lemon butter sauce with broccoli and zucchini over rice or linguini	$21.50
Chicken Marsala Sauteed chicken breast in a marsala wine sauce with mushrooms over rice or linguini	$21.50
Mediterranean Delight Sauteed broccoli, mushrooms, zucchini, string beans and cauliflower in a light marinara sauce with white wine, feta cheese, fresh garlic and tomatoes over rice.	$17.95
Chicken Madeira Sauteed chicken breast in a madeira wine sauce, topped with asparagus and mozzarella over mashed potatoes.	$21.50
Chicken A La Vodka Sauteed chunks of chicken breast in a light pink vodka sauce over penne.	$21.50
Stir Fry Chicken Served with garden vegetable over rice.	$21.50
New Orleans Chicken Mildly spicy. Sauteed chunks of chicken breast with penne in a light cajun cream sauce.	$21.50
Side Orders
Dinner Greek Salad	$7.45
Dinner Caesar Salad	$7.45
Tossed Salad	$6.50
Potato	$3.50
Vegetable	$3.50
Potato Pancake	$6.50
Spaghetti	$7.95
French Fries	$4.75
French Fries With Melted Cheese	$5.65
Waffle Fries	$6.50
Waffle Fries With Melted Cheese	$7.30
Sweet Potato Fries	$6.40
Sweet Potato Fries With Melted Cheese	$7.50
Fountain Delights
Egg Cream	$3.25
Milk Shake	$6.50
Frosted Float	$6.50
Ice Cream Soda	$6.35
Soda Float	$6.35
Sundaes
Mitchell’s Sundae Choice of two scoops of ice cream covered with your choice of either vanilla, chocolate, cherry, root beer, walnut or coffee syrup, topped with whipped cream and cherry.	$8.25
Hot Fudge Sundae Choice of two scoops of ice cream topped with hot fudge, whipped cream and cherry.	$8.95
Caramel Sundae Choice of two scoops of ice cream with creamy caramel topping, whipped cream and cherry.	$8.95
Marshmallow Sundae Choice of two scoops of ice cream with gooey marshmallow topping, whipped cream and cherry.	$8.95
Chocolate Sprinkles Sundae Two scoops of chocolate ice cream with chocolate syrup, topped with whipped cream, cherry and oodles of sprinkles.	$8.95
Peanut Butter Cup Sundae Two scoops of vanilla ice cream covered with hot fudge and smooth peanut butter topping, topped with whipped cream, peanuts and cherry.	$8.95
Mallomar Sundae Two scoops of vanilla ice cream covered with hot fudge and gooey marshmallow topped with whipped cream and cherry.	$8.95
Milky Way Sundae Two scoops of vanilla ice cream covered with hot fudge and creamy caramel, topped with whipped cream and cherry.	$8.95
Banana Split Choice of three scoops of ice cream on top of sliced bananas, covered with scrumptious strawberry topping, whipped cream walnut, sprinkles and cherry.	$10.95
Royal Barge Waffle with vanilla and chocolate ice cream topped with hot fudge, strawberry topping, whipped cream, sprinkles and cherry.	$11.95
Around The World A delicious warm brownie with one scoop of vanilla ice cream topped hot fudge, walnuts, sprinkles, whipped cream and cherry.	$11.25
Mitchell’s Famous Buster Brown Two scoop of chocolate ice cream, chocolate syrup and creamy butterscotch topping with whipped cream, walnuts, sprinkles and cherry.	$10.95
Grilled Ice Cream Sandwich Grilled pound cake filled with vanilla and strawberry ice cream topped with caramel and chocolate syrup.	$10.95
Apple Crisp Delicious slices of apple covered with crumbs sprinkled with cinnamon, topped with vanilla ice cream, caramel topping and whipped cream.	$10.95
Pint Of Ice Cream	$5.75
Quart Of Ice Cream	$8.75
Desserts
Cheesecake	$5.50
Brownie	$3.25
Assorted Slice Of Pie Apple crumb pie.	$4.95
Chocolate Chip Cookie	$2.95
Jello Cherry Jello. With whipped cream.	$3.25
Chocolate Pudding Comes with whipped cream.	$3.25
Pound Cake	$2.75
Homemade Rice Pudding	$5.50
Add Scoop Of Ice Cream (Single)	$3.50
Add Scoop Of Ice Cream (Double)	$4.75

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Elisa T.

Short Version: Family-owned, classic style diner in a clean, modern atmosphere with quality food.

… more

Elyssia SV

Very warm and welcoming atmosphere. The salad dressing that comes with the Greek salad is amazing!!!! Food has great quality and everything was fresh! I will definitely be back!

… more

Val Foster

Breakfast was very good. Waitstaff kept circling. Came hungry & left full. Nice amount of food.

… more

Rhonda Singh

I was browsing Grubhub to place an order at this restaurant & called to ask about a special request not on the menu. The lady was professional & stated that the restaurant offered delivery services as well. I placed the order with the restaurant directly & was grateful I did. All the food tasted great & was packaged nicely. The delivery person was nice also informed me that I was out of their delivery area, to which I informed him that the lady said I could place it over the phone & it would be delivered. My order total was close to $100.

… more

rennae francis

Omg what a great place for brunch! First off, it’s huge! So there really wasn’t a wait. Secondly the servers were so friendly and the menu is also HUGE! SO MANY OPTIONS! I opted for the chicken and waffles and my fiancé had the french toast will eggs. All delicious. I also had a mimosa which was well made. Great portions! Will def re visit.

… more

Isabella Gonzalez

Very fast and friendly service, the food was amazing and one of the only times I’ve gone to a diner with free coffee refills and the coffee doesn’t taste like water.

… more

Claudio Woolley

Needed a place for breakfast and this place came up on the list. At 1st, I was not sure about it since it seemed empty from the outside. The facade of the restaurant is very nice. Upon entering, was greeted by the manager or owner with a slight accent. What a nice guy!!!! Also, was amazed how almost full the place was. You would not even suspect the amount of families eating inside based on the quietness of outside. As we were shown to our booth, all you can see with the waitresses were plates of all forms of eggs, pancakes and waffles; all looking good. The service is fast and furious. If you are hungry, they will have your plate ready in a matter of minutes. The coffee is fresh, the orange juice is plentiful and fresh. What is the final point is again the guy up front. As you see him seating people, cleaning tables, getting to go orders ready with so much energy and with a huge smile on his face.

… more

Kyndra S-H

Went for breakfast with my family and it was a great time. It was Saturday so it was very busy but still very good service. Everything is cooked the way you ask for it. And the staff was friendly and quick despite being so busy. Definitely will be back!

… more

Cameron Javed

Service was ok, but the food was just not good… (Bland, dry, cold). The prices were also pretty high, especially considering the quality of the food, and they take out their own tip. Safe to say this is my first and last time eating here…..

… more

Y.S. F.

Food was excellent.

… more

… View more

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Mitchell’s Restaurant Menu – Valley Stream, NY

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions