Based on 141 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
611 3rd St, Crested Butte, CO 81224
Phone: (970) 349-1110
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 3–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Christine Jacobs
In Crested Butte for a week and only found Mikey’s the last day! We had resorted to buying and cooking our own food because it was absurdly expensive to eat in town. THEN – we found this place!! We were riding bikes and each just got one piece of pizza – 4.00 each – which is what we pay in Maryland. Received a piece of pizza twice the size of a regular pizza and the crust – OH MY GOODNESS!! Thin, crust – delicious! I finished my pizza first and begged my husband for half of the crust left from his. When that sports center is finished – Mikey’s better be ready – because their business will explode!! Blessings to you at Miky’sfor keeping the true soul of good pizza and food – good business at a reasonable price. Crested Butte touts itself as a very liberal, anti big business – yea, yea, the small guy – and then demolishes the wallets of those that try to get a meal there. Mickey’s …they keep it real – they are what Crested Butte was supposed to be before their liberal agenda meant capitalism and they bought their Lexis! I have to come back someday only to see Micky’s – bless you – you are the salt of the earth and what makes this country great.
… more
John Kohler
Their NYC style crust is awesome! If you want a great pizza off the beaten path then this is your place. Service is always great and their pizzas never disappoint. Love their pepperoni and “The Meat Supreme”!
… more
Thomas Day
Great place for pizza or just a slice. Good selection of drinks (including canned Gatorade!) Customer experience could be improved if they asked folks not to park in the fire lane and idle exhaust into benches and tables where folks are eating.
… more
Ron Leet
Fantastic hidden gem in Crested Butte. Just off the main drag tucked into a small building across from the Skate park. The breakfast burrito is incredible and sized for 2 meals. Pizza by slice during lunch is a hard to beat on price and quality. Skip the lines and head to Miley’s for a great culinary experience.
… more
Jennifer Nieborg
Our daughter wanted pizza while we wanted to go downtown to a restaurant so it was perfect that they had pizza by the slice. She loved it and she is a pretty picky eater.
… more
Da Leigh
Delicious pizza at a great price! The slices are huge and the staff is super friendly.
… more
Daniel Mercier
Mikey’s is definitely known for they’re impeccable pizza. But let me tell you folks try the burger. The god damn burgers at Mikey’s are the things I dream about. I mean everything is all good, but treat yourself 😉 and branch out baby.
… more
Christopher Gerstner
This is the pizza and vibe you’re looking for, after a day on the mountain.
… more
Nolan Jensen
Pizza rolls were good. Glad I called ahead… Took them an hour to prepare. When I picked them up I was informed that the prices posted inside had not been updated in years, so the bill was about 50% more than anticipated. Rather than make a stink at the register, I have decided to passive aggressively share my experience with the world in the form of a negative review.
… more
Bryon Roland
The pasta is amazing! Coming back for sure!
… more
… View more