Based on 148 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2914 E Grange Ave, Cudahy, WI 53110
Phone: (414) 488-8007
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Joanne Michalski
My husband ordered two pizzas, an order of mozzarella sticks, and an order of cheese garlic bread for delivery. Fifteen minutes after the pizza was to be delivered my husband called and the gentleman said they don’t deliver, and we had to pick it up. It took a couple of days, but the manager did call my husband to apologize for the inconvenience and talk it out. Sounds like the manager thought there was a box for delivery unchecked on the website, but it turns out it wasn’t. We appreciated the phone call.
… more
Neal Letteney
I have to hand it to the folks at Pizza Pete’s. You might not expect it, given their humble location, but there’s so much that they do RIGHT. I spoke with the cook, Isaiah, and the delivery driver, Zion, while I waited for my order and asked them about their food and their processes. They make their dough and sauce on-site daily, they hand slice all their vegetables (even the mushrooms!), they season things according to their own recipes, and they make everything to order. I’m not sure why, but I expected frozen dough, premixed sauce, dry boxed sausage “product,” and cheapo cheese, among other common shortcuts. Wow, they proved me wrong!! I have attached a photo of my pizza, but I want to be clear that I ASKED Isaiah to leave it in the oven for an extra 3-4 minutes. That’s because I prefer a somewhat well-done pie. It’s notable that they’ll give you choices like that. I should mention that they do have a few tables on-site, presumably for the “pizza-by-the-slice” crowd – but you shouldn’t expect the ambiance of a true dine-in Italian restaurant. That’s not who they are, and it’s not who they try to be (if it’s a romantic night out you’re looking for, there are other nearby options). This is a carryout and delivery place with truly good house-made pizza. So, if you want a carryout pizza from a unique non-chain restaurant, give Pizza Pete’s a try. Their food competes well with other area pizzerias.
… more
Ashley Schreiner
Moved to Cudahy right across the street from Pizza Pete’s two wks ago. After a long day of moving, unpacking, etc, we ordered delivery…yes, we live right down the street but were very tired. $40 never got us so much food from a pizza joint (dbl order wings, xl pizza, mushrooms). Not only affordable but the food was amazing. And hello, another Friday night that I’m too worn out to cook, so Pizza Pete’s it is! *editing to add, the wings aren’t small at all AND the size of the sausage topping is HUGE!
… more
Terry Kloss
Its certainly a humble looking establishment, don’t let that stop you from ordering. Hand tossed pizza was fantastic. Topping a plenty, reminds me of pizza from my youth.
… more
Dee OhGee
I had a great Pepperoni pizza tonight. Erica makes a great thin crust and she provided excellent service. I’ll be coming back for more. And the chicken dinner is my normal go to. So need I say more….
… more
Heather Kamnetz
10+stars. Highly recommend. As 1st time customers ever and for delivery. 8/4/23. Outstanding customer service,chef and delivery staff. Phenomenal hand tossed Pizza crust. Generous toppings. Ours was. Sausage,fresh mushroom, onion,b.olive pizza. Perfectly baked pizza. Oder of Ckn strips. Are lightly breaded, juicy white meat&delicious. Side salad enoumous. Best Salad from a restaurant. Ive ever eaten. Truly Large enough for a family of 4. Has thinly sliced Red Onions, cucumbers,tomatoes,round sliced carrots,romaine lettuce. No Croutons. All was absolutely Delicious. My Fiance John&I. Will now be regular customers.
… more
Nate Fakler
Best stuffed crust I ever had, sauce is perfect for the acidity, and the toppings are fresh af. This is the real deal for a unique pie. NY style, Chicago style, it doesn’t matter, Pete’s style is on top!
… more
Megan Shallcross
First time ordering from here today and OMGOSH this place is it. Pizza was delicious and full of toppings. Huge cheesy Wonton wrapped Mozzarella sticks, and yummy garlic bread.
… more
Duane Ignasiak
Too bad you can’t eat the pictures,they really looked great. Got takeout today
… more
Roman Stanfill
I have literally been around the world and this is the best pizza I’ve had
… more
… View more