Based on 93 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
Address:
1174 Fischer Blvd Unit 1, Toms River, NJ 08753
Phone: (732) 503-4293
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Chuck Mound
If you are a Fan of Lobster, then you will love this place. Here is the delema, it leaves you wanting more. For $23, you are done in 3 bites. I understand the price of Lobster, so you can decide for yourself. I enjoyed the Connecticut Sandwich, just wanted more. It is an every now and then type of place. I will be back.
… more
Daralis HW
Really,really good eats. A bit pricey for the size of the roll especially when feeding 4 people. Non the less very good Italian, Main, Connecticut lobster roll sandwiches. Oh the chicken fingers and Yukon potatoes were yummy as well.
… more
Mike A
First visit and will not be our last. West Coast Turkey sub pictured. I am 6′ 2″ to give perspective of the size of the whole sub. Amazing quality. We bought several different lobster rolls and a couple chicken subs. Everything was awesome. My family all raved about their selections. If you go to the beach, this is the place to stop for you sandwich needs. Best of luck with your new business to Rachel and Zach and your staff.
… more
Jessica Burke
This is probably the 5th or 6th time my husband & I went to Mystic. Initially it was a 5 star review– otherwise we wouldn’t have gone back. It’s pricey for sure, but it was worth the occasional splurge….
… more
Matthew Tsucalas
The food was absolutely delicious, we got a Connecticut Lobster Roll and some Lobster Bisque and the service was very good and nice. But the reason why they got three stars is because of the portion size. I have had seafood from all over the northeast and so I understand the price of Lobster and other seafood. But still, the price of a Lobster roll was ridiculous. I paid 20 dollars for a basic small roll which barely had any Lobster on it too. Although the food you got was good, it was still not nearly worth it. Unless you plan on paying 30-40 dollars per person to be just satisfied, I suggest you go somewhere else.
… more
Henry Klak
Absolutely one of the best lobster rolls I’ve had. Service was great, food came out quick and menu selections are off the hook! Don’t miss out…
… more
James Buerger
We only checked the Google reviews, and thank god we skipped the currently-meh Yelp reviews. The lobster rolls were great and the service was amazing. We didn’t get her name, but the owner, who seemed to be doing everything, was super friendly and brought us free key lime pie and lobster bisque, even after the restaurant was past closing time. Strongly recommend.
… more
Ashley Reid
My boyfriend and I came in a half hour before close, he never eats lobster. We met the owner and she gave us honest opinions and never rushed us. We ended up with tacos, three rolls and soup. Honestly I could not have been happier with any of it. The service, the speed, the quality all of it was above and beyond.
… more
April Rataski
Maine Lobster roll was phenomenal! They were generous on the lobster meat. Very tasty
… more
Allan Korets
After going to Chang Thai an amazing pad Thai place next door to this lobster spot for years , I finally gave mystic lobster a try yesterday. I ordered the “specialty” lobster Mac n cheese and the BLT lobster roll ….. Total was nearly 50 dollars , the Mac and cheese was better at outback and cheaper and bigger . The lobster roll was the SMALLEST thing I’ve ever purchased for 25 dollars , words can’t even describe, I will never be going back and honestly do not know how this little place remains in business still after robbing all the local residents
… more
… View more