Family owned & operated, the Miller Family opened Courthouse Pizzeria in 2015. We converted the former Whitey’s Army Navy store and prior to that the original Medina Courthouse, into a local gathering spot for families and friends to be able gather and enjoy a slice or whole pie of authentic NY Style Pie. Courthouse Pizzeria only uses quality ingredients to offer our Guests award-winning NY Style Pies (AKA Pizza). We make our dough & sauce in-house every morning, our veggies are cut fresh, we use the best cheeses available and our proteins are only of the highest quality. We recently added a full-service bar offering a wide variety of beer, wine and cocktails. Hope to see you soon!
Warm, family-owned spot serving NY-style slices & pies with creative toppings in casual environs. Based on 782 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2 Public Square, Medina, OH 44256
Phone: (330) 952-1743
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–7 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jon Santi
Ordered since they opened. Quality was always good. Now this is the third time in a row our order or quality is horrid. 1st time undercooked. 2nd time got the order wrong and put meat on my vegetarian wife’s pizza. 3rd time, smaller slices, cold, and the price isn’t worth it. 37 bucks for a family size salad. Yeah crazy. Over a 3 month period it is just getting worse. Accountability, there is none
… more
3C Etching
Always enjoyed the vibe of Courthouse! They have the best New York Style Pizza and because they are on the square of Medina you can follow up the visit with shopping, ice cream, etc nearby. If you haven’t been, you need to check Courthouse out!
… more
Derek Bolling
Disregard any negative reviews regarding the margherita pizza because when I tell you this was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had, i promise you won’t be disappointed. The crust, the toppings, everything was on point. They were slammed when we got in, but we were seated immediately and fed within 15 minutes. The guy that took our order was extremely polite to us and he was working hard behind the counter. Kudos to you man, you make an awesome pie. I would also like to recognize the bartender, the one who asked the band if the guy playing piano was playing stand by me. She knows who I am talking about. Lol. Sis, you were fantastic and don’t think for a second I didn’t see you flying around there helping everybody. You are an asset to the team, you kept that place moving and flowing properly and if you aren’t in management, they seriously need to get you in charge of a few things. 10/10 —we visited Thursday, 5/11 at around 5-6pm. Please let the entire staff know they were EXCELLENT. We will return from over an hour away.
… more
Christy Morek
Dead touring a new property in Medina and stopped her for lunch! Small cute environment. We told the guy behind counter (maybe owner) we were fist timers he was so awesome explaining the history of the building and recommendations for pizza. We chose the margharita pizza …it was Bomb! That’s all I got will definitely be back
… more
Angelo “AJ” Jimenez
Cool atmosphere great pizza shop. The owner was the best and they sell take and bake kits! Great activity for the family. Thank you Courthouse Pizzeria
… more
Bob Schepis
My wife and I went inside to order while our son went to park. I ordered two large pizzas and two fountain drinks. We sat down and waited for our son. I went and got myself a coke and my wife a water. Our son came in and I told him to get a fountain drink I paid for it already. He got his drink and sat with us. Seconds later a man comes over rudely to our table with a receipt and says to my son ” here you need to pay for your drink”. I said I already paid for his drink. He said you only paid for two drinks. I said that’s correct my wife had water. He apologized half heartedly and walked back behind the counter. Then our first pizza came out and if you look at the picture you can see the crust is about 2 inches long. That makes a large pizza a medium pizza. Picture taken of pizza.
… more
Megan Esch
Made a second order for Simone we missed ordering for. Literally took a cheese pizza and threw toppings on it and heated it back up. Quality is zero. Also didn’t seal bag for DoorDash.
… more
Troy Hager
First timer. Ordered Margarita Pizza. The inner 1/3 was soupy. The tomatoes wetness made the pizza way too wet. Could not enjoy the thin crust near the middle. We Will try again as all the ingredients tasted great and the dough/ crust near the outside 2/3 was very good. The waitress even noticed how soupy it was and said they put to many tomatoes on it. You can see in the pic near the spatula
… more
stew huffman
This pizza us amazing. Nice little place. Great menu and the drizzles are awesome. I recommend the hot honey and the garlic parmasean drizzle. Staff and owner are amazing
… more
Stephanie Longo
Such great pizza. Jake, a staff member, treated us very well. I felt like we were cared for as if we were family. He checked on us twice and took our plates when we were finished. He was so polite. I wish I could go on about him, but please, if the owners see this, tell him he made our visit a pleasant experience and we will come back just because of him. The pizza was good too, but I would be happier if he working when we visit again. I recommend everything. I don’t think you’ll go wrong with anything you choose. Also, I used to wait on the owners when I worked at dennys, and I can tell you, they are sincerely great people. I miss them very much.
… more
… View more