Your favorite neighborhood take and bake pizza + fresh market salads: now offering hot slices and pizzas too! You may know us for our famous Homemade Pizza Co Crust — the celebrity of all crusts.
We’re proud members of the North Shore community, thank you for your loyal support!
Please visit our website to place your *online order*, www.bakehomemadepizza.com!
Local Ingredients + Exceptional Flavor + Convenience = Bake Homemade Pizza.
Take-out chain providing premade, customizable pizzas to bake at home, plus salads. Based on 33 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price
✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
2122 Central St, Evanston, IL 60201
Phone: (847) 424-1400
Hours
| Sunday | 3–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
3–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 3–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–8 PM |
| Thursday | 3–8 PM |
| Friday | 3–9 PM |
| Saturday | 3–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jennifer Hayden
I have ordered regularly from Bake 425. Tonight’s service was horrible!! They got my order wrong. When I went to pick it up, they informed me they were out of nuts for the pear blue cheese salad. They gave me the wrong pizza which I didn’t discover until I got home. When I called to report the mistake, they asked me to return back to the store. When I arrived, again, key ingredients were not available for the pizza. We asked for some type of compensation such as a free cookie or comping the pizza. “We don’t do that,” said the employee. It’s sad how the service quality has completely declined.
… more
Jon Ack
Place is not run well at all. Got NO cooking instructions. Only one person had a clue what they were doing. But the wort part was how DIRTY the place was. Disappointed.
… more
Joe Green
This is the best pizza. We love to bring it home and cook it “wood fired” in our chiminea. It rivals some of the best we have had.
… more
Hiral Patel Hutton
We are new in the neighborhood and for the first time today we ordered the Pizza over the phone and it was very disappointing. Girl who took the order didn’t tell us that their oven is not working and on top of that she asked for the tip. When my husband went to pick up the pizza, she handed him frozen pie. My husband asked her why he wasn’t told about the oven not working when he placed the order and asked for a refund. Of course we didn’t get a refund. Not only did we experience bad customer service but we paid a tip for it. I can not comment on a test because our oven is busted. I am glad a new pizza place is opening in the neighborhood because I don’t think we are going back to “Bake Homemade Pizza” again.
… more
Olivia Landon
These pizzas are THE BOMB. Anyone who couldn’t wait a few minutes for them to wrap up the order or doesn’t think these hard working folks deserve a tip has lived on the North Shore wayyyy too long. Doing the work to bake it yourself is a thousand percent worth it because the flavor profiles compared to the rest of the central street pizza is just next level.
… more
heather clancy
We order here at least weekly. Easy and really like popping it in the oven for nice crispy crust. Crust is decent but ingredients are very good.
… more
Lourdes Sosa
Came to pick up the pizzas. They didn’t even have the order. I arrived at 6:05 and they were supposed to be ready by 6:00. Now I have to wait for them for another 15-20 minutes. We should be compensated for the hassle. One of the guys was VERY RUDE. I’ll be making some phone calls
… more
Martin Mitchell
The food was delicious. Absolutely one of the best places to order from. Not too expensive either! Definately one of my favorite places now!
… more
Jacob W
Quick service, great quality food, and very kind employees. Just an overall great place
… more
Sari Jurek
SO delicious! I was hesitating to try this place but I am so happy I took the chance because it was a FANTASTIC dinner!! Fun to make at home and eating it hot and fresh was more then I could ask for!! I ordered the calzone and breadsticks. I can’t wait to try the pizza next!!
… more
… View more