Upscale Italian fare created from local ingredients & served in a casual, rustic space. Based on 562 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
522 S 8th St, Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: (920) 452-8455
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 5–9 PM |
| Friday | 5–10 PM |
| Saturday | 5–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 5–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 5–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 5–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: resy.com
Reviews
Jennifer Kallias
Romantic, lovely atmosphere with delectable food and impeccable service. My husband and I stayed in Kohler but drove over to Sheboygan for dinner at Trattoria Stefano due to its high rankings, and we were not disappointed. After a round of two different types of bread (both delicious) dipped in olive oil, we ordered the salad special of the night, which we agreed was the best part of our meal: fresh arugula with a very light lemony dressing, paired with thin strips of prosciutto, melt-in-your-mouth fresh mozzarella, blueberries, figs, and a balsamic drizzle. Our waiter Antonio was very knowledgeable about the entire menu and made great recommendations, including the afore-mentioned salad and a glass of wine (one red, one white) for each of us. We decided to try the meatball appetizer, which was good but not anything astounding–the sauce was the best part. For our main courses, I had the homemade pear ravioli in the brown butter sauce and my husband ordered the osso bucco. Both dishes were amazing! The semi-sweet ravioli was complemented and perfectly balanced by the salty brown-butter sauce. The osso bucco plate was gorgeous–as you can see by my photo–and the flavor pairings were memorably tasty. We almost always order dessert, but this time we couldn’t because the portions were so generous and we were so happily full! The prices were quite reasonable for the quality and quantity of food we received. We agreed we’d return again!
… more
Lana J
Nice Italian restaurant in downtown. You need reservations. We didn’t have reservations and ate at the bar. The bartenders were very nice and made some excellent suggestions. I ended up ordering the fish of the day which was halibut. It was amazing.
… more
Scott Golimowski
Very nice place. Staff is excellent!! Food was superb!! But the price wasn’t!! 48 bucks for the plate that I had!! Not a lot of meat for that price!! 30 bucks for that plate is what it should have been!! The beets were cold!! They have a large drink menu. Parking is on the street and you have to feed the meter beforehand.
… more
Colin Phalen
I stopped at this amazing restaurant for the first time last week, but it won’t be my last! The food was incredible, and the service was top-notch! We ordered the bruschetta for the table (pictured), and the rest of us ordered different pastas. We all left very satisfied! Can’t recommend enough!
… more
Laura Forster Maheshwary
An absolute amazing meal and experience! We celebrated our anniversary here and not being from the area we weren’t sure what to expect. Not only was the food out of this world but our server, Antonio, made the experience so enjoyable and in a way I haven’t experienced in ages. He knows his stuff and took the meal to the next level. A must!
… more
Wis Co
Honestly.. as restaurants go this is almost as good as it gets. We were in Sheboygan today to visit the two Kohler museums (which were great, but I liked the new one a bit better, more content). Decided to give this place a try since the reviews were more than good.
… more
David Gallianetti
One of the best Italian options in the Midwest. Amazing, authentic food. Fresh ingredients prepared in simple and often quite interesting ways is the key. Much of the pasta is made in house.
… more
Scott Williams
A little torn about this one… Almost 5 atars but not quite. Mainly because I felt the menu was a tad limited. Service was excellent, appetizers were excellent, I had the halibut, which was very good.
… more
Wes Nemec
Very lovely experience here, I called and made a reservation for 17 people on relatively short notice and the staff worked very hard to get us in. They were able to make our reservation for a bit later at 8:00 p.m., but the table was ready early which was nice. Staff was super helpful on site, service was great and The food was also delicious. Really nice ambiance at this restaurant, I’d say it’s one of the nicer places in Sheboygan which worked out well because we were treating clients to a dinner. Highly recommend for the experience overall, be aware The prices are a bit higher but you get what you pay for here.
… more
Yuri Vieceli
Amazing. This restaurant is a real Italian restaurant! All of the food tasted a lot better than my expectations. Tiramisu there is 28 years also recipe. The best tiramisu ever. The hospitality was so good. We are coming back soon!!
… more
… View more