Sgt. Pepperoni​’s Menu – Bayfield, WI

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Bayfield, WI

Based on 62 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Sgt. Pepperoni​'s 54814

Address:
21 N 1st St, Bayfield, WI 54814

Phone: (715) 779-0153

Website: https://greunkesinn.com/sgt-pepperonis-pizza/

Social Profile:

Hours

Thursday 2–9 PM
Friday 2–9 PM
Saturday 2–9 PM
Sunday 2–9 PM
Monday 2–9 PM
Tuesday 2–9 PM
Wednesday 2–9 PM

Menu

Sgt. Pepperoni’s Pizza
Sgt. Peppers Work Pizza
Ingredients: pepperoni, sausage, onion, mushrooms, green pepper, black olive, green olive.		 $19.00
Vegetable Supreme Pizza
Ingredients: onion, mushrooms, green pepper, black olive, green olive, tomato.		 $16.00
Godmother’s Favorite Pizza
Ingredients: sausage, mushroom, onion, black olive.		 $18.00
Soprano Special 3 Meat Pizza
Ingredients: pepperoni, sausage, ham plus roasted red peppers, crushed red peppers, parmesan cheese and seasonings.		 $18.00
Summer Special Pizza
Ingredients: grilled chicken, mushrooms, black olives, onion, tomato, and ranch sauce.		 $19.00
Spicy Chicken Pizza
Ingredients: grilled chicken, red pepper, green pepper, onion, crushed red peppers.		 $19.00
Hawaiian Pizza
Ingredients: ham, pineapple, onion, black olive.		 $19.00
Hawaiian Chicken Pizza
Ingredients: chicken, pineapple, onion, black olive.		 $19.00
Cheese Cheese Me Pizza $12.00
Cheese Plus One Pizza $13.00
Cheese Plus Two Pizza $14.00
Cheese Plus Three Pizza $16.00
Pizza Fries $10.00
Breakfast
Breakfast Greunke’s Eggs Benedict
Toasted English muffin, Canadian bacon, & perfectly poached eggs topped with hollandaise sauce. Served with American fries or hashbrowns.		 $9.95
Breakfast Biscuits & Gravy With Eggs
Baking soda biscuits smothered with our homemade sausage gravy and served with 2 eggs any style.		 $8.95
Fisherman’s Breakfast
2 eggs any style, sausage or bacon, American fries or hashbrowns, & choice of toast.		 $8.95
Breakfast Judith’s Skillet
American fries loaded with sautéed onions, mushrooms, tomatoes, sausage, & cheddar cheese. Served with scrambled eggs and an English muffin.		 $9.50
Breakfast Pancakes
Served with plenty of Butter & Syrup		 $7.25
Breakfast Hot Oatmeal
Old fashioned oats served with brown sugar, raisins, milk, & choice of toast.		 $4.75
Breakfast Capt. Vic’s Veggie Omelet
Sautéed veggies & cheddar cheese served with choice of toast.		 $8.95
Breakfast Greunkes Ham & Cheese Omelet
An omelet with loads of smoked ham & cheddar cheese served with choice of toast.		 $9.00
Breakfast Cheese Omelet
An omelet with plenty of melted cheddar cheese served with choice of toast.		 $8.00
Breakfast Sides
Egg $1.50
Hashbrowns $2.95
American Fries $2.95
Bacon $2.95
Sausage Patties $2.95
Sausage Links $2.95
Sliced Smoked Ham $3.25
Broiled Lake Superior Whitefish $6.50
Smoked Lake Superior Trout $7.50
Pancake $3.95
French Toast $3.95
Toast $1.95
English Muffin $1.95
Bagel With Cream Cheese $2.75
Cinnamon Roll $3.25
Salads & Soups
Dinner Smoked Lake Superior Trout Salad
Smoked lake superior trout served on a bed of mixed greens with tomato, red onion, toasted pine nuts, & feta cheese crumbles. Served with a side of homemade lemon-dill vinaigrette.		 $14.95
Dinner Classic Caesar Salad
Chopped romaine lettuce, tomato, shredded parmesan cheese, homemade croutons, & caesar dressing.		 $5.95
Dinner Side Caesar
Chopped romaine lettuce, tomato, shredded parmesan cheese, homemade croutons, & caesar dressing.		 $3.95
Side Salad
Mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, red onion, shredded cheddar cheese, & croutons served with your choice of homemade dressing.		 $3.95
Homemade Soup Du Jour
Ask your server about today’s selection!		 $2.95
Homemade Chili Soup $3.75
Burgers & Sandwiches
Dinner Angus Beef Breast Burger
1/3 lb. Angus beef patty or grilled chicken breast served on a toasted kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato, red onion, & roasted garlic mayo.		 $6.95
Dinner Classic Reuben Sandwich
Thinly sliced corned beef, swiss cheese, & sauerkraut on toasted marble rye. Homemade Reuben sauce served on the side.		 $9.95
Dinner Superior Whitefish BLT Sandwich
Deep-fried or broiled lake superior whitefish served on a toasted ciabatta roll with applewood smoked bacon, mixed greens, tomato, red onion, & homemade tartar sauce.		 $10.95
Entrees
Dinner Lake Superior Whitefish
Broiled or deep-fried fresh lake superior whitefish served with fresh lemon wedge & homemade tartar sauce.		 $18.95
Dinner Lake Superior Trout $19.95
Dinner Pecan Breaded Trout $22.95
Dinner Walnut Breaded Trout $21.95
Dinner Hemingway Trout
Fresh lake superior trout served with fresh lemon & homemade tartar sauce.		 $21.95
Dinner Lake Superior Whitefish Cakes
Lightly breaded and deep-fried lake superior whitefish cakes served with homemade cranberry tartar sauce.		 $10.95
Dinner Deep Fried Wisconsin Cheese Curds
Lightly breaded Wisconsin cheddar cheese curds served with homemade marinara or ranch dipping sauce.		 $8.95
House Specialties
Dinner Filet Steak Sandwich
Usda choice char-grilled beef filet served on texas toast with homemade fries & coleslaw.		 $17.95
Broasted Chicken Dinner
4 pieces of broasted chicken served with choice of starch, vegetable, & homemade coleslaw.		 $15.95
Dinner Vegetarian Portabella Pesto Pasta
Homemade herb pesto & toasted pine nuts tossed with linguine pasta and topped with grilled portabella mushroom & parmesan cheese. Served with toasted french bread.		 $15.95
Dinner Vegetable Linguine Marinara
Sautéed bell peppers, red onion, tomato, portabella mushroom, and homemade marinara tossed with linguine pasta and topped with parmesan cheese and fresh parsley. Served with toasted french bread.		 $14.95
Dinner Chicken Parmesan
Homemade marinara tossed with linguine, topped with parmesan & mozzarella cheeses and fresh parsley. Served with toasted french bread.		 $14.95
Lunch Wraps
Lunch Four Star Club Wrap
Generous amounts of herb-roasted turkey breast, smoked ham, applewood smoked bacon, romaine lettuce, tomato, & mayo wrapped in a whole wheat tortilla or on whole-wheat toast.		 $10.95
Lunch Thanksgiving Wrap
Herb-roasted turkey breast, homemade mashed potatoes, and stuffing, turkey gravy, toasted pecans, & dried cranberries wrapped in a whole wheat tortilla.		 $10.95
Lunch Entrees
Lunch Lake Superior Whitefish
Broiled or deep-fried fresh lake superior fish served with homemade french fries, sweet potato fries, mashed potatoes, or baked potato, homemade cole slaw, fresh lemon, & homemade tartar sauce.		 $11.95
Lunch Lake Superior Trout
Broiled or deep-fried fresh lake superior fish served with homemade french fries, sweet potato fries, mashed potatoes, or baked potato, homemade coleslaw, fresh lemon, & homemade tartar sauce.		 $12.95
Lunch Blue Plate Special
Homemade meatloaf with mashed potatoes and stuffing topped with gravy & served with homemade coleslaw.		 $10.95
Lunch Roasted Turkey Breast
Oven-roasted turkey breast served with homemade mashed potatoes and stuffing topped with turkey gravy, & served with homemade coleslaw.		 $11.95
Lunch Broasted Chicken Luncheon
2 pieces of broasted chicken served with homemade french fries, sweet potato fries, mashed potatoes, or baked potato, & homemade coleslaw.		 $10.95
Kid’s Menu
Kid’s Breakfast Pancake With Bacon $4.95
Kid’s Breakfast Pancake With Sausage $4.95
Kid’s Breakfast French Toast With Bacon $4.95
Kid’s Breakfast French Toast With Sausage $4.95
Kid’s Breakfast Egg & Toast $4.95
Kid’s Breakfast Biscuits & Gravy With 1 Egg $6.95
Kid’s Breakfast Strawberry Cake With Sausage $5.95
Kid’s Breakfast Strawberry Cake With Bacon $5.95
Kid’s Breakfast Raspberry Cake With Bacon $5.95
Kid’s Breakfast Raspberry Cake With Sausage $5.95
Kid’s Breakfast Blueberry Cake With Bacon $5.95
Kid’s Breakfast Blueberry Cake With Sausage $5.95
Kid’s Lunch & Dinner Cheeseburger $4.95
Kid’s Lunch & Dinner Hamburger $4.95
Kid’s Lunch & Dinner Jumbo Hot Dog $4.95
Kid’s Lunch & Dinner Grilled Cheese $4.95
Kid’s Lunch & Dinner Mac’n’Cheese $4.95
Kid’s Lunch & Dinner Chicken Strips $4.95
Beverages
Coffee $1.95
Tea $1.95
Milk $1.95
Chocolate Milk $1.95
Tomato Juice $1.95
Fruit Juice $1.95
Hot Chocolate $2.50
Coke Products $1.95
Iced Tea $1.95
Lemonade $1.95

… View more

Reviews

hataricat21
Delicious pizza!!! The crust was consistent with the crunch to chewy ratio. There was the perfect amount of cheese, toppings and sauce. I was very happy with the staff experience and the food. Great place to stop in.

… more

J H
Considering how bad this could be considering how few options there are for pizza it was surprisingly good. Just got a pepperoni pizza. Heck, I’d get it if it was in the Twin Cities and Bayfield has a whopping population of 584 people.

… more

Steve Day
This review is not for the pizza or service it’s about the fact that they make no effort to change their hours of operation on Google (which is super easy to do). We were in town for a cruise and were planning pizza here after a googling pizza around. After walking 3 blocks we were welcomed with a locked door and no one in sight when their hours of operation showed open 2-9…this was at 3:15. Just make a little effort! : (

… more

Nick Boland
Solid pizza and pleasantly surprised by crust, sauce and taste.

… more

Curtis DeCora
Delicious pizza, I was surprised when I saw the staff tossing the dough. Most pizza places serve frozen pre-made crusts. We ordered the double cheese, double crust, and it was pretty remarkable given the business setup. It is all to-go, there is a nice little table on the deck where you can dine with family members. All-in-all, it was a surprisingly delicious pizza with great flavor, toppings, and quality. I will be ordering again.

… more

Bob Lewis
Very good large vegetable pizza. Square cut so perfect for a group. Good spread of vegetables with cheese. Sauce not too see. Pizza was ready on time for pick up. I definitely would visit again

… more

Ronald Duke
The Godmother’s Pizza was amazing! We bought a large, ate 1/2 and ate the rest for lunch the next day. Not many eating choices in Bayfield now that Maggie’s is gone.

… more

Jean K
We spent the night at Gruenkes, which is exactly where this pizza place is, and needed a pizza late at night. This pizza is amazing! The sauce flavor is unique, a little sweeter than most, which I loved ❤. We had pepperoni, onion, and green pepper. It was done in about 20 minutes. Located right in town close to everything that tourists love. I will definitely go back here for this pizza.

… more

Laura Meyers
The pizza was not bad. We prefer a thinner, softer crust, but it was a little too thick and very tough. More sauce would have been better also.

… more

TJ Travels
Savior@10pm. Nice taste. Large pizza good for 2.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch