Based on 91 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1374 New Haven Ave, Milford, CT 06460
Phone: (203) 874-0011
Website: http://www.eastshorepizza.com/
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:15 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9:15 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:15 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:15 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:15 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:15 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Murali J
They charged extra when I ordered takeout. When I asked why they did that, I was told credit card orders will be charged extra by machine. They never put any notice that they will do that. The only note I saw there was they offer 4% discount on cash payments. I don’t want to deal with anyone not doing business honestly, so I won’t go there again
… more
Jason Lubitz
I live in hotels 48 weeks per year and enjoy trying food from everywhere. 24 minutes from web order to hotel room, unheard of! Extra plates, utensils, and napkins because I’m not at home, thoughtful. Fresh, did I say fresh ingredients. Very hot! One bite review. Mmmm! Crust is like a breadstick. Sauce is perfect. Great prices! Definitely worth it. and to top it off, a great team member hand delivered it to my room, Thank you!
… more
Sheretta Haynes
I’m visiting from NC. I was told this pizza was one of the best. I’m sorry to say I was very disappointed. Although there was plenty of toppings, there was barely any cheese. There were so many empty areas. There are a few things I enjoy when I come home to visit, good pizza is one of them and I have been throughly disappointed and will never go back to this establishment. Then when I called to complain about it they said “that’s how it comes” SO, your pizza comes without cheese? INTERESTING. You don’t have to worry about me coming back. I’m originally from here and know of other great pizza places that actually put cheese on their pizza. ✌
… more
Shelby Dillman
Besides delicious food, the staff unexpectedly went above and beyond to help me out. With my husband deployed, those acts of kindness meant the absolute world to this mother of 2. Very family friendly. Happy to have found our new regular pizza place.
… more
Bill Efird
Super fast delivery. Best pizza in 3 counties
… more
Jacob Rivera
Pizza was amazing staff was super nice
… more
Mary
I usually like to praise rather than give bad reviews but really…?!? Awhile ago I had to start telling the person who answers the phone not to add parmigiana cheese to my meals because “it’s put on everything” was the response. But that’s the purpose of ordering exactly what it says on the menu & no other ingredients should be added unless the customer asks for it. Then today! I ordered a sausage, pepper & onion grinder with extra peppers & onions. I got a lot of sausages on a grinder roll with diced raw peppers & onions! Did I pay extra? Aren’t peppers & onions on a sausage & pepper grinder supposed to be cooked!!? Shouldn’t there be huge chunks to make it taste juicy? Is it me or should we get what we actually ordered?
… more
Vicky H
This establishment originally had a 5 star rating from me until my recent order. I placed an order for delivery totaling to $5 but was charged $9 once my order arrived. Because it didn’t meet their delivery minimum which I was not informed about what so ever by phone nor does their recently updated takeout menu list the required amount needed to receive the free delivery. Although their food is delicious, I will be refraining from any further orders unless I’m picking up my food personally.
… more
Diana Barnum
I am very pleased with extra fast delivery, and I am ecstatic about the extra cheese pizza i ordered. Thats what you call EXTRA CHEESE. Thanks East Shore pizza.
… more
G
While this use to be an acceptable pizza place, they do not live up to their advertisement to match coupons. They refused to accept one of THEIR coupons for a large pizza with 1 topping & 2 liter soda at their price on the coupon. There was NO expiration date. However, their refusal worked to my advantage. Silver Sands delivered 1 large pizza with 1 topping for $9.99, included a roll with their large Greek salad and wings. And, they were quicker! East Shore missed out on a large order because of their refusal to honor their coupon and a customer for ever.
… more
… View more