The 5 Mile Cafe Menu – Penfield, NY

Type : Restaurant

Location : Penfield, NY

Based on 411 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

The 5 Mile Cafe 14526

Address:
2084 Five Mile Line Rd, Penfield, NY 14526

Phone: (585) 586-2232

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 8 AM–2 PM
Thursday 8 AM–2 PM
Friday 8 AM–2 PM
Saturday 8 AM–2 PM
Sunday 8 AM–2 PM
Monday Closed

Menu

Beverages
Coffees $2.50
Hot Tea $2.50
Juices $3.00
Milk $2.50
Chocolate Milk $2.50
Hot Chocolate $3.00
Soda $2.50
Club Soda $1.50
Iced Tea $2.50
Lemonade $2.50
Bottled Water $2.00
Kid Drinks $2.00
Breakfast
One Egg, Meat, Home Fries & Toast
A classic breakfast with all your favorites		 $10.00
Two Eggs, Home Fries & Toast
A classic breakfast with all your favorites		 $8.00
Two Eggs, Meat, Home Fries & Toast
A classic breakfast with all your favorites		 $11.00
Crab Cake Benny
2 poached eggs and our homemade crab cakes on an English muffin topped with hollandaise sauce. Served with one side		 $16.00
Eggs Benedict
Two Poached eggs, canadian bacon on an english muffin with hollandaise sauce. Served with choice of a side.		 $13.00
Veggie Benny
Two poached eggs, tomato slice and spinach on an english muffin with hollandaise sauce. Served with choice of a side.		 $13.00
Cheese Omelet
Omelet made with choice of up to 3 cheeses. Served with choice of side and toast.		 $11.00
Chicken Fajita Omelet
Diced chicken, mixed cheese, peppers, onions, side of salsa & sour cream. Served with toast and choice of a side.		 $13.00
Meat Lovers Omelet
Choice of 3 meats & cheese		 $13.00
Cheesy Sausage Hash
Shredded potatoes, sauteed onions, italian sausage, smothered with cheddar cheese & topped with choice of eggs		 $13.00
Corned Beef Hash
Home made cornbeef hash (not from a can) topped with two poached eggs. Served with a choice of toast.		 $13.00
Five Mile Plate
Home fries with sauteed onions, melted cheddar cheese, two sausage patties, home made meat sauce, topped with two poached eggs and served with a choice of toast.		 $14.00
Lox & Eggs
Smoked Salmon, eggs, toast and choice of side. Can Add the works (capers, onion and tomato)		 $16.00
Steak & Eggs
Hand cut steak, 2 eggs, toast and choice of a side.		 $16.00
Pancakes
Large buttermilk pancakes.		 $4.00
Pancake Combo
Our Large buttermilk pancakes, eggs and a meat choice. Combos are the amount of each iterm you get.		 $10.00
Stuffed Pancakes
Short stack of blueberry pancakes, stuffed with bavarian creme. Topped with whipped creme and strawberry topping.		 $12.00
French Toast
Short or full stack of french toast		 $8.00
Cinnamon Challah French Toast
Thick cinnamon challah bread garnished with powdered sugar.		 $10.00
Stuffed French Toast
Jamaican style bread, stuffed with bavarian cream, topped with strawberries, blueberries and whipped cream.		 $12.00
Potato Latkes
Our home made potatoe latkes, two eggs and two strips of bacon. Served with apple sauce and sour cream.		 $12.00
Breakfast Sandwich
Two eggs your way, choice of meat and cheese on a sesame seed roll. Served with a choice of a side.		 $12.00
Breakfast Wrap
Two eggs your way, choice of meat and cheese in a wrap. Served with a choice of a side.		 $12.00
Grilled Veggie Breakfast Wrap
Grilled asparagus, red & green peppers, red onion, zucchini, yellow squash, eggs and swiss cheese. Served with choice of a side.		 $13.00
Turkey Burger
Two eggs your way with american cheese		 $14.00
Five Mile Plate Wrap
Home fries, sausage patties, two over easy eggs, onions, cheddar cheese and homemade meat sauce served in a flour wrap.		 $14.00
Broccoli Cheddar Quiche
Home made broccoli and cheddar quiche served a choice of a side.		 $11.00
Broccoli Bacon Cheddar Quiche
Home made broccoli, bacon and cheddar quiche served a choice of a side.		 $11.00
Quiche Lorraine
Home made swiss, bacon and onion quiche served a choice of a side.		 $11.00
Biscuit & Gravy
Large home style biscuit smothered with gravy, two eggs and choice of side		 $12.00
Italian Frittata
Peppers, onions, potatoes, Italian sausage and provolone cheese. Comes with bread choice		 $12.00
Veggie Frittata
Peppers, onions, spinach, tomatoes, potatoes & swiss cheese. Served with a bread choice		 $12.00
One Egg $2.00
Side Meat Choices $5.00
Toast $2.50
Bagel $3.00
Biscuit $2.50
Muffin $4.00
Fruit $4.00
Fruit W/ Yogurt $10.00
Side Of Home Fries $4.00
Side Hashbrowns $4.50
Side Of Avocado $3.00
Side Of Grilled Vegetables $6.00
Side Of Corned Beef Hash $8.00
Side Biscuit And Gravy $5.00
Side Gravies And Sauces $3.00
Side Of Latkes $6.00
Side Of Crab Cakes $8.00
Real Maple Syrup $2.00
K-1 Egg, Meat & Bear Pancake $5.50
K-1 Egg, Meat & Toast $4.50
K-Bear Pancake
Our large kids pancake with a bear face. Served with syrup.		 $3.50
Lunch
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, house made croutons and caesar dressing.		 $9.00
Chicken Fajita Salad
Fajita seasoned chicken, peppers, onions, tomaotes and mixed cheese. Served with salsa and sour cream.		 $14.00
Cobb Salad
Mixed greens, diced ham, turkey, tomatoes, egg, cucumbers, carrots and cheddar cheese.		 $14.00
Greek Salad
Mixed greens, red onions, pepperoncinis, cucumbers, kalamata olives and feta cheese. Served with a side of Greek dressing.		 $11.00
Taco Salad
Beef or chicken over crisp lettuce, tomatoes, onions, black olives and mixed cheese. Served with salsa and sour cream		 $14.00
Turkey Melt
Sliced oven roasted turkey, tomato and choice of cheese. Served on choice of bread with a side.		 $13.00
Tuna Melt
Albacore tuna salad, grilled tomato on grilled rye bread and cheddar cheese. Served with choice of side		 $13.00
Patty Melt
Our beef patty, sauteed onions, swiss cheese on grilled seeded rye bread. Served with choice of a side.		 $13.00
Five Mile Burger
Served with lettuce, tomato, onions. Add cheese +$1		 $12.00
Turkey Burger
Served with lettuce, tomato, onion on a grilled kaiser roll		 $13.00
Spicy Burger
Our beef patty topped with jalapenos, cheddar cheese & sriracha mayo. Served with a choice of a side.		 $14.00
Grilled Cheese Sandwich $9.00
Ahi Tuna Wrap
Grilled ahi tuna, asian slaw, sweet chili aioli, avocado and asian dressing in a wrap. Served with soy sauce and choice of side.		 $16.00
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Chicken tenders tossed in Buffalo wing sauce, romaine lettuce, tomato, cheddar & bleu cheese. Served with choice of a side		 $13.00
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken breast and romaine lettuce tossed in caesar dressing with parmesan cheese. Served in a wrap with a choice of a side.		 $13.00
Turkey Club
Sliced oven roasted turkey, lettuce, tomato, bacon and mayo on your choice or toast. Served with a choice of side.		 $13.00
Chicken Salad
Home made chicken salad served on choice of bread. Comes with a choice of a side		 $10.00
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Served on toasted rye bread with sauerkraut, swiss cheese & 1000 island dressing		 $12.00
Corned Beef Reuben
Cooked and sliced corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss cheese and 1000 island dressing on seeded rye bread. Served with a choice of a side.		 $13.00
Turkey Reuben $13.00
Grilled Chicken $13.00
Open Faced Steak Sandwich
NY Strip with sauteed peppers, onions & mushrooms		 $15.00
BLT
Bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo		 $11.00
Quesadilla
Served with cheese, grilled onions & peppers. Add chicken +$3 / Add beef +$4		 $10.00
3 Chicken Tenders $5.50
Avocado $2.00
Side Of Seasoned Fries $4.00
Basket Of Seasoned Fries $6.00
Basket Of Sweet Potato Fries $7.00
Fruit $4.00
Macaroni Salad $4.00
Pasta Salad $4.00
Side Caesar Salad $6.00
Side Coleslaw $4.00
Side Salad $6.00
Soup $4.00
K-Cheeseburger
Served with fries		 $6.50
K-Chicken Fingers
Served with fries		 $6.50
K-Grilled Cheese $5.00
K-Hamburger
Served with fries		 $6.00
K-PB & Jelly $5.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Ivy Dong
My bf and I came here a couple days of ago and we had the BEST food ever. The owner was so attentive and sweet. My broccoli and cheddar quiche and my bf’s burrito was DELICIOUS.

… more

JanisElaine
First time dining at 5mile and this quaint cozy breakfast spot was bustling!! Family owned business kept the tables clean and kitchen steadily filling orders –

… more

charles polley
Food was exellent! Very friendly staff, and people. Every bite was good. Great atmosphere, eat inside or outside. Very calm peaceful place. I can’t compliment the staff enough. Thank you for the wonderful service. Definitely coming here again.

… more

Mary Kirchgessner
It was a very cute little cafe with great personal touches. Food was good.

… more

Pistol Pete Luciano
Food is really really good. And the service is great very friendly. It is on the small side, cozy and comfortable. but because it’s so good and small there is sometimes a wait to get seated. And they will pace out taking your order in order to keep the kitchen in a good place of getting orders out. So just read what’s on your table and on the walls. You might even read something you never new you needed too.

… more

Linda Clark
A new breakfast “spot” for me! It is not in my part of town but we’ll worth the drive. The owner and her family were fascinating, professional and hardworking. I had the corned bed hash yum. I chose to have my eggs scrambled (pepper was added by me). My dining mate had turkey sausage links with eggs and breakfast potatoes. A great dining environment. A little tight if covid conscious. Get there early on Sunday!

… more

gen brennick
Family run home cooked Jamaican traditional to non traditional twist. The food is amazing. Staff pleasant, extremely helpful and knowledgeable on items listed.

… more

Rebecca Gerideau
I love rhis quaint place!! The food is always perfectly seasoned The service is professional and friendly. They care that the meal is to your liking. The musical selection creates a relaxing ambiance. What brought it all together for me were the positive messages reminding us to thank God always. I highly recommend 5 Mile Cafe Thank you for your service.

… more

Allie Burns
An absolute east side gem!! I haven’t been here since before Covid and cannot believe I spent so much time away. The atmosphere is beyond cute & cozy. A friend and I were seated outside right away. Staff were knowledgeable, attentive, and friendly. I was inspired by the diverse menu- Jamaican cuisine to challah bread to quiche and everything in between. Truly there is something for everyone to enjoy. I ordered one of the specials for breakfast : crab cake on an open faced croissant with scrambled eggs and home fries. I deemed it “a religious experience” while enjoying. I will certainly be returning and am so thankful for this family to share their talents with the community!

… more

Evelyn Munger
We found this wonderful establishment yesterday morning! Celebrating John’s 65th birthday with his favorite meal of the day! The food was fantastic, homemade by MOM and the wait staff isamazing! You must check it out! ENJOY!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch