Toast Coffeehouse Menu – Bay Shore, NY

Type : Breakfast restaurant

Location : Bay Shore, NY

Our mission is to delight our customers
with the best breakfast and brunch experience possible.
We believe that breakfast and brunch are more than just meals – they are moments
to savor and share with friends and family. That’s why we are dedicated to serving
innovative, high-quality dishes made with the freshest and finest ingredients.
Our menu features a mix of classic and modern dishes, with something for everyone –
from savory to sweet, from light to indulgent.
Our goal is to create a warm, welcoming atmosphere where our customers feel at
home, whether they’re starting their day, taking a break, or enjoying a lazy weekend
morning. We are committed to providing exceptional service and creating memorable
moments for every guest.

Based on 936 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Toast Coffeehouse 11706

Address:
9 S Pk Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Phone: (631) 647-9560

Website:

Hours

Tuesday 8 AM–3 PM
Wednesday 8 AM–3 PM
Thursday 8 AM–3 PM
Friday 8 AM–3 PM
Saturday 7:30 AM–3:30 PM
Sunday 7:30 AM–3:30 PM
Monday 8 AM–3 PM

Menu

Food Specials
Monkey Bread Skillet
Crispy cinnamon swirl bread smothered with vanilla icing and cinnamon syrup

*contains gluten and dairy

 $14.95
Chorizo & Corn Tacos $15.95
Tres Leche French Toast
With fresh berries

*contains gluten and dairy

 $15.95
Berry Crumble Pancakes
Fresh berry compote, oat streusel and vanilla crème

*contains gluten and dairy

 $14.95
Falafel Avocado Toast
Fresh sliced avocado, red onion, everything bagel seasoning & homemade tzatziki yogurt sauce

*contains gluten and dairy

 $14.95
Watermelon Burrata Salad
Grape tomatoes, cucumber, red onion and balsamic drizzle		 $15.95
Strawberry Shortcake Pie
*contains gluten and dairy		 $7.95
Key Lime Pie
*contains gluten and dairy		 $8.95
Drink Specials
PB & Marshmallow Shaken Espresso $6.00
Churro Cold Brew $6.00
Coffee Drinks
Coffee $3.75
Tea $2.50
Cafe Latte $4.95
Cappuccino $4.95
Iced Cappucino $4.95
Iced Latte $4.95
Iced Coffee $3.75
Peanut Butter Mocha $5.95
Chai Tea Latte $5.50
Matcha Latte $5.95
Caramel Apple Chai $5.95
Shaken Espresso Maple Latte $5.50
Salted Caramel Latte $5.50
Hot Chocolate $5.50
Double Espresso $4.00
Americano $4.00
Cold Brew $4.95
Single Shot Espresso $2.00
Vegan Breakfast
Vegan Avocado Toast
Toasted multigrain bread with sliced avocado, red onion, and microgreens, served with home fries		 $11.95
Supreme Sammy
Scrambled egg, sausage & Chao cheese with chipotle mayo on a multigrain roll		 $14.95
The Alchemist
Two scrambled eggs, with your choice of fruit or sausage, served with home fries and toast		 $15.95
Tofu Scramble
Grilled tofu with spinach, zucchini, mushroom, asparagus, & red pepper, served with home fries and toast		 $13.95
Mt. Shasta Scramble
Roasted zucchini, spinach, mushroom, sundried tomato, sauteed onion, & eggs, served with home fries and toast		 $16.95
Farmer’s Omelet
Grape tomatoes, kale, edamame, quinoa, avocado & Chao cheese		 $16.95
Twin Sister Burrito
Scrambled eggs, sausage, potatoes, peppers, and onions, served with home fries and mango salsa		 $16.95
The Brussels Quesadilla
Scrambled eggs, sausage, Brussels sprouts, corn & pepper relish with Chao cheese		 $16.95
Coconut Multigrain French Toast
Dipped in Coconut milk & vanilla, with mangos & bananas, served with your choice of side		 $15.95
Very Berry Pancakes
with warm berry compote & fresh berries		 $14.95
Short Stack Very Berry Pancakes $7.95
Early Riser
Organic Oatmeal
With cinnamon apples and dried cranberries, topped with brown sugar and strawberries		 $10.95
Fruit Parfait Bowl
Fresh fruit & berries on top of vanilla yogurt and coverd with organic harvest granola		 $10.95
Gourmet Egg Sandwich
Two farm fresh eggs, grilled chorizo, avocado, jalapeno jack, chipotle aioli served with home fries		 $14.95
Classic Avocado Toast
Mashed & fresh sliced avocado, red onion & microgreens on toasted multigrain		 $11.95
Avo BLT Toast
Fresh sliced avocado, mashed avocado, bacon jam, grape tomato & microgreens served with home fries		 $12.95
Burrata Caprese Avocado Toast
Sun dried tomato pesto, fresh sliced avocado, julienned basil & balsamic glaze served with home fries		 $14.95
Egg Sandwich
Classic egg sandwich with two eggs cooked to your liking, your choice of meat, American cheese, and your choice of bread!		 $5.95
CBT $6.95
Quesadillas & Burritos
Ranchero Quesadilla
Scrambled eggs, black beans, roasted corn & pepper relish, with melted jalapeno jack and chipotle aioli on a grilled honey wheat tortilla		 $16.50
Hawaiian Coast Quesadilla
Scrambled eggs, BBQ pulled pork, red pepper, grilled pineapple, & yellow cheddar		 $16.50
Voodoo Quesadilla
Creole scrambled eggs, shrimp, chorizo, fresh avocado, roasted corn & pepper relish, melted cheddar		 $17.50
Bandito Burrito
Scrambled eggs, crisp bacon, potato, roasted red pepper, & smoked gouda, served with home fries & mango salsa		 $16.95
Original Burrito
Scrambled eggs, sausage, potato, peppers, onion, & jack cheese, served with home fries & mango salsa		 $16.95
Gringo Burrito
Egg whites, spinach, turkey, & jack cheese in whole wheat tortilla, served with home fries & mango salsa		 $17.50
Domingo Breakfast Tacos
Creole scrambled eggs, pulled pork, fresh avocado, guacamole, crispy tortilla strips, salsa verde & jack cheese in corn tortillas		 $16.95
Toast Favorites
Eggs Any Style
Two organic eggs, your choice of bacon, turkey bacon, sausage, or ham, served with home fries and toast		 $12.95
Benedict Arnold
Two organic poached eggs served with grilled ham on a toasted english muffin, topped with hollandaise, roasted red pepper & green onion, served with home fries		 $17.50
Splendid Benedict
Two organic poached eggs served with sliced avocado fritter on a toasted english muffin, topped with hollandaise & maple bacon crumbles, served with home fries		 $17.50
Corned Beef Hash & Eggs
Two organic poached eggs atop homemade corned beef, caramelized brussels sprouts, on thick cut rye with hollandaise & diced bacon		 $19.95
Biscuits & Gravy Benedict
Two organic poached eggs served with sausage gravy and homemade biscuits		 $16.95
Shrimp & Grits
Two organic poached eggs with crumbled chorizo & sauteed cajun shrimp in etouffee style sauce over cheddar grits		 $17.95
Three Ring Circus
Two organic eggs, home fries, classic pancakes & your choice of bacon, turkey bacon, sausage, turkey sausage or ham

*no substitutions

 $16.95
Omelets
Plain Jane Omelet
American cheese omelet, served with home fries and toast		 $12.95
Avocado BLT Omelet
Avocado, crisp bacon, spinach, plum tomato, & Vermont white cheddar, served with home fries and toast		 $16.95
Mediterranean Omelet
Baby spinach, plum tomato, onion, & feta, served with home fries and toast		 $15.95
Delancey Street Omelet
Crisp bacon, spianch, mushroom, tomato, onion, & swiss, served with home fries and toast		 $16.95
Huevos Migas Omelet
Chorizo sausage, tomato, green pepper, onion, & jalapeno havarti, served with home fries and toast		 $16.95
The “Dig Me” Omelet
Egg whites, spinach, turkey, & jack cheese, served with home fries and toast		 $17.50
Skillets
Miss Lucy’s Tortilla Skillet
Creole scrambled eggs, sausage, potato, green onion, melted cheddar and corn tortillas topped with sour cream, served over home fries		 $16.95
Denver Skillet
Softly scrambled eggs, grilled ham, green pepper, mushroom, and onion, topped with cheddar cheese, served over home fries		 $16.95
Avocado Skillet
Softly scrambled eggs, grilled turkey, roasted red pepper, green onion, fresh avocado with white cheddar, served over home fries		 $16.95
Garden Gourmet Skillet
Softly scrambled eggs, roasted zucchini, spinach, mushroom, sundried tomato, and sautéed onion, served over home fries		 $15.95
Nonna’s Skillet
Softly scrambled eggs, turkey sausage, fresh basil, roasted grape tomatoes & ricotta		 $16.95
French Toast & Crepes
Brioche French Toast
Fresh strawberries & creme fraiche		 $12.95
BKYLN French Toast
Stuffed with NY style cheesecake and topped with a warm berry compote

*Contains Gluten

 $14.95
Apple Strudel
Cinnamon apples & creme fraiche

*Contains Gluten

 $14.95
The Krispy Nutella
Fresh strawberry with nutella drizzle		 $14.95
Cinnamon Swirl French Toast
Creme fraiche & powdered sugar		 $14.95
Nutella & Banana Crepe $14.95
Berry & Brie Crepe $14.95
Pancakes
Classic Pancakes
Comes with powdered sugar		 $13.95
Chocolate Chip
Comes with powdered sugar		 $13.95
Cookie Dough
Comes with powdered sugar		 $14.95
Cinnamon Bun
Comes with powdered sugar		 $14.95
Apple Crumb
Comes with powdered sugar		 $14.95
Banana Walnut
Comes with powdered sugar		 $14.95
Blueberry Pecan
Comes with powdered sugar		 $14.95
Sweet Potato With Honey Butter
Comes with powdered sugar and honey butter

*contains gluten

 $14.95
Short Stack
Comes with powdered sugar		 $6.95
Waffles
Belgian With Fresh Berries
Comes with powdered sugar & whipped cream		 $14.95
Tennessee Chicken & Waffle
Cinnamon sugar sweet potato waffle with spicy honey fried chicken thigh, roasted red pepper & green onion

*Contains Gluten & Dairy

 $17.95
Chicken & Waffle
Belgian waffle with cornmeal crusted fried chicken thigh topped with fresh pineapple & strawberry, served with maple pecan syrup

*Contains Gluten & Dairy

 $17.95
Vegan Lunch
Foragers Salad
Spring mix, roasted Brussels sprouts, dried cranberries, almonds, sliced apples, red onion and honey poppy seed vinaigrette		 $14.95
Spicy Power Bowl
Quinoa with kale, edamame, sliced avocado, sweet potato, black beans, sliced tomato, chipotle mayo & microgreens		 $15.95
Plant Based Burger
With lettuce, tomato, and onion on multigrain roll		 $17.95
Vegan Portobello Panini
Grilled portobello, red onion, mixed greens, fresh mozzarella & sundried tomato pesto on a multigrain roll		 $16.95
Vegan Vienna Chicken
Breaded chicken, spinach, sundried tomato pesto and mozzarella on a toasted multigrain roll		 $16.95
Vegan Brooklyn Chicken
Breaded chicken, mushroom, spinach, & mozzarella on a garlic toasted multigrain roll		 $16.95
Vegan Kids Chicken Fingers $8.95
Lettuce Continue
Classic Chicken Caesar Salad
Grilled chicken, romaine hearts, rosemary croutons, shaved asiago		 $15.50
Toast House Salad
Grilled chicken, sliced green apple. red onion, candied walnuts & crumbled gorgonzola		 $15.95
Lemon Chicken Salad
Grilled chicken, dried cranberries, toasted almonds & crumbled goat cheese with homemade lemon dressing		 $15.95
Chicken In The Garden
Homemade chicken salad on a bed of mixed greens, with grape tomatoes, cucumber & red onion		 $15.50
Small Salad $7.95
Bistro Bites
Grilled Cheese Trio
Melted American, cheddar, and swiss with tomato on multigrain		 $13.95
Apple, Brie & Bacon Grilled Cheese
with caramelized onion on multigrain		 $14.95
BLT On Multigrain
Crisp bacon, lettuce, and tomato with basil mayo on toast multigrain		 $15.50
Wraps
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce and shaved asiago		 $16.50
Sweet-N-Smokey Chicken & Portobello
Roasted red peppers, baby spinach and goat cheese with balsamic glaze		 $16.95
Chicken Salad Wrap
Our homemade chicken salad with apple, mixed greens & tomato		 $16.50
Southwest Turkey Wrap
Turkey, crisp bacon, mixed greens, tomato, red onion & jack cheese with chipotle mayo		 $16.95
Sriracha Shrimp Wrap
Shrimp, black bean, roasted corn & pepper relish, & mixed greens with sriracha mayo		 $17.95
Hampton’s Ham & Brie
Honey ham, red onion, mixed greens, cucumber, apple, candied walnuts, brie with sweet mustard vinaigrette		 $16.50
Roast Beef & Avocado
Grilled red onion, mixed greens, tomato & white cheddar with avocado ranch		 $16.50
Toast Specialties
Turkey Reuben
Turkey, sauerkraut and swiss with 1000 island dressing on toasted rye		 $17.50
Bayou Flat
Cajun grilled turkey, red onion and tomato and jack cheese with chipotle mayo on toasted flat bread		 $16.95
The Bad Larry
Grilled turkey, crisp bacon, avocado, red onion, tomato and white cheddar with avocado ranch on a toasted flat bread		 $17.50
The Boardwalk Melt
Roast beef with crispy onions, spicy horseradish mayo & melted mozzarella on toasted rosemary focaccia		 $17.50
Cuban Reuben
Pulled pork, ham, sliced pickle, coleslaw, & melted swiss with spicy mustard on homebaked rye		 $17.50
Nashville Fried Chicken
Spicy fried chicken, mixed greens & pickles with chipotle aioli on a brioche roll		 $17.50
Vienna Chicken
Grilled chicken, spinach, fresh mozzarella with sun dried tomato pesto on a toasted multigrain roll		 $16.95
Brooklyn Chicken
Grilled chicken, mushroom, spinach & fresh mozzarella on a garlic toasted multigrain roll		 $17.50
The Breadwinner
Chicken salad, cucumber, tomato, gorgonzola cheese on toasted rosemary focaccia		 $16.50
RB Famous
Roast beef, grilled portobello, red onion & fresh mozzarella cheese with basil mayo on toasted rosemary focaccia		 $17.50
Steakhouse Burgers
New York Burger
Handmade beef burger, served with lettuce, tomato, & red onion on a brioche bun		 $16.95
Cheddar Bacon Burger
served with lettuce, tomato, & red onion on a brioche bun		 $17.95
Jack & Avocado Burger
served with lettuce, tomato, & red onion on a brioche bun		 $17.95
The Iron Skillet
Handmade beef burger topped with bacon jam, caramelized onion & pulled pork on a brioche bun		 $18.50
Homemade Chicken Burger
Handmade ground chicken burger served with lettuce, tomato & red onion on a multigrain roll		 $17.95
Plant Based Burger
All natural plant based burger with lettuce, tomato, & red onion on a multigrain roll		 $17.95
Kids
Kids Scrambled Eggs & Bacon
choice of bacon or sausage, served with home fries and toast		 $7.95
Kids French Toast
with strawberries, served with bacon or sausage		 $7.95
Kids Silver Dollar Pancakes
served with bacon or sausage		 $7.95
Kids Grilled Cheese
on whole wheat		 $7.95
Kids Chicken Fingers $8.95
Kids Cheese Quesadilla $7.95
Sides
100% Real Maple Syrup $2.50
Bagel $2.50
Muffin $4.00
Side Bacon Jam $2.50
Side Grilled Chicken $5.95
Side Coleslaw $2.95
Side Grilled Shrimp $6.00
Side Of Avocado $2.00
Side Of Bacon $5.50
Side Of Berries $3.50
Side Of Biscuits And Gravy $7.95
Side Of Corn Beef Hash $12.95
Side Of Dipping Sauce $0.75
Side Of Dressing $0.50
Side Of Eggs $2.00
Side Of French Fries $4.50
Side Of Fruit $2.95
Side Of Ham $4.50
Side Of Hollandaise $2.00
Side Of Home Fries $4.50
Side Of Jalapenos $0.75
Side Of Mixed Vegetables $3.95
Side Of Pickles $1.00
Side Of Sausage $5.50
Side Of Sausage Gravy $4.00
Side Of Spinach $0.00
Side Of Sweet Potato Fries $6.50
Side Of Toast $1.50
Side Of Turkey Bacon $4.50
Side Turkey Sausage $5.50
Side Of Vegan Sausage $4.50
Side Salsa $1.50
Side Tomato $1.50
Small Salad $7.95
Iced Teas
Iced Teas $3.50
Lemonades $3.50
Juices and Milk
Orange Juice $3.95
Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice $6.95
Apple Juice $3.95
Cranberry Juice $3.95
Pineapple Juice $3.95
Grapefruit Juice $3.95
Tomato Juice $3.95
Milk $3.50
Chocolate Milk $3.95
Smoothies
Strawberry Banana $5.95
Pineapple Coconut Sm $5.95
Wild Berry $5.95
Mango $5.95
Soda
Soda $3.50
Seltzer $2.50
Cocktails
Virgin Mary
House Bloody Mix		 $6.95

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Lani Olsen
Just had a brunch here and it was amazing. The service was the best we had in a long time and Jessica R was just awesome. She made our experience so enjoyable and even went out of her way to accommodate our pup. Truly amazing food – big portions!! Next time I will share with someone 🙂 and we will def come back next time we are in NY ❤️

… more

William Kucmierowski (Brimstone)
HUGE fan of Toast. Not only is the location visually stimulating; but I’ve never had a bad meal there! Crazy combinations that will tantalize your tastebuds, portions where you can justify the cost and the coffee is incredible. Polite and knowledgeable staff. Very highly recommend – one of the best spots for breakfast on Long Island.

… more

Amir Mullick
Amazing serving size and the menu is loaded with unbelievable options!!! I would go every weekend! Loved the pancakes, the toasts, their omelets, and every coffee option.

… more

Nick Renna
The search for the perfect coffee house has finally come to an end after visiting Toast! It’s the kind of place that makes me wish google had a 10 star rating instead of 5….because this place needs 10 and believe me it’s gonna be hard to top. Perfect scores all around for atmosphere, service and food. Just look at these pics. No pictures of the place because I’ll save the surprise when you visit and I know you’ll visit! Oh and if you’re wondering what is the meal in the pic, it’s called Miss Lucy’s Tortilla Skillet! Three letters O M G. Stop reading this review and run to Toast…you won’t be sorry. Oh and I just found out that they’re opening one in Long Beach this year! Can’t wait!

… more

Annie Pham
The best brunch I’ve had in a while! The staff was super friendly, the atmosphere is beautiful, the food and drinks were to die for! Definitely try this place out of you haven’t already!

… more

Rose Mathieu
Great experience at this restaurant! The server was friendly and it was good service all around. The food was good and flavorful. It was my first time going and definitely wanna go back to try more items on the menu. The price was reasonable

… more

M. Evans-Henry
Had a wonderful time at Toast for a work event. Staff was friendly and attentive. Food was absolutely amazing! There were about 8 of us and we were all satisfied with our drinks and our meal. I had the Graham cracker French toast with peanut butter and banana absolutely amazing! I also had a hot vanilla latte so good! Definitely recommended!

… more

Krystal S
I put my name on the virtual waitlist and it said 20-40 minutes

… more

Rodino Janowski
Hard to put into words how amazing this place has become from the ambiance to the most fantastic staff I’ve chatted with in Bay Shore. *Our waitress whom I’m sorry to forget your name (was a dancer from and early age 🙂 has the most beautiful personality and is a gem! The food was scrumptious! We had the lemon ricotta pancakes along with chicken and waffles and both were stunning. Can’t wait to go back

… more

TheRJWilliams
First time here. This was an amazing cozy breakfast spot, right in bayshore. They had fresh squeezed OJ. I didn’t know what I was missing.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch