Homey setting with a fireplace, bar & patio for housemade pastas & traditional Italian mains. Based on 542 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1789 Penfield Rd, Penfield, NY 14526
Phone: (585) 586-2426
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 4:30–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 4:30–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 4:30–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 4:30–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 4:30–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 4:30–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
TJ B
Great spot for a date night. The food was delicious, drinks were made well and my favorite part was the excellent service by our server Erica. She was charismatic and really made the experience personal. We happened to be there when it was very busy and they still accommodated us. The only thing is prepare to bring some $$$. The quality of the food and service was worth it. Plan ahead and make a reservation.
… more
Forever Wild Outdoors Adrenaline Adventures
We had lifelong friends up from South Carolina for their first tasting of Joey’s food. They were not disappointed!
… more
Christine Jusewicz
Disappointing at best! I ordered linguine with clam sauce and it was not good. I expected a nice sauce made with wine and olive oil with garlic and onion in it…along with minced or chopped clams. What I got was a bowl of pasta floating in what I assumed was beef broth with a couple of tiny pieces of onion in it….topped with a dozen steamed clams. It was tasteless other than the saltiness of the beef broth. So disappointing. I will likely not go back.
… more
Chansen Diaz
This is the best Italian spot in the town. I love pasta and bye far the best so far even still. Excellent place to take someone on a date, really chill vibes. I was checking to see if they are still open and decided to leave a review. I haven’t been in a few years, but seeing how they are still around says a lot.
… more
Lisa Hinman
We held our 40th wedding renewal at Joey’s Party House. The food and service were outstanding! Ronnie does a wonderful job and is extremely easy to work with. Beautiful event!
… more
Emma Whitmore
We went on a Thursday night around 6pm. There was a good amount of people there but still quiet a few tables open. It took over 15 minutes to place our drink order and it was because we had to stop one of the waitresses passing by our table. The bartender ended up being our waitress and she was very nice but it took awhile to order anything because she was busy at the bar. Absolutely nothing against her, seemed unfair to her that she was the only bartender for the restaurant and our waitress. Once we placed our orders they came in a decent amount of time. Loved the bread and oil that they give you! The food was okay (the red sauce wasn’t to our liking), atmosphere was nice, and employees were friendly, just not sure if it was worth the high prices. Not sure if we will be back again but can see why people like to go there.
… more
Shawn Ridgway
Amazing food and staff! Very worth it!
… more
Beth Ramzy
Went for dinner for our anniversary. We started with the calamari scampi and a meatball salad. I had the swordfish risotto special and my husband had the veal & chicken capicola. Everything was delicious!
… more
Taylor Alvarado
Was excited to try this place based on good reviews but was pretty disappointed. When we got there it took about 5-10 minutes for anyone to even acknowledge us. The employees kept walking past us ignoring us. A simple “someone will be with you shortly” would have been nice. Penne vodka did not taste like vodka at all. Honestly tasted like they served us mac and cheese
… more
james bardanis
Picked up dinner and it wasn’t good at all. Chicken French was average at best and the bolegnase was the worst I’ve ever had, the sauce was so bland it couldn’t have even come out of a jar. There was maybe a quarter cup of ground beef in the sauce. The pick up door at the back of the restaurant is literally the backdoor to the kitchen. You knock on it like ur asking for scraps and then wait outside the restaurant until someone from the front comes back there to cash you out( which took 10 min)….the food was sitting there the whole time. Definitely won’t go back.
… more
… View more