A Slice of NY Pizza Menu – Springville, UT

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Springville, UT

Based on 160 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

A Slice of NY Pizza 84663

Address:
210 N Main St, Springville, UT 84663

Phone: (801) 489-1916

Website:

Hours

Wednesday 11 AM–8 PM
Thursday 11 AM–8 PM
Friday 11 AM–9 PM
Saturday 11 AM–9 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday 11 AM–8 PM
Tuesday 11 AM–8 PM

Menu

Whole Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
Margherita Pizza
Supreme Pizza
BYO Pizza
Hawiian Pizza
Chicken Cutlet Parmesan Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Taco Pizza
Texan Pizza
Pizza by the Slice
Chicken Parmesan Pizza Slice
Build Your Own Pizza Slice
Cheese Pizza Slice
Taco Pizza Slice
Cheese Pinwheel Slice
Hawaiian Pizza Slice
Margherita Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Pinwheel Slice
Supreme Pizza Slice
Texan Pizza Slice
Garlic Knots
Garlic Knots
Marinara
Ranch
Desserts
Italian Rainbow Cookies
Lunch Specials
Lunch Special
Slice of pizza, 2 Garlic knots and a water or can of soda
Beverages
Soda
Gatorade
RockStar Punch
Brewed Iced Tea
Unsweetened Black Tea
Sweet Tea

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Tony Tiso
As a former New Yorker I was pretty skeptical to try a “slice of NY pizza” in Springville, UT (a town not exactly know for its cuisine). But I was blown away – just the right amount of cheese, just the right amount of grease, perfect texture. They nailed it. The garlic knots are addicting too. Add in the friendly service and family atmosphere and it might just be my new favorite pizza around here…watch out Two Jacks!!! If you’ve read this far go pick up a pie already you won’t be disappointed.

… more

Star Anise
AMAZING!! I fell in love with a NY slice in my visits to New York – no other pizza place in Utah holds a candle to them. The large slice with a crispy bottom, thin chewy dough, perfectly balanced sauce and cheese, and of course – the iconic pepperonis cupping tiny pools of oil. If you’ve ever been to Little Italy you know this is EXACTLY what you’re looking for. The pizzas are priced well, the service is quick, and this is my new staple for when I’m missing the Big Apple.

… more

Sheri Mueller
You gotta try the pepperoni roll! This pizzeria just opened up, and boy was I impressed! It’s 1000x better than the 7-11 that they bought and renovated. The employees were so kind and helpful, they smile at you and make eye contact and are willing to answer questions. They strive to make your order just right! I got a Hawaiian and supreme- they were delicious. I’ve been to New York and had pizza around Manhattan, and it was spot on NY pizza taste, texture and temperature (nice and hot and fresh!). Garlic knots are hot and tasty too. They have some Italian cookies as well.

… more

Austin Stokes
Very good pizza. The garlic knots are pretty good too, just make sure you eat them while they are warm. Excellent service and it was quick too. Price was definitely worth it for how big the slices are and how good the food is

… more

Bradley Platt
Edit: I had to come back and edit this review after the totally inappropriate, rude, and mean comments made by the owners here. I am currently among the top 10% of restaurant reviewers on google maps. I have over 520k views on my reviews. I tell it like it is. You better believe I’m not going to give any good recommendations for this place. I have critiqued many places and never received such a response. Professional restauranteurs respond to such critiques with promises to do better and gratitude for helping them to do better. Not here…..the owner insults you.

… more

Mean_TeddyKiller
Pizza could’ve used like two more minutes in the oven but otherwise very good. Update, I got pizza here again and it was completely raw dough in the middle along with the pizza’s being folded over in the boxes

… more

Jennifer Cummings
Burned pizza, bad service and very disappointed. I hate to leave a negative review but my experience was truly a let down. I ordered 2 large pizzas, a supreme & a pepperoni, to go. I had a nice talk with the owner while I waited. When I arrived home and opened the boxes the pizzas looked fabulous. Unfortunately it was all downhill from there. As we bit into the pizza all we could taste was blackened, burned crust. I turned the pizza over to find the underside charred to black. It was truly inedible. The second pizza was the same. I immediately called to try and get a replacement but the store had closed by then. We were left to scramble for a new meal as the pizza wasn’t fit to be eaten.

… more

Tayla Chapa
Popped in and order a slice of everything to try! The grandma’s pie was AMAZING! And the garlic knots are to die for. Ranch was heavenly. The place has a ton of drinks to choose from and a fun little ambiance inside. Owned and operated by the cutest family. Will gladly come back and support them!

… more

Savannah Tiso
I know this hurts to hear, but Utah generally has the most flavorless, blandest, cultureless food in America. Great state…terrible cuisine. Except this place. Truly a standout for pizza. And I know good pizza. Not to mention the staff is super friendly and the atmosphere is chill. Come support your local business, we need more restaurants of this quality. 5 stars!

… more

Carl Spencer
Absolutely love this place! Chris is great and I’m glad he brought this store here. We have a lot of pizza options in town, but I eat here multiple times a week now. It’s so convenient to grab a slice or two, and get on your way. I’ve tried every flavor so far, all great.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions