Based on 581 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
904 N Rte 49, Casey, IL 62420
Phone: (217) 932-2220
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: facebook.com
Reviews
Nicole B.
Honestly the pizza was ok. It wasn’t great. It wasn’t horrible. My order was messed up, but the owner took care of it. Also the bottom of my pizza was a bit charred.. I am not a fan, although others may be. It is thin crust. The toppings and sauce were delicious. The cherry and blueberry dessert pizzas were ok. They were a bit bland. Like they needed something..
… more
Judi Andrews
We were on a road trip and decided to stop and see all the local big stuff – the pizza came up on my food search and we are glad it did. It definitely took a while to make, but it was worth the wait for an evening meal. Disappointed that my husband would have had to wait nearly an hour for deep dish, but the regular pizza was really amazing. The staff could have been more hospitable but overall it was a good experience. The environment has a fun, laid back family feel to it. The kids really enjoyed the giant pizza cutter out front!
… more
The Truth
I’m trying this for the first time. Their cheese sticks, prima Rosa, pizza, and sandwiches were all fantastic and quality. Will say the Italian beef had very little beef. I didn’t deduct any points though. The one young waitress working tables is hustling and bustling. Great service. I’ll be back
… more
JJ Passalacqua
We had the Deep Dish Garden Pie Pizza. Delicious! I recommend call ahead to order of you want Deep Dish. Cuts your wait time in half
… more
Amanda Bruce
Traveling through and stopped to see the Big Things in a Small Town. Didn’t want fast food, so we opted to try Greathouse Pizza. Glad we did! Lots of options, friendly staff, and the pizza was amazing.
… more
Jason Adams
Drove an hour!! Spent 2 1/2 hours there!!! Food was really good………..Service and Management/Ownership was the WORST!!!!!!!!Took us over a hour and a half to get our food!!!!
… more
Tiffany Pulkowski
Visiting from out of town and found this local place for a bite to eat and it was great! Everything we ordered was fantastic. We had the cheese strips, a deep dish pizza, a thin pizza, and an Italian beef sandwich. Definitely recommend each of those! The deep dish pizza does take nearly an hour ro cook but is absolutely worth it! Only complaint is that they don’t bring all the food out together so the people who ordered the sandwich and thin pizza were finished eating before the others got their deep dish pizza.
… more
Kimberly Strowmatt
My salad was wonderful,pizza the absolute best but I paid 7.99 for like a sample size of Mac and cheese. The atmosphere was very bland . Took a bit to get used to no waiters. The employee’s very friendly.
… more
Jennifer Dean
Came from out of town and excited to eat here after 7 years. Arrived an hour and 1/2 after opening on a slow Wednesday. Gravel parking lot. Sign on front door for additional charge for credit card use. Sign near counter to seat self and order at register when ready. Register area is very “busy” with writing/menu. A black stand up cooler pushed up against front counter blocks view into kitchen. Dining tables set up odd. Ordered a 10 inch thin crust cheese pizza, cinnamon knots, small and regular drink. $25. Credit card copy to sign had a place to leave a tip before obtaining any food or drinks but you are your own wait staff. Receipt offered and received one from credit card terminal but not from register with price of items rang up.
… more
Morgan Colyer
This place is Pizza Palace! There is no where nearby that you can get this quality of pizza. It’s worth the drive over to Casey IL for a taste of real pizza. They have several speciality pizzas to try. The deep dish is excellent. If you plan on ordering one be prepared for a 45 min wait. It’s totally worth it. They have great garlic knots and salads to start with. The only down side to this restaurant is the beverage they serve. I’m not one who enjoys Pepsi. If you do you’ll be in paradise in this small yet huge place of pizza.
… more
… View more