No-frills branch of a family-owned chain offering pizza, subs & pasta to carry out. Based on 286 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1749 W 5th Ave, Columbus, OH 43212
Phone: (614) 488-7934
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Andrew Lowry
I haven’t had this pizza in a long time (5+) years, but it’s somewhere my parents used to get all the time when I was younger. I got a double pepperoni well done on a Tuesday where they had a special and I only paid $15.95 and it was totally worth it. The pizza itself was delicious (I love the sauce) and exactly how I would have wanted it. I’ll definitely be back again soon.
… more
Camille Ferrell
They have good pizza, but they put way too much cheese. If cheese is your thing, I definitely recommend them. Sauce is just a tad bit spicy. Not all that spicy. It’s really good pizza. My favorite part is how they kinds burn the edges of the pepperoni.
… more
Carol D
Everyone is always so nice here and the prices are very fair. We’ve only ordered pizza and it’s very good: crisp crust and lots of toppings. One favorite is the white pizza. The flavor of the tomatoes is outstanding. My other favorite to get if I want something different than the rest of the family is an individual sized sausage, mushroom, and green pepper. There’s something about that size that is perfection in both quality and quantity. I highly recommend.
… more
Stephanie Thompson
The pizza, bread sticks and pasta salad were delicious! We ordered for pickup and the staff was not very welcoming, borderline rude when we picked up. Would still go back because the pizza is THAT good.
… more
Jennifer Scott
My family orders from here every Friday!! We have for years. Hands down the best pizza in town . If your wanting pasta try the rigatoni!! Rotolo’s is a staple in our home for Friday night pizza night. You’ll love the atmosphere and everyone who works there. Highly recommend you try it A.S.A.P
… more
J.R. McMillan
Rotolo’s in Grandview was among our first Columbus-style pizzas when we moved to Central Ohio.
… more
Carter
I stopped by to purchase some dough to try and make a pizza at home. It was one of the best “homemade” pizza’s I’ve ever had. I will be stopping in again soon to buy more dough and pizza! Rotolo’s is a fantastic pizza shop!!!!
… more
daniel cromwell
In this constant changing world of conveyor pizzas it’s good to know that the Rotolo family is still here giving you quality like it was done yesterday by their parents I know that people are in a hurry and they want everything done quickly and on the conveyor belt but there’s nothing like quality over speed and quantity freshly baked in the oven by a Pizzaiola (a trained pizza baker) instead of setting a timer for the pizza to go through a conveyor oven machine. That’s Amore
… more
jayden Hollis
Not only the best pizza in Columbus, its the best in OHIO!
… more
Robert Nelson
My favorite pizza when I lived near west campus. And still Just as good as I recall 35 years ago.
… more
… View more