Based on 82 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price
Address:
402 E Broad St, Smithville, TN 37166
Phone: (615) 215-1313
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Maryanna Miller
Pizza was soggy, wet and not very tasty. Toppings slid right off and all that was left was a piece of soggy dough and pile of goop we had to scoop back on and eat with a fork. No drink machine. Serve can soda, for $1.50 per can with no free refills on them. Prices were very high. $18 for our soggy pizza. Waitress was very friendly but owner lady kept coming to our table making sure everything was fine even though We never complained, was friendly but we constantly had someone at our table being overly attentive like they were waiting for a complaint. We are not complaining just sharing our experience so maybe the owners can fix some of these issues for future customers. Definitely had better pizzeria pizzas.
… more
David Walker
Most excellent Italian food, well worth the drive
… more
Caleb Hendrix
We dined in here a couple weeks ago and the atmosphere was nice. The food was decent but nothing to write home about. The pizza was hard to eat because it was so greasy when you picked a slice up all the toppings slid off and all that was left was a soggy piece of dough. The flavors were great but the dough was just soaked with grease. The chicken parmigiana was good, lasagna definitely sub par, and the spaghetti was ok. I was shocked when we ordered two sprites and they came out in a can. After three refills we were charged 1.50 per can and spent 7.50 on 5 cans of Sprite which is absurd. Sadly it was not a very pleasant experience for us.
… more
Tammy Davis
We were greeted right away by our very gracious and attentive server. This place is very clean, modest, and welcoming. We felt treated as family. Now, the food. If you enjoy fresh ingredients (I’m talking “real” food here), and non-cookie cutter type food, then you’ll love it! We did! We don’t live close, but the food and the atmosphere will definitely bring us back often. Enjoy!
… more
Geoff German
My wife and I moved here from New York (via South Carolina) and its has been a struggle to find a good piece of freaking pizza in this state. Honestly the closest thing we have had to good pizza was something we found at a mall (note: this pizza SUCKED). So you can imagine our surprise when we found ourselves in the tiny little town of Smithville and stumble upon the tiny little Italian restaurant and they have the BEST DAMN PIZZA I HAVE HAD IN THIS STATE! The crust was thin, the cheese was plentiful and the pizza had a layer of grease on the top that only a delicious piece of pie would have on it. It was just fantastic. I live two hours from Sicily’s Best but I will be heading there for a slice at least once a month and I know that it will be worth the four hour round trip. So, if you are a person who lives in this state and is forced to suffer with the garbage that most of this state considers pizza, I feel for you and send you out to Sicily’s Best where you can get a taste of some decent pizza at an affordable price. Hats off to the entire crew at Sicily’s Best.
… more
Joshua Yates
Ordered a large supreme and garlic knots (buns?), the pizza was very good (best I’ve had around here). The garlic knots could have used more garlic for my tastes, and some sauce for dipping them would have been nice. Overall very good, and I plan to return.
… more
Sandy C Brown
Truly impressive Sicilian/Italian food! Perfect calamari every time we order it, pasta dishes seasoned expertly, wonderful sandwiches and salads. Cannoli prepared to order; even my grandma would love them. Try the homemade garlic knots: oh my! Great pizza, and changing specials make this a regular stop for us. Can’t go wrong!
… more
Ray Simpson
Ordered the antipasto salad as an appetizer. All of the entrees came with soup or salad but, they did not have soup so ordered other sides stating we would’ve liked soup. Charged us $5 for each side and tried to say the waitress told us there was no substituting (never happened). Management handled issue very poorly.
… more
Robin Lineberger
Came to visit in Sept and the wings were very dry and over cooked. Yes I know you have to cook chicken to a certain degree and time but these were way over cooked. We have had two bad experiences here and always go back to give it another try. You would think at the price they would not be over cooked. Also yes I know someone is going to say something bad back for this review and I would hope they would hold respect for their customer’s when responding to reviews. They do have excellent food and are a little pricey. But please hold respect for your customer’s when responding. All we are doing is trying to let you know when a mistake has been made so you can correct it next time. Thanks so much for understanding and we look forward to our next visit.
… more
kyra west
A much needed addition to Smithville. My husband and I had the problem of needing to drive out of town for decent food. Sicily’s Best is better than decent. There is a whole experience that comes with eating Italian recipes that have been handed down through generations. This is not a fast food joint or a place to get your “meat and two,” it’s a place for celebrating family, culture, and thoughtfully prepared cuisine. The prices are higher than this town is used to, but the food is much better than anything you can get here in our tiny town. I recommend it to everyone and if you’re not happy the owners are always more than ready to try and make it better! Oh and the pizza is INCREDIBLE.
… more
… View more