Colorful counter-serve joint for thin-crust pies, calzones & salads to eat in or to go. Based on 59 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $$
Address:
600 S Holly St, Denver, CO 80246
Phone: (303) 316-7353
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Stanley Trout
Nothing to look at and the service is hit or miss but this place has the best pizza I’ve had in Denver. They are the only place I’ve been that really understands how to make good pizza crust. You can put whatever you want on a pizza but if you start with crappy crust you get crappy pizza. Good toppings, good sauce and , as I said, great crust.
… more
Stanley Griffin
Loved the pizza! The crust is just right. You either know it or you don’t and these guys have it down. Would’ve been a 5 but the specialty pizza toppings seemed like they weee thrown on top and they fell off when we were eating them. Not to say it tasted bad at all! Great flavor, fun to eat a super giant slice!
… more
Andres Gerardo
Ordered a bbq chicken pizza, picked up and the staff was really friendly. When i got home to get ready to eat it it had pork, thinking it wouldn’t be a big deal, called back and asked to see if we could swap it out. The receptionist, still very friendly said it should be a problem, would check with her manager. Rick, the owner, came on, and explained to him my situation. He said he would be happy to do it, but would have to charge me for the pizza again. I told him, we would give him the pizza back, uneaten, but said he would still charge us for it. He refused to help out his customer, which was crazy given how much we paid for a pizza. This is my first online review of a restaurant, and because of such a poor treatment, I would NOT recommend one to eat there. If you do happen to run into an issue and want to exchange your meal, know that you will be paying for BOTH meals.
… more
Kyle Huber
Have ordered delivery a few times from NY Pizzeria. Overall it’s pretty good… At least much better than the chains. The delivery is quick. I really like the Queens specialty pizza…. Mmm. Not too pricey but not the cheapest either. Overall a good combination of taste and cost.
… more
Sha Cohen
We are frequent customers. Probably at least once a month. I once went in to pick up a pie to take home; the owner apologized that the pie was going to be a few more minutes and offered me a beer on the house. How did he know that’s all I really wanted? Great service, on time delivery and of course great pizza.
… more
Mercedes Deville
I’ve always thought New York pizza was the best pizza in “fast food” type
… more
Mary Beck
Terrible pizza terrible wings
… more
Morgan Evans
Disappointed. Placed an order for delivery and was quoted 45 -50 minutes for pizza and wings to arrive. After an hour, called to check status of order and was told that it should be arriving any minute. Waited another half hour and called to cancel my order. The representive did not ask for my order number or any other confirmation other than if I had ordered a 16 inch pizza. He did say a unempathatic sorry but failed to offer an explanation as to why the order never arrived or even attempt to recover our patronage of the business. Way to impress a first time customer.
… more
Empress Jah9 (NeeNee)
I had given up on pizza since I moved here from NYC. It seemed pointless to even eat pizza anymore. But I just moved to this neighborhood and have yet to go grocery shopping, so I thought, what the hell? Yo, let me tell you, this pizza made me miss home, but not in a “god, why can’t people make pizza everywhere like they do in NY?” kind of way, but more of a “oh, now that’s home” kind of way!!! This pizza made me believe that there are a few New Yorkers out here in cowboy land. The only problem I have now is sticking to my diet knowing you are right up the street. But seriously, great pizza! The honey in the dough really makes a difference. Great pizza. Don’t know about the rest of the food. Keep up the good work!
… more
mark clay
So we just moved into the area and I wanted to try a local non-chain place. I read some reviews and decided to give them a try. I ordered a 20″ pizza @ 8:30pm on a Friday nite–not exactly the dinner rush. We live less than a mile away and we waited over an hour to have a cold pizza delivered! So much for a first impression–make that first AND LAST impression.
… more
… View more