Based on 209 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
857 Mill Creek Rd, Manahawkin, NJ 08050
Phone: (609) 597-1156
Website: https://www.anthonyspizzerianj.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Timothy Shane
If you THINK you can find a better slice, best of luck. I’m a few towns over and we hit this place whenever we can. Usually on the way to the island we’ll grab a pie, it’s a PERFECT New Jersey pizza. Guy at the counter told me he did 500 pizzas recently in a day – and I’m willing to bet they were all incredible. Keep it up and keep killing it guys!
… more
Litzy A
Delicious and fresh pizza! We got the supreme pizza and a sub and they were both great! Staff is friendly, fast paced, and attentive. The restaurant itself is clean and inviting. One of the best pizza places near LBI!
… more
adam jeschke
Visiting Beach Haven West 8/26 we decided to get pizza on our first night. It’s was great! So good we decided to do pizza and sandwiches on our last night there as well. From upstate NY home of the cold cheese pizza and the pizza from Anthony’s was better than most places here.
… more
olga cheoiglesias
Anthony’s has Great Pizza And Chicken Wings!! Amongst Other Delish Dishes!! The people there are Friendly and Nice!!
… more
Diane Ciemnolonski
I’ve been on LBI for a while and was dying for some Wings and a Cheesesteak, I’m very picky about both, the cost on the Island for wings is outrageous, and the cheesesteaks hardly have meat and are expensive too. So I google Wings and found this place and took a chance. Everyone working was super friendly, ordered my wings and cheesesteak with fried onions, and there it was ready within 15 minutes. The wings were very good, the hot sauce was tasty. The Cheesesteak was amazing. There was tons of meat, and it was extremely tasty. The roll was so fresh. I only ate half and saved the other half for the next day, and ended up eating it cold . It was still extremely good, and the roll head up overnight. Definitely recommen.
… more
Shelly
Best pizza around. Old school. Great oil, sauce, and fresh cheese. Eddie is family. Great guy, always has been. Give him and his family your business.
… more
Alex Kinon
Whether you call it Anthony’s, Neil’s or Eddie’s, this is your #1 spot for pizza and Italian specialty foods in the Beach Haven West area. Totally dedicated and focused on offering excellent food, ownership doesn’t want the distraction of fooling around with delivery, so pick-up or eat-in are your only options.
… more
Mitch Wasserman
Great pizza and sandwiches. Pleasant, helpful staff. Nothing fancy as far as atmosphere. Order early on summer Fridays. We love it!
… more
William Schadewald
To get right to point good food friendly service. I ordered the peppered steak with mushrooms and a chicken parm. Both were cooked perfectly. Chicken wasn’t dry and both had plenty of flavor. Sorry no pictures. I was so hungry. We just ate
… more
James Sheehan
pizza has been consistently on point. I was really impressed with the cheesesteaks.
… more
… View more