We have been serving fresh and delicious food with a friendly smile. When you come to Arni’s Monticello, you’re getting more than just a good meal, you’re experiencing one of Indiana’s finest restaurant traditions. Family and friends all gather here to experience the feel-good environment, great service, and the one of a kind thin crust pizza. Call today or visit our website for more information!
Family-friendly regional chain eatery with a simple selection of pizza, pasta & Italian sandwiches. Based on 513 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup
Address:
517 N Main St, Monticello, IN 47960
Phone: (574) 583-2764
Website: http://www.meetyouatarnis.com/
Hours
| Sunday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Laurie Alford
Such good food and excellent service for us out of towners❣️ Thank you for your time today❣️
… more
Lee Anne Rossio
We ordered 2 pizzas for carry out and they were delicious! The staff were very friendly, working together when I picked up our order. Would highly recommend Aiden’s Big Show pizza.
… more
Jonathan Rich
The Arni’s senior salad is the best option here. Pizza is okay. Service is hit or miss depending on who helps you. It was my third time here and the kid at the front counter was a little rude.
… more
jcj sutt
Food is usually good but the fried chicken on my salad was horrible. It was very dry and hard. Didn’t notice until I got it home. Oh well dog got a crunchy snack.
… more
Teresa Reedy
The hot ham and cheese was great but nothing special. The building was cold and the service was okay. Will be awhile before I go back
… more
Brandon Rhine
The best pizza and salads around. Aidens big show pizza is great. A new favorite.
… more
Kathleen Preston
Love this Arni’s- we always have great service!! The Arni’s Senior Junior salad is my fav and the hubby is all about the pizza. If you’re looking for someplace good- check it out!!
… more
Tom Bombadil
Ground Pepperoni pizza and an Arni’s Jr. Salad will be worth the detour, can’t wait for another road trip to stop. Pizza is still great after heating it back up in the oven.
… more
Kevin Foster
Reserved a table for 12. When we got there someone was sitting at it who had 11 friends coming. Ok. Honest mistake. No wait staff to take your order. Works like an uppity fast food joint. Order at the counter then they’ll bring it to you. Ordered two pitchers of soda. We got warm liters of soda and Styrofoam glasses half full of ice. They brought out appetizers but no table service. After asking for that we got four small paper plates. When the pizza showed up it reminded me of cheap frozen pizza. When we tasted it, WOW, I couldn’t have been more right. They advertise”best pizza in town”. Apparently Walmart doesn’t sell frozen pizzas in Monticello. This was our second attempt at dinner in this town. I am totally convinced Monticello, Indiana is the culinary armpit of America. Good thing we passed a Taco Bell and an Arby’s on the way in. Did I mention they don’t sell beer or wine? I didn’t, did I. That would have made this tolerable. I would give pizza hut 5 stars before I gave this place one. You’ve been warned.
… more
Tif Danford
Staff always friendly love their pizza, breadsticks and salad. I really love their cheesecake on a stick
… more
… View more
