As a family owned business, Massey’s has been winning the hearts of Columbus pizza lovers from one generation to the next. Massey’s has a secret dough recipe, baked on the hearth, with abundant toppings including: old world tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, aged provolone, Massey’s exclusive Guido Brand Portofino Pepperoni, house made Italian sausage and Italian meatballs. A unique blend of ingredients and fresh ground spices has given Massey’s the “Perfect Pizza Taste”.
Local pizzeria chain serving wide range of pizzas (including famed pepperoni), subs, salads & more. Based on 916 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
4464 E Main St, Whitehall, OH 43213
Phone: (614) 559-2222
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Rebecca
Best pizza I have eaten. A blast from the past with old world style pepperoni, onions, green peppers, banana peppers, and mushrooms!
… more
Bryan Luckey
Have always enjoyed Masseys and this location was no exception. Had the buffet. Got my fill and food was great. Employees were friendly and helpful. Very Happy with the experience.
… more
Daniel Sizemore
Placed a phone credit card order at the Whitehall store and was charged double and within 5 minutes had two fraudulent charges placed on my card(was alerted by the bank). When I called the store they denied any knowledge and couldn’t even remove the charge for two pizzas when I only ordered one. Next day I called the corporate office and was told they wouldn’t dispute the second charge and would investigate the fraud. I never heard from them again. Skip ahead one year and my grandson who lives with me ordered a pizza from there without me knowing. They at first said they don’t deliver here. Then said payment would have to be in cash. He was ok with that and ordered a pizza that never arrived. Absolutely worst pizza experience ever especially for the high prices they charge. I would give zero stars if that was an option.
… more
spirit Love
It’s a little more then most pizza places but for good reason, they have so much food that other places don’t have n it taste great. They have a buffet on weekdays with a lot of variety. I recommend to everyone unless ur trying to save money.
… more
Darin Atzenhoefer
I’ve been to Gahanna, Lancaster and 161 locations, Whitehall is the most awesome place to order a Massey pizza from employees, to cleanliness to just very well prepared and tasty pizza I will only go there for my pizza fix .thanks everyone you don’t get good service anymore!!!
… more
Jim Barnhart
The place is filthy and run down. Upon arriving, most of the tables were dirty and had to ask for one to be cleaned. The air conditioner apparently did not work as the thermostat on the wall was set at 65 but it was 85 in the dining room. Salad bar was empty on several things and went low on pizza (Down to three dried out pieces). Waited an hour and finally asked if they were going to put any more out. Not sure what is going on here but this place needs help.
… more
Norma King
The absolutely best pizza in town. The crust is crispy with just a hint of cornmeal underneath. The toppings are plentiful and fresh. Their subs are all served hot with plenty of fixings. The staff is friendly and personable. Prices are great.
… more
Leavy Peretto
The pizza is just ok but the subs are bomb .com. the meats have a great flavor and I love the way the pepperoni curls. These guys call themselves the “Cadillac ” of pizzas and their toppings were premium as well as the sauce. The crust was a little hard for my liking but still decent. The sub was way better than expected and the service was on point. The guy on the phone was very well spoken and definitely added to the pleasentness of this ordering experience.
… more
Judy Gaines
I HAVE MORE THAN LOVED & CRAVED MASSEY’S FOR ALL MY LIFE AND ALWAYS WILL NO MATTER WHAT I HAVE ORDERED IVE ALWAYS BEEN HAPPY AND FULL!! SO GLAD MY PARENTS STARTED US OFF IN LIFE WITH YOU SINCE WE WERE LIL’KIDS!! !!! DINE IN, TAKE OUT AND DELIVERY!!
… more
Karina Sanchez
We’ve ordered for pickup here twice now. The first time we had no issues with our pizza or mozzarella sticks. They were ready on time and were good. The only reason I’m giving 2 stars is thanks to the first visit. This time, not so much. We got two subs and garlic dippers. No issues on the meatball sub, but the veggie sub we ordered was a disaster. We specifically said no onion, and it says this on the receipt they gave us as well. The sub we got was missing lettuce, tomato, banana peppers, and Italian dressing and was LOADED with onions. The picture I attached is just the onions from one side of one half of the sub. My husband went back to get a replacement and it was not any better. We were starving by this time so we didn’t want to wait for yet another replacement, and at least this one didn’t have onions. It was still missing the things listed above and now had green olives for some reason. I’m so disappointed.
… more
… View more