This eclectically decorated BYOB eatery lures locals with its artisanal specialty pizzas. Based on 713 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
9 S Black Horse Pike, Blackwood, NJ 08012
Phone: (856) 228-1234
Website: http://holytomatopies.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 3–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–9 PM |
| Thursday | 3–9 PM |
| Friday | 3–9 PM |
| Saturday | 3–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jonathan Schettino
Better than 5 stars! This is perhaps the best pizza I’ve had outside of Naples! The reason: quality ingredients. We got “the flip.” The tomatoes for the sauce are locally grown and hand crushed. Besides the amazingly flavorful tomatoes, the sauce has a good quality extra virgin olive oil, fresh garlic, and the perfect amount of dried oregano in it. Usually ingredients get lost in the sauce. Not here, the individual flavors can actually be appreciated. The crust was the right amount of crispy and thin. Staff/owners were very friendly. In a state that is known for good pizza, this place really stands out. I will definitely be back from now on every time I visit my family in Jersey!
… more
victorfrombaltimore
What a great little spot outside of Philadelphia. Tomato pie is legit. Fast & friendly service. Cool atmosphere. Welcoming owners. Can’t wait to stop in again!
… more
Gabrielle Capaldo
If I could give this place more than 5 stars I would!! The owners, Tom and Terry, are the nicest people ever. Their food is INCREDIBLE! From the salads to the pizza, everything is so so delicious. My family and I go there all the time and we are obsessed. If you are ever nearby, and looking for amazing food and a homey feel, you have to go to Holy Tomato!
… more
Francis Lapp
Food is usually good. Service is usually good. Last time I went, pizza was really late coming out, and they used an outrageous amount of garlic. Made it really tough to get through the $25 pizza.
… more
Bryan Startzenbach
One of my favorite places! This BYOB has great pizza – thin and crispy with fresh ingredients. The house salad is just amazing.
… more
Joshua Pashalian
I recently had the pleasure of dining at Holy Tomato, and I must say, it was an experience that exceeded my expectations. From the moment I entered the restaurant, I was greeted with warmth and kindness. Holy Tomato truly lives up to its name, offering a heavenly combination of delightful pizza and exceptional service.
… more
Denise Christinzio
This is a small, funky restaurant filled with eclectic decor, fun atmosphere, delicious pizza selections, salads and homemade
… more
John Reiff
Hate to give a good spot bad reviews but this pizza was just not good. It was cold to start de.f don’t recommend pickup. They burned it also so a burned cold pizza. And the overall quality is not what it is..I give it maybe a 3 but a 2 because of it being cold.
… more
Louis Dalessio
WOW! What a great place to enjoy some of Americas favorites! The wife and I made another visit to this Spectacular Diamond in the Rough. Our starters were their House Salad, which we highly recommend, and their Mexican Street Corn. Absolutely Delicious, with a taste all its own. The salad is so tasty with its home made dressing and the corn is like no other-it’s that good! A Must in Our Book! Then comes the Pizza, we have tried most, no one favorite as they are all uniquely tasteful and different. Last but not least, the deserts, The Cinna-Balls are a sweet lovers dream and the Cappuccino belongs in a Five Star restaurant and I’m not kidding when we say that. And to complement the Awesome food are the very delightful staff and of course The Owners. We can’t say enough nice things about Everyone here and the food they serve. All we can do is tell any and all to put this on your food bucket list-you will be very happy you did so and no need to thank us. Looking forward to our next visit here!
… more
Mia S
Best pizza I’ve ever had, and service was amazing! Michelle was our server, and she was very attentive and sweet
… more
… View more