Based on 85 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
Address:
192 Maple Ave #4702, White Plains, NY 10601
Phone: (914) 761-8661
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
T Powis
Family oriented is right, the owner is personable, humorous, and still working the cash register… Best garlic knots I’ve ever had, but this brownie is EVERYTHING!
… more
Jailene
The pizza is great for take out and I love eating at the restaurant. I love the cold cuts and bread w/ butter that they give you. Serving sizes are big especially their pasta dishes. Waitress is super nice and accommodating.
… more
Anthony kuhn
I really wanted to love this place, but the pie just wasn’t very good. The crust was much too chewy and the sauce is kinda tasteless. The service was friendly enough and everything else was fine, but I just wanted a better pizza. The search for a good local pizza joint continues…
… more
Robert Leavy
Pizza was good, hot and quick. 2 large custom pies on a Friday in under 30 mins for pick up.
… more
Walter Garff
If I could have one pizzeria in my neighborhood it would be Magnottas. I love Angelo, his pizza and his legacy. They are beautiful Italian Americans. Great bang for the buck here
… more
Chester Randolph
I just hate that they are going out of business.I was born and raised in White Plains NY. I bought so many Pizza’s from Magnottas, I could own that place. I was living across the street when they first opened the doors.I now live in Alabama, and I am trying to get back to White Plains so I can visit my favorite a Pizza Place, but it looks like they will not be in business by the time I arrive in Westchester. If only I could get back to Magnotta’s before they close. They were the best, are the best, and will always hold the title as the best, even if they are closed. Angelo take care, we truly enjoyed your food.
… more
Vincent Orlando
Been getting pizza here since I was a kid, hasn’t changed still one of the best pizza’s you will ever have. All the food here is good, garlic knots are also the best in the city. Prices are very reasonable as well.
… more
Pete Fields
BEST. GRANDMA. SLICE. EVER. Highly recommend every assortment of pizza slices available. If you’re up for an amazing pie and a few laughs from the owners (real old school Italians), I suggest you call/ run to this place immediately. I love coming here
… more
Katherine Henderson
Best pizza I’ve had in the 6 years I’ve lived in White Plains. Reasonably priced, perfect ratio of sauce to cheese, really awesome garlic knots, and friendly staff.
… more
Victoria Oppenheimer
Good food at reasonable prices with good service and a friendly owner would have me going back at times – but sauce that tastes like my grandma was in the kitchen keeps me going as often as possible! Best thing on the menu?….eggplant rollentini….no….the meatballs….no….the chicken parm….no….the pizza….but if you have pizza you don’t eat the slices of amazing bread that comes with the meals. Okay….maybe go A LOT and try everything!
… more
… View more