We’re an independent Pizza shop located center of town, and are proud to be the favorite for locals to meet friends for a fresh pizza or delivered straight to their home. We serve homemade, hand-tossed pizza all year-round, and the stone ovens turn out New York-style pies every day from midday until close. Come see us today!
Based on 319 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2123 Templeton Gap Rd, Colorado Springs, CO 80907
Phone: (719) 265-6922
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Josue
Went there for the 14 inch pizza, the thing was was not crisp, pepperoni was non almost non existent. Sauce is decent and so is cheese mix but when the price is higher than than that of almost anyone else. The service was fine and the atmosphere was present but overall you’re better off spending you’re money at Louis or black jack
… more
Leslie S
Ordered Calzones twice. First time delivery and it was overcooked. Ordered again for curbside delivery. Asked for light ricotta because the first was too much-got no ricotta at all and calzone was so over cooked you wanted to scrap the black off. Tried the fried pasta and it was so cooked you chewed it like gum. I will stick to Louie’s
… more
Kathy Creech
You can buy by the slice. They are New York size slices, so one was enough for me, kids could split a piece. I really like the slice I got called fugetaboutit. They have beer. I will go back for sure. I liked that it wasn’t downtown or on the Northside of town. It’s more of a neighborhood vibe and in a small shopping center. I think I will try take out next and order full-size pizza.
… more
Tim Boyette
Had Joey’s NY Pizza for the first time this week and was *so* pleasantly surprised! I tried two of the meatless pizzas, Cheese and Margherita. They were large NY slices and both were delicious! The Margherita pizza is bold AF, very tomato forward and a decidedly thick pie. LOTS of Parm right on the slice. Daring.
… more
Jennifer Garcia
the staff is very nice me make you feel very welcome. I love the garlic rolls. The pizza is very good New York style. The price is not overly expensive it’s about average for pizza. I recommend giving it a chance. I really like it my husband likes it.
… more
Cynthia Wisekal
First visit at this pizza place. I tried their plain cheese pizza slices and a slice with meats & veggies. I had to add oregano to the cheese slices. I liked the thin texture and the crust was good. I also tried their garlic knots. They were chewy and garlicky. Good!
… more
Tamethya Daivs
We stop in to grab a bite to eat and the food was delicious!! Huge slices of pizza hence the name!! The wings were also delicious as well!! The pineapple voka was good too!! My babygirl loved this place. Will definitely be back!! The people that work there were super friendly and very helpful with helping picking out a pizza to take home!!
… more
Johnny Larson
The worst experience in a long time going to Joeys. The people working served my gal a burnt pizza without the toppings we ordered. Then told her it wasn’t burnt and threw on the missing toppings and burned it further. Didn’t offer a discount but did offer a 2 liter. They offered to remake it, but we ordered it because we are in a rush. Im just miffed at this going out the door. My gal is too nice lol. I worked in a pizza joint for a decade. This would have never seen the outside of the shop.
… more
Brittany A Smith
Our pizza was great. Garlic knots, not so much. They were all burnt on the tops and looked like they were begining to burn on the bottoms. They were also tough to chew. I’ll stick to the pizzas. ETA: I ordered one of their new desserts, apple crumble pie and sadly they forgot the crumble.
… more
Adam Cohen
This place is hit or miss. It seems that they’ve become more generous with their toppings, however the 18″ pizza we just picked up was quite burnt.
… more
… View more