Based on 115 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
Address:
241 S Elm Ave, Eaton, CO 80615
Phone: (970) 454-1300
Social Profile: 
Reviews
Arlen Edsall
The shrimp pizza is the best I have ever had. Amazing food, hand made with fresh ingredients. Great atmosphere with a wide selection of beer and wine makes the whole experience tasteful and fun! Thanks to Troy the owner for being such a great guy whenever we come in.
… more
Cathie Goode
If there was a negative star I would give that!! Gross!! Last time we ordered pizza and it was soggy!!! So we decided that we would try the lasagna. Oh my gosh save your self and get Stoffer’s!! It was horrible!!! At least we have it another shot!! I would never recommend this place to anyone!!! Frozen food is way better and has more flavor!!!
… more
Jason Bank
They were so nice to us! The pizza was soooo full of toppings. It was great! My wife and daughter in law also had a glass of wine, and my son had a beer. Free refills on fountain pop. STRONGLY recommend!
… more
Jeremy Olinger
Pizza has nice small town taste. Let it cool down and firm up, really good. Beer is cold. Would love to go more if there was the ability to watch a sports game or two and drink more beer! Wins all around.
… more
Christopher Gray
I normally would give Justines a 5 rating but I recently told my sisters how great their pizza was and they stopped there in Eaton on their way home from my house in Cheyenne Wyoming and ordered their pizza. My sister said that when they started eating the pizza at home the entire bottom of pizza was burned. Not a good first time experience. I guess they won’t be back. Always had great pizza myself.
… more
Lynne Heidman
We usually are very pleased with their pizza,.but the last time we went( a few days ago) the pizza was barely warm, and the toppings were not cooked through. They tried to reheat it, but still wasn’t their usual good pizza. We will try another time…
… more
Vicki Dixon
Justine’s is hands down the best pizza in Eaton! Handmade, fresh and delicious!! Awesome salads too! My favorite is the Greek salad. Also don’t miss the pasta, sub sandwiches and calzones. Yum!!
… more
EMILY WALLIN
The pizza, as usual, was great. However, when I went in to pick it up, not one single employee was wearing a mask. I was told “It’s Weld County, so we don’t really have to.” That’s actually not true, and I don’t want this to be a political post, but I do want people who care to know masks aren’t being worn. I won’t return until the mandate from the state regarding masks is removed or the employees start wearing them.
… more
Lisa Hudson
We have been going to Justine’s since they opened. Stopped in tonight on my way home and the young girl waitressing smiled and asked how I was doing as I walked in the door. The owner was friendly, as always and the young man behind the counter was very pleasant and efficient. Love the pizza and all you can eat spaghetti night, but nothing beats the staff and their great attitudes!
… more
Heidi Hancock
Amazing pizza and garlic cheese bread! Not greasy at all! My husband and I both loved it and we are hard to please on pizza. Thank you Justine’s Pizza!
… more
… View more