Based on 48 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$
Address:
181 E Innis Ave, Columbus, OH 43207
Phone: (380) 231-8524
Website: https://www.toasttab.com/menu/v3
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jennifer Bergman
Very tasty & good quality food for an affordable price. I got a pepperoni & extra cheese pizza; crispy crust with the right amount of fluffiness from the dough… cheese wasn’t a greasy mess & perfectly melted. Both human & pet approved!
… more
Jimmy Pailin
Tobars slice is a fantastic neighborhood pizzeria and sub shop. The pizzas are delicious. There is only one size, approximately a large, but in addition to the meats typically offered on pizzas, vegetables can be added for free. Good thick chewy cheese on pizzas, so much that you don’t need to order double cheese. And, the subs are also deliciously made. At least in April and May, a porch fire is lit at 8 pm in the evenings adding a wonderful social atmosphere on slightly cool evenings. (Not to worry, it’s one of the new stainless steel smokeless fire pits.)
… more
anthony groce
Willing to go above and behind definitely a amazing vibe not just a a pizza place if you wanna feel like you apart of a family Tobars slice got you
… more
Stacey Hendricks
Good pizza. Great price. Fast service. Welcoming atmosphere. Nice front deck for seating. A pleasant experience all around. I like that it’s a local independent small business with hustle, we need more of these on the Southside.
… more
Shannon Scott
There was an issue with my order & the owner totally made it right. Very good service & a great pie. We tried the payroll. Loved it! Not the usual fare you expect with pizza. You gotta try this!
… more
Nathan Rasmussen
Literally the best pizza around and very welcoming. I will be back again for sure. If you looking for great food this is your place Also highly recommend the “Nate The Great pizza”
… more
Kevin Eble
Great pizza! First time here and will be back soon! This is a local pizza place ran by a local guy who is working hard to build his business the right way! Something that is hard to come by these days! Really impressed! Keep it up!
… more
Samson Heine
I love pizza, and my man Tobar makes a mean pie. This is a small operation, but PLEASE give them a chance. Service was quick and friendly. On top of that, the food is just as good (if not better) than other pizza shops, with equally competitive pricing. I ONLY support local food when it is quality, and this is definitely that. This food is made with pride and love, and it shows! You guys just earned a regular customer. Much love and blessings!
… more
Anthony Hawkins
Great customer service. Pizza was great and was done in a timely manner. Definitely recommend Tobars Slice. 10/10 recommendation. If you’re looking for a great environment that’s the place to be. I love everything on the menu. The owner is very welcoming every time me and my family come in.
… more
Myeka Mcleod
I order a personal pizza. They don’t have a menu. He was kind enough to make it anyway. If you like sweet pizza sauce their pizzas are for you.
… more
… View more