Based on 202 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
19152 Co Rd 46, New Paris, IN 46553
Phone: (574) 831-4160
Website: http://oldtimepizza.wixsite.com/old-time-pizza
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed
Holiday hours
|
| Tuesday | 4–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 4–8 PM |
| Saturday | 4–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Joe Miller
Average. I ordered the Super sandwich, which was like a pizza sandwich. Not impressed. They had absolutely nothing on the walls and for a town known for a Speedway, that was disappointing. Not recommended
… more
Scott Babcock
Great place to eat. Felt relaxing and felt welcomed to stay an eat. My daughter and I loved the pizza!
… more
Christopher
The food was absolutely delicious, but a little pricey…I know the cost of living, overhead, and employee’s, are a little outrageous…but it might bring more business. ???
… more
Adam Storer
Pleasantly surprised by this pizza. Not what I recall from years ago, but a good improvement. I really like the meat pizza and my kids loved the cheese.
… more
Lisa Pires
Not the same as it used to be. The food doesn’t taste the same. My h u stand ordered the pork chop dinner they said they would give him 2 since they were small and he only got one.l
… more
Stephanie Stewart
Very quaint pizza joint but worth the visit. Super friendly owner/staff. Food was hot, fresh, and delicious. I hadn’t been here for years in between and I guess they have new owners but the flavor is still the same as years ago.
… more
Matt Smith
Simply over priced. $35 for a large pizza, it does taste goob… but it’s not worth the cost
… more
Matthew Wagner
Pizza is still decent, but the wait times are outrageous. We waited over an hour for our pizza. A gentleman came in with his parrot and ate in the restaurant and the owner never even batted an eye. I don’t want to be eating next to someone with a bird on their shoulder. That screams unsanitary.
… more
Sharica Speaks
I ordered from work then was unable to leave right away. Old time pizza closed and when I started to leave a message.. the lady answered and stated she had stayed hoping I called and still allowed me to come get my food. I pulled up and it was brought to my car still hot and fresh! Delicious food. Great friendly service! They go the extra mile for the customer! Thank u!
… more
daisy brown
Hubby and I have been going for years always best service and prices! That’s not case anymore! Food sucked definitely changed recipes and prices r crazy. I rather go get a juicy steak for that price! I want the real stumps back!
… more
… View more