Based on 235 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
Address:
1600 W Causeway Approach STE 1, Mandeville, LA 70471
Phone: (985) 778-2371
Website: http://www.thatsamorepizzaonline.com/
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Travis P
We had a party of 4 adults and 3 kids. The appetizers were very good. We ordered a Chicago and a New York style pie. We were very disappointed with both. The crust seemed overdone. It was hard like a rock. I would have been willing to try again just in case there was a new cook or whatever, however…..
… more
Daniel Scheer (MrPhyzyx)
Heard a lot about the deep dish Chicago style pizza… and now I see why! Despite the quoted 45 minute cook time, it was not an issue with great drinks and some buffalo shrimp! We ordered the small 7 inch pizza and took plenty home with us. This is a definite winner!
… more
Harmony Edge
We were roadtripping from Iowa and came across this little pizzeria. Wow. The pizza is amazing. We got the 16in pizza and breadsticks and the 3 of us have leftovers for sure. The food was delicious, fresh, and hot. Our waitress Diane, part owner, was so pleasant and her attention to her customers top notch. The other co-owner was also very attentive chatting with the locals and checking tables.
… more
Pamela Fleitas
I love this place! The staff and the atmosphere was great. the food was unbelievably good!
… more
William Squires
Fantastic!! The Chicago Deep dish is the best pizza I have ever had!!! Did I mention how delicious the Chicago Deep Dish Pizza is?!! The pizza is freshly made, uses real cheese (and lots of it) and probably weighs in at over 5 pound. When you pick up the box it feels much to heavy for a pizza, in a good way. I have only gotten take out from them but every time I pick up my pizza it’s very clean inside and has a friendly vibe to it. Love this place.
… more
Susan Wilke
Delicious!! We got a half & half deep dish pizza. Half meat lovers & half Chicken Alfredo. So delicious!!! The owner is so friendly and helpful. They have Creole Creamery ice cream as well. Definitely go try them out. If you want to, he said you could order ahead & he would have your pizza ready when you get there!
… more
Cori Lee
Went here for the first time ever earlier today. Food was so good and the service was quite lovely! The pretzel pizza was sooo cheesy and the New York style pizza we got was delicious! We are local so we will definitely be back! ❤️
… more
Chris
Tried the original location a few weeks ago and the owner told us this was opening soon. We were happy to see they opened up and were doing dine-in. Went with the family for our son’s birthday dinner. Got a 16″ Supreme and 16″ Shrimp Alfredo pizza. Both of them were New York style. They were soooo good!!! Their prices are good and pizza is excellent! Will definitely be back!
… more
Will
I did a carry out order, I had to make a separate trip to my vehicle with the large New York style pizza because… It’s large, like really large.. The Chicago deep dish is legit!! Salads are big! Overall 10 out of 10. Would recommend and will be returning.. often!
… more
Frederick Hernandez
Slop. Crust was soft cheese slid off half the pizza. Very disappointing! Can’t reheat the leftovers Wasted $44 dollars
… more
… View more