Since 1945, three generations of the Penzone family have brought you authentic Italian cuisine and family tradition. We are excited to continue the legacy in a new form, a cloud kitchen. We use the same recipes to offer many of our original restaurant’s classics such as homemade spaghetti and meatballs, lasagna, fettuccine alfredo, picnic salad, and more! Customers have the option of ordering from their favorite delivery service or directly from our website for pickup. We are excited to be serving Columbus again!
Based on 18 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
Address:
1282 Essex Ave, Columbus, OH 43201
Phone: (614) 937-0240
Website: https://www.florentinelegacy.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Reviews
MRBARBQ 1
Decided to order from the Florentine last night. Very easy to order from DoorDash. Ordered the spaghetti with mushroom sauce. The pasta was nice and firm noodles, the sauce had tons of tomatoes in it, not a watery sauce. Fresh mushrooms that were luscious. Great seasoning. Could have ate another serving easily. Brought back memories from the restaurant. Yummmy!!! Don’t miss out, check them out.
… more
Bystander M
DoorDash kitchen. Much better than Olive Garden. Classic Italian food in the comfort of home. Would love to see desserts added.
… more
Tina T
We ordered for pickup on Wednesday. The order was correct — lasagna, spaghetti with meatballs, eggplant parmigiana and breadsticks. The lasagna was good and the eggplant itself was good. The spaghetti and the pasta that came with the eggplant was so over cooked, it was as if someone put it in and left for a 3-minute break before returning to get the pasta out. It was gummy and inedible. The breadsticks were unremarkable. The two stars are for the sauce, lasagna and eggplant. We will not return. Literally the worst pasta we have ever had in our lives. Save your money!
… more
Tim Kazee
1st time ordering. Ordered the manicotti, meatball, Alfredo with grilled chicken and mushrooms and cheesy bread. OMG! YES! Absolutely will be back. We have found our Italian joint close to home.
… more
Asia Luft
WOW is all I can say! I was blown away by how amazing ALL of the food was. Ordered through DoorDash and everything was still hot and so fresh! Some of the best Italian I’ve ever had.
… more
Chris Huda
I don’t know if Florentine served fettuccine noodles as spaghetti, or frozen chixn parm Patty’s, so 2 strikes there, but the sauce and meatballs were good.
… more
Jennifer Mott
We did the pick up option. Food was just as we have remembered and very tasty, however, not a great value. Portion of the meal itself was decent, but smaller than we remembered. Bread/salad are not included with each meal. I don’t mind paying if it’s something special, but it was a toasted frozen bread stick with an herbed butter mixture brushed on. The salad was 1/2 cup of pre-mixed salad mix (iceberg lettuce, carrots, red cabbage) with their homemade dressing. Unfortunately with the way it was packaged (salad in a thin deli salad contain in the same bag/on top of hot food) the salad was cooked by the time we got it home and limp/soggy. If we are feeling REALLY nostalgic, we’ll be back, but not at that price/value.
… more
dug
Delicious, good portions, unique flavors. I asked for a little extra sauce (they have very tasty sauce) and said it was ok if there was an upcharge. They gave me a container of sauce on the side for no charge. Quality, value, and kindness. You love to see it
… more
Georgina Whalen
One of our favorite places for a delicious dinner. I love their salad, breadsticks, meatballs, chicken Parm, and chicken Parm bites! Delicious food that is consistent and just what we crave.
… more
A LS
Food was great, had it delivered and it was still on point! Lasagna was amazing!
… more
… View more
