San Cristobal Menu – Middletown, NY

Type : Mexican restaurant

Location : Middletown, NY

Based on 298 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

San Cristobal 10940

Address:
52 Cottage St, Middletown, NY 10940

Phone: (845) 775-4373

Website:

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday Closed
Thursday 11 AM–9 PM
Friday 11 AM–9 PM
Saturday 11 AM–10 PM
Sunday 11 AM–9 PM
Monday 11 AM–9 PM

Menu

Botanas / Appetizers
Guacamole $8.00
Pico De Gallo $8.00
Cheese Quesadilla $9.00
Chicken Quesadilla $11.95
Beef Quesadilla $13.95
Nachos Regulares $9.99
Nachos Con Carne $14.99
Coctel De Camarones / Shrimp Cocktail $13.95
Ceviche De Camarones / Shrimp Ceviche $14.95
Ceviche De Tilapia / Tilapia Ceviche $11.95
Coctel Vuelve A La Vida $12.95
Aguacate Relleno De Camarones / Avocado Stuffed With Shrimp $11.95
Sopas / Soup
Chicken, Squash & Carrots $9.99
Sopa De Camaron / Shrimp Soup $14.95
Sopa De Mariscos / Seafood Soup $17.95
Pozole Con Carne De Puerco $12.95
Panza De Res $12.95
Sopes
Sopes (3)
Frijoles, lechuga, queso y crema & your choice of meat / carne: bistec, chorizo, tinga de pollo, quesillo, chicharron, cecina, longaniza, pollo.		 $11.99
Huaraches / Corn Tortillas
Res / Sautéed Steak $5.99
Pollo / Chicken $5.99
Longaniza / Spicy Pork Sausage $5.99
Cecina / Flank Steak $5.99
Carne Enchilada / Pork Enchilada $5.99
3 Picadas Con Salsa Roja O Verdes Con Cecina O Carne Enchilada, Etc $11.99
Tostadas / Hard Tortillas
Regular $2.99
Pollo / Chicken Tostadas $4.99
Bistec / Steak Tostadas $4.99
Tinga / Stewed Chicken $4.99
Quesillo / Cheese Tostada $4.99
Enchilada / Spicy Pork $4.99
Camarones / Shrimp Ceviche $6.99
Ensaladas / Salad
Ensalada De Nopales / Cactus Salad $8.99
Ensalada De Camarones / Shrimp Salad $16.99
Ensalada De Pollo / Grilled Chicken Salad $13.99
Ensalada De Pollo Empanizado / Crispy Mexican Chicken Salad $13.99
Tacos Placeros
Tacos Placeros / Homemade Starters $9.50
Chile Relleno / Stuffed Pepper Taco $9.50
Longaniza / Spicy Pork Sausage Taco $9.50
Longaniza Con Papa $9.50
Cecina Con Papa $9.50
Chorizo Con Papa $9.50
Milanesa / Res – Breaded Steak / Chicken $9.50
Huevo Hervido / Hard Boiled Egg $8.50
Tacos Dorados / Hard Shell Tacos
Pollo / Chicken Taquitos (4) $7.99
Chorizo / Spicy Pork Sausage (4) $7.99
Papa / Potato Taquitos (4) $7.99
Queso / Cheese Taquitos (4) $7.99
Quesadillas de Maiz
Regulares Quesadillas
Flor de calabaza, huiclacache, champiñones, calabazita.		 $8.50
Quesadillas De Carne
Bistec, chorizo, tinga de pollo, quesillo, chicharron, cecina, longaniza, pollo.		 $10.00
Quesadillas De Camarones De Maiz $13.00
Quesadilla De Camarones De Harina $14.95
Gorditas De Chicharrones $11.99
Molotes $4.99
Tortas
Torta De Jamon / Ham $9.99
Torta De Milanesa De Res / Breaded Steak $10.99
Torta De Milanesa De Pollo / Breaded Chicken $10.99
Torta De Carnitas / Pork
Served with cilantro and onions with radish, onion, salsa & green salsa.		 $11.99
Torta De Bistec / Steak $10.99
Torta Cecina / Flank Steak $10.99
Torta Cubana / Cuban $15.99
Torta Hawaiana / Hawaiian $12.99
Tortas Campechanas
Choice of meat: al pastor, carnitas, cueritos, carne enchilada.		 $14.99
Torta Campechana De Lengua $16.99
Soft Tacos
Tacos Al Pastor / Marinated Pork $3.50
Tacos De Carnitas / Pork $3.50
Tacos De Longaniza / Spicy Pork Sausage $3.50
Tacos De Cueritos / Pork Rinds $3.50
Tacos De Lengua / Beef Tongue $4.25
Tacos De Pollo / Chicken $3.50
Tacos De Res / Sautéed Steak $3.50
Tacos De Chorizo $3.50
Tacos De Cecina $3.50
Burritos
Burritos De Pollo / Chicken $10.99
Burrito De Res / Beef $10.99
Burrito De Carnitas / Pork $10.99
Burrito De Carne Adovada / Spicy Pork $10.99
Burrito De Lengua / Beef Tongue $12.99
Burrito De Chorizo / Mexican Sausage $10.99
Burrito De Vegetales / Vegetables $8.99
Burrito De Nopales / Cactus $8.99
Burrito Grande (Chicken / Steak) $14.99
Burrito Grande San Cristobal / Shrimp $16.99
Cemitas
Cemita Especial / Special
Milanesa de res, jamon y queso / Steak, ham & cheese.		 $12.99
Cemita Milanesa De Res / Breaded Steak $11.99
Cemita Milanesa De Pollo / Breaded Chicken $11.99
Cemita De Carnitas / Pork
Cilantro y cebolla / Cilantro & onions.		 $12.99
Cemita De Carne Enchilada / Spicy Pork $12.99
Cemita De Bistec / Steak $12.99
Cemita Cubana / Cuban
Jamon, carne enchilada / Ham and spicy pork.		 $16.99
Cemitas Campechanas
Choice of meat: al pastor, carnitas, cueritos, carne enchilada.		 $15.99
Cemita Campechana De Lengua $16.99
Entradas / Entrées
Pollo Borracho
Chicken breast sautéed with garlic, onions, green pepper, red peppers and jalapeños in tequila.		 $14.99
Pollo San Cristobal
Grilled chicken, chorizo, nopalitos, onions & slices of jalapeños.		 $16.99
Pollo Poblano
Grilled chicken with slices of poblano peppers, corn & mushrooms.		 $16.99
Milanesa De Pollo / Breaded Chicken $14.99
Bistec San Cristobal
Steak accompanied by chorizo, cactus, cambray onions & sliced jalapeños.		 $19.99
Mexicucho
Steak and shrimp a la diabla.		 $21.99
Bistec Poblano
Steak with shrimp, onions, mushrooms, jalapeños & grated mozzarella cheese.		 $21.99
Platillo De Pollo Asado $14.99
Milanesa De Res
Breaded steak.		 $15.99
Bistec Azteca
Steak split in half, stuffed with Mexican cheese, onions, mushrooms and special sauce.		 $16.99
Tampiqueña
Grilled beef, with cambray onions, delicious cactus and jalapeños. Add shrimp for an additional charge. 		$19.99
Chuletas De Cerdo Encebolladas
Pork chops with onions.		 $14.99
Chuletas En Salsa Verde
Pork chops in green sauce.		 $15.99
Chicharron En Salsa Verde O Roja
Fried pig skin on green or red sauce.		 $10.95
Especiales de La Casa / House Specialties
Chimichangas
Beef or chicken rolled in a flour tortilla & fried to pastry flakiness, garnished with guacamole and sour cream.		 $13.99
Bistec A La Mexicana
Steak sautéed in garlic, cooked with tomatoes, onions & peppers seasoned with jalapeño.		 $16.99
2 Chiles Rellenos / 2 Stuffed Peppers & Cheese $16.99
Carne Asada
Steak well frilled with chambray onions & delicious nopalitos cactus.		 $16.99
Mole Poblano
Chicken breast with mole sauce.		 $15.99
Cecina Mexicana
Grilled flank steak marinated in lemon with cambray onions, cactus and jalapeños.		 $16.99
Chilaquiles
Fried tortilla covered with salsa roja (red) o Verde (green), cheese and sour cream with your choice of Cecina, carne enchilada or eggs etc.		 $13.99
Enchiladas (Red / Green / Mole Poblano)
Soft corn tortilla filled with chicken breast or steak bathed in your choice of sauce (red / green / mole poblano), lettuce, cheese, sour cream, onion, radish & avocado.		 $13.99
Enchiladas Vegetarianas
Soft corn tortilla filled with poblano peppers & corn with choice of salsa roja (red), verde (green) or mole poblano.		 $12.99
Enchiladas Suizas
Chicken flour tortilla with green sauce.		 $14.99
Enchiladas De Camaron, Verdes O Rojas $18.99
Huevos En Salsa Verde O Roja $10.95
Platos Fuertes / Main Dishes
Fausto Especial
Bistec, camarones, cebolla cambray, jalapeño, nopal y vejetales soteados / Steak, shrimp, cambray onions, jalapeños, cactus and sautéed vegetables. 		$24.99
Janeth Especial
Pechuga de pollo, camarones, chorizo, cebolla cambray, jalapeños, nopal y vejetables sarteados / Grilled chicken, shrimp, spicy sausage, cambray onions, jalapeños, cactus and sautéed vegetables. 		$24.99
Chilo Especial
Bistec, pechuga de pollo, chorizo, queso frito, cebolla cambray, jalapeños, nopal y guacamole / Steak, grilled chicken, spicy sausage, fried cheese, cambray onion, jalapeños, cactus and guacamole.		 $28.99
Giovanni Especial
Steak with shrimp, onions & mushrooms. served with sour cream & guacamole.		 $21.99
Platillo Campesino
Bistec, chorizo, carne enchilada, queso frito arroz, frijoles, nopales, chile toriado y cebollitas / Steak, mexican sausace, marinated pork, fried cheese rice, beans cactus leaves, chile and cebollitas.		 $29.99
Platillo El Patron
Chuleta, queso frito, chile relleno, bistec, arroz frijoles, nopal, chile toreado y cebollitas / Steak, pork chop, chorizo, fried cheese, rice, beans, cactus leaves, chile & cebollitas.		 $29.99
Fajitas
Fajitas De Bistec / Steak Fajita $16.99
Fajitas De Chicken $15.99
Fajitas De Shrimp $18.99
Fajitas Mixtas
Chicken, shrimp & steak fajitas marinate with homemade seasoning, sliced of onions, mushrooms, red & green peppers.		 $25.99
Mariscos / Seafood
Mojarra Frita / Whole Fried Fish
Servido con arroz y ensalada de la huerta. / served with rice and garden salad.		 $17.99
Mojarra Al Mojo De Ajo
Tilapia seasoned with special garlic salsa.		 $17.99
Filete A La Diabla / Tilapia Fillet
Servido con arroz y ensalada de la huerta. / served with rice and garden salad.		 $16.99
Filete Asado / Grilled Tilapia Fillet
Servido con arroz y ensalada de la huerta. / served with rice and garden salad.		 $16.99
Camarones A La Mexicana $16.99
Camarones En Salsa Verde $16.99
Camarones A La Diabla / Shrimp A La Diabla
Servido con arroz y ensalada de la huerta. / served with rice and garden salad.		 $17.99
Camarones Al Mojo De Ajo
Shrimp sautéed in butter with garlic.		 $16.99
Camarones Empanizados / Breaded Shrimp
Servido con arroz y ensalada de la huerta. / served with rice and garden salad.		 $16.99
Camarones Enchipotlados
Shrimp bathed in delicious chipotle salsa.		 $16.99
Camarones Borrachos
Shrimp with green peppers, red peppers, onions & jalapeños in tequila.		 $16.99
Taco De Pescado / Fish Taco (3) $15.99
Taco De Camarones / Shrimp Taco (3) $15.85
Combinaciones / Combos
Taco, Chimichanga, Burrito
Servido con arroz y judías. / served with rice and beans.		 $15.99
Taco, Burrito, Enchilada
Servido con arroz y judías. / served with rice and beans.		 $15.99
Taco, Enchilada, Chile Relleno
Servido con arroz y judías. / served with rice and beans.		 $17.99
Enchilada Suiza, Enchilada, Chile Relleno $17.99
Plato Vegetariano
Cheese enchilada, cheese chile relleno, tostada regular.		 $15.99
Postres / Desserts
3 Leches Cake $6.95
Flan Napolitano / Neapolitan Flan $6.95
Flan De Chocolate / Chocolate Flan $6.95
Helado / Ice Cream
Vanilla, strawberry, chocolate or mixed.		 $4.99
Pastel De Chocolate / Chocolate Cake $6.99
Bacon Cheeseburger
Bacon Cheeseburger $9.99
Side Order
Crema / Sour Cream $2.00
Aguacate 1/2 $3.50
Arroz / Rice $3.95
Frijoles / Beans $3.95
Papas Fritas / French Fries $4.95
Arroz Y Frijoles / Rice & Beans $5.99
Chile Toreado $5.95
Cebollitas $5.95
Nopales $5.95
Chile Toreado, Nopales Y Cebollitas $10.95
Guacamole (Small) $2.00
Ensalada $3.95
Vegetales Sorteados $5.95
Menu de Niños / Kids Menu
Chicken Fingers With Fries $7.99
Mozzarella Sticks With Fries $7.99
Mini Burritos $7.99
2 Chicken Tacos With Rice & Beans $10.99
2 Steak Tacos With Rice & Beans $11.95
Cheese Quesadilla With Fries $7.99
Cheeseburger With Fries $7.99
Bebidas / Drinks
Refrescos Mexicanos / Mexican Drinks
Jarritos, sidral, coca cola, sangria, fanta, squirt.		 $3.25
Boing De Mango / Mango Boing $3.25
Boing De Guava / Guava Boing $3.25
Aguas Frescas / Flavored Water
Jamaica, horchata, tamarindo, melon, piña, fresa, mango.		 $4.75

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

J
Small hole in the restaurant with the most delicious food. The staff is very nice and helpful. Definitely will be going back.

… more

Lois Munoz
Stopped eating here some time ago due to poor service. Decided to try again and nothing has changed. It’s a shame because food is decent.

… more

Paulo Trevisani
This cozy, unassuming Mexican restaurant was the nicest surprise.

… more

Erica
The food was delicious and the atmosphere was very cozy. Our server was incredibly patient and friendly. This is definitely a place I would recommend.

… more

Marcel Welty
Really delicious, great friendly staff, and fair prices. Warm atmosphere. Great find

… more

Iris D
One of my favorite restaurants in Middletown, we order from San Cristobal at least 2x a week. Their food is amazingly delicious, always fresh & their staff is super accommodating. We love their Pozole which comes with 2 regular tostadas which are quiet delightful. The Pozole is fresh, the broth has a nice thickness to it & the seasoning is always on point. Their variety of tacos placeros is plentiful, one of our favorite is Papas con Chorizo & extra fried hot peppers.

… more

C Concepcion
Their Torta Cubana is the best sandwich in town.

… more

Jason Rodriguez
This is my fave Mexican spot in Middletown. They have great portions and there agua frescas are fantastic! Pricing is fair also!

… more

ry chav
Love the food, shrimp ceviche is my fav, delicious and consistent unlike other places in town. The chicken chimchanga is great and their tamarind water is rich in flavor. Wish they delivered cause I don’t drive.

… more

panther santiago
authentic Mexican food, the best in the area, excellent service

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch