Based on 128 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
Address:
220 E Wall St, Eagle River, WI 54521
Phone: (715) 477-1111
Website: http://www.butchs-pizza-north.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Derek Schultz
Nice, friendly, and fast service. Pizza was good, but there was just something off about the taste. Don’t know if it was the sauce or not, but wasn’t necessarily bad, as I still enjoyed my pizza. Conveniently located right on Eagle Rivers downtown strip.
… more
Dennis S
I could give them one third of a star. If you’re not local?Do not buy pizza here. We bought pizza for a large group. (10 pizzas). When we got back and opened? A couple were burned. They were poorly labeled and we couldn’t even tell which was which. (See photos) They were marked in code. Worst of all when I got back home I reviewed the bill and their prices online. We got overcharged by $25 or $30. The pizzas didn’t even taste that good. Our young man were starving and ate them without much comment except ” these aren’t too good”. New employees? Wrong temperature in the oven? Who knows. If we ever have to order here again I’m going to check everything before I leave the door, check the bill and make sure they use a marker to label which is which. Doubt I will make that mistake again.
… more
Gary Behling
I never thought I would find my favorite thin crust pizza 2,400 miles from home. I’m partly serious here, but in a way I would almost be willing to leave my home in Tucson, and move to Eagle River just so I could eat Butch’s Pizza every day. We always order our pizza well done and eat it there. You know how pizza is if you take it home and Butch’s is so special, we eat it there. Sometimes we will get another to go. Order it your way, it still will be one of the very best pizzas (if not THEE best) thin crust pizza you’ve ever eaten.
… more
Michael Carter
28.00 for a large pepperoni pizza 85.00 total bill for 3 large pizzas… absolute price gouging establishment…. He says prices have gone up.. not that much… the meat lovers pizza that was over 30.00 had maybe 1 piece of bacon broken up on it 6 little pieces of sausage and maybe 6 pepperoni’s on it… the supreme that was also over 30.00 barely had any vegetables or meat on it it literally looked like a cheese pizza…. Owner says oh your from Illinois… yes and we are the reason you are in business….. no local is paying 85.00 for 3 large pizzas with less than half the topping that should be on a normally priced pizza… I recommend not using this business….
… more
David Sterne
We’ve done take take out for well over a decade. This time we had the fire alarm, hand tossed and garlic cheese bread. They’re still running as cari out but only like 2 or so tables inside. You pull in, they come out for payment, when pizza done it comes out. If it’s nice out and you want to eat outside, not going home, the rotary club put a nice little park in on wall st a block away, where an old service station was in down town.
… more
Panther Platform
I’ve ordered the same medium hand tossed sausage and pepperoni pizza with onions, mushrooms and tomatoes half a dozen times and the pizza arrived at my apartment right away and was still very hot. The quality of the ingredients is exceptional compared to most pizza serving establishments, pizza hut RIP, especially the sausage. Nothing bricks a perfectly good pizza like inadequately processed sausage. I walked down there earlier to order the pizza and walked back to get it 25 minutes later from my apartment half a block from Butch’s and it was so delicious that I had to bust out a compliment with minor nano-aggressions but no micro-agressions despite it being the eve of memorial day. This definitely ain’t no little caesars. I don’t care what it costs as long as it’s good AF.
… more
Michael “Kory” Woods
Good pizza/calzones; fast, very friendly delivery — even if you might feel snowed in! It seems the meatballs may have changed in the past year, though — they used to be larger.
… more
Cody Brewington
Pizza is severly overpriced for a below average pie. I’ve had better Jack’s frozen pizza’s. Not to mention the gentlemen who brought our pizza out was rude and had no customer service skills.
… more
David Wilke
Excellent pizza, fast service, would give them 6 stars if I could. Prices are reasonable and toppings are plentiful. Sauce is mild, not too spicy. Can always add some heat if that’s what you like but our crew likes it mild. Nothing worse than spicy if you like mild. You can add heat but you can’t remove it. Theirs is perfect. Highly recommended.
… more
Schuyler Bishop
We loved the pizza! We’re in town for some late season snowmobiling and got in later and wanted a quick dinner. Their veggie thin crust with extra cheese was perfect, delicious and we ate a whole large. Loved it!
… more
… View more